경험적 법률가 연구의 발전을 위하여 - 이호선의 「법과 정책연구」 글에 대한 검토와 제언

이준웅 ( Une-woong Rhee ),이재협 ( Jae-hyup Lee ) 한국법정책학회 2016 법과 정책연구 Vol.16 No.2

이 글은 이호선 교수가 < 법과 정책연구 > 제15집 제4호에 게재한 "한국 로스쿨 체제, 과연 사법시험의 대안인가?"라는 글을 비판적으로 검토한다. 첫째, 이호선의 글은 연구목적이 불분명하며, 연구문제가 부재하며, 결론을 정당화하기 위한 방법과 결과가 충분하지 않은 등 경험적 학술논문으로서의 기본요건을 갖추지 못하고 있다. 특히 이호선의 글을 선의로 해석해서 이재협 등의 연구에 대한 재현연구를 시도한 것으로 보더라도 연구의 재현성 여부를 평가할 수 있는 필수적인 방법론을 제시하지 않고 있으며, 재현연구가 갖추어야 할 최소한의 방법론적 기초를 구비하지 않고 있다. 둘째, 이호선의 글은 표집이론, 모집단, 표집틀 등 사회과학적 표본조사 연구에 사용되는 기본적인 개념을 혼동하고 있으며, 모집단과 표본 간의 상위성에 대해 오해를 보인다. 셋째, 이호선의 글에는 이재협 등의 연구에 대한 해석적 오해를 담고 있다. 특히 사법연수원 출신 법률가와 로스쿨 졸업 법률가 간 가구소득의 차이를 비교함에 있어서 비교시점을 상이하게 설정하는 등 오류를 범한다. 결론적으로 이 글은 법학교육제도와 법률직역의 구조가 급격히 변화하고 있는 상황에서 경험적 자료축적을 통한 실증연구가 필요함을 주장하며, 향후 법학과 인접학문이 공동연구를 활성화해야 함을 제안한다. This article critically reviews the paper written by Professor Lee Ho-Sun, "Korean Law School System, Is it really an alternative to Judicial Exam?", which was published in the Law and Policy Review, Vol. 15, Nov. 4. First, Lee Ho-Sun``s paper lacks basic requirements for an empirical scholarly article: (1) the research purpose is unclear, (2) the research questions are not provided, and (3) the methods and outcomes do not sufficiently support conclusions. Even if Lee Ho-Sun``s paper can be regarded as a replication study of Jae-Hyup Lee et. al.``s research, it does not provide necessary methods to assess its replicability. In addition, the paper is not equipped with minimum methodological foundations. Second, Lee Ho-Sun``s paper confuses basic concepts in social scientific sampling studies (e.g., sampling theory, population, sampling frame), and does not correctly interpret the difference between parameters and statistics. Third, Lee Ho-Sun``s paper contains many interpretive misunderstandings of Jae-Hyup Lee et. al.``s research. For example, in interpreting the household income differences between the graduates of the Judicial Research and Training Institute and the graduates of law schools, Lee Ho-Sun sets a different time frame than that used in Jae-Hyup Lee``s research. This article advocates that more empirical studies are needed to adequately assess the rapid changes in the legal educational system and the structure of the legal profession in Korea, and to that end, that more interdisciplinary research collaboration is necessary.

서초동(서울시 서초구)의 거미상

김주필(Joo Pil Kim),정혜리(Hye ri Jeong),김대희(Dae Hee Kim),박동우(Dong Woo Park),서재웅(Jae Woong Seo),이현우(Hyun woo Lee) 한국거미연구소 2017 한국거미 Vol.33 No.1

2016년 3월 31일부터 7월 31일까지 서울특별시 서초구 서초동에 위치한 서울고등학교 교정 일대를 서울고등학교 환경생물부 부원들이 채집 조사한 결과 20과 43속 53종의 거미가 조사 연구되어 이에 보고하는 바이다. From March 31st to July 31st in 2016, members of an environmental biology club at Seoul High School located in Seocho-gu, Seoul, Dae-Hee Kim, Dong-Woo Park, Jae-Woong Seo and Hyun-woo Lee, collected 20 families 43 genera 53 species of spiders and report the result of the study here.

고순도 투광성 알루미나 Yarn Guide의 제조 및 특성

이승환,나상웅,이재형 영남대학교 공업기술연구소 2000 工業技術硏究所論文集 Vol.28 No.1

High purity translucent alumina yam guides were fabricated by injection molding. The green density was 54% of the theoretical after injection molding and debinding. Heat treatment in an argon atmosphere at 1750℃ for 5h to obtain translucency resulted in huge grain sizes in the specimens. Therefore, isostatical hot pressing was necessary for translucency and fine microstructure. After presintering in an oxygen atmosphere at 1550℃ for 5h followed by isostatical hot pressing at 1600℃ for 1h, the translucent alumina was highly dense, over 99.9% of the theoretical, and had 5 to 10㎛ size grains with a high hardness of 14.1GPa. The color was slightly dark due to the carbon atmosphere in the hot isostatic press, however, it would not affect the performance as yarn guides. Owing to the ultra high density, high hardness and fine microstructure, the isostatically hot pressed yarn guides would satisfy the requirements for the application in the high-speed textile machine.

남녀별 음주율 현황과 음주와 관련된 요인분석

이지전,이상욱,송재석,박웅섭 關東大學校 醫科大學 醫科學硏究所 2003 關東醫大學術誌 Vol.7 No.1

In this study, drinking prevalence and the factors associated with drinking by gender were investigated. A cross-sectional study was conducted from 22 April to 3 May in 2002. 1000 subjects(301 females and 699 males) aged 13 to 59 were personally interviewed by trained interviewers. Data on socio-demographic characteristics, drinking related behaviors and health behaviors of subjects were collected. Among females, 191(63.5%) subjects were drinkers and preferred beverage was beer. Drinkers were likely to be 30-39 year-old, employed, religionless, smokers and metropolitan city residents. Among males, 579(82.8%) subjects were drinkers and preferred beverage was Soju. Drinkers were likely to be 19-29 year-old, religionless, jobless, smokers and county residents. After adjusting for various confounders, age, religion and smoking were statistically significantly related to drinking. Smoker(Odds ratio=2.68 females, 2.77 males) and catholic-buddhist(OR=1.51 female, 3.83 males) had higher drinking risk than non-smoker and protestant. County residents had borderline significantly lower drinking risks(OR=0.50) than metropolitan city residents among females.

Prednisolone과 Prednisone의 임상약동학적 평가

신재국,윤영란,차인준,이경훈,장인진,신상구,박찬웅 大韓臨床藥理學會 1994 臨床藥理學會誌 Vol.2 No.1

Permalloy자성박막의 이온빔 에칭에 관한 연구

이환철,양재웅,안재우 대진대학교 1995 大眞論叢 Vol.3 No.-

The etching characteristics of r.f.-sputtered permalloy magnetic thin films using ion beam apparatus are investigated. The process parameters investigated during ion beam etching are accelerating voltage, beam voltage and beam current. The etch rate of the permalloy films is proportion to the beam current, but it is not directly related to the accelerating voltage and beam voltage. The dependence of etch rate on the process parameters can be explained by the ion beam current density. It is found that the ion beam etching is on effective method in obtaining well-developed micropatterns on the permalloy thin films.

人蔘根 腐病發生에 미치는 病原과 線蟲의 關聯性

李敏雄,申鉉成,沈在郁 동국대학교 1985 論文集 Vol.24 No.-

4 roots of 2 year old ginseng were planted in a small pot trateing with fungal pathogens, Fusarium solani, nematodes isolated from the ginseng (Panax ginseng C.A. Meyer) cultured soil and the two mixed inoculum respectively. Rate of infestation and nematodes distributed around the harvested host plant after 40 days was investigated. To obtained results were as follows: Each group was treated with F. solani, nematodes and mixed inoculum showed higher disease index by infestation from 3.3 to 3.8 while control group was healthy showing lower disease index of 1.2. The nematodes identified were 4 genera in control group and F. Solani inoculated group. 11 genera of nematodes including Xiphinema spp were distributed in the nematodes inoculated pot, and their numbers were higher in the population. Especially Radophalus spp, Tylenchulus spp, Meloidogyne spp, Xiphinema spp and Ditylenchus spp were numerous in their population density, but Belonolimus spp and Hemicyciophora spp were lower. Fourteen genera of nematodes were distributed in the mixed inoculation pot than only the nematodes treated group. and also the population was higher in the mixed inoculation group. The more populated genera is number were Ditylenchus spp, Paratylenchus spp, Paratylenchus spp. Hemicycliophora spp, Meloidogyne spp, Helicotylenchus spp and Tylenchorhynchus spp, but Hirschmanniella spp was less in the population density.

백서의 일과성 국소허혈-재괄류 모델에서 U-74389G와 MK-801이 뇌경색 크기에 미치는 효과

김재일,김종민,양대웅,이근호,윤병우,노재규,이상복 대한신경과학회 1999 대한신경과학회지 Vol.17 No.1

진단 초음파를 이용한 정상 성인의 정중신경 측정

이정아,임길병,이홍재,정웅태,황현오 최신의학사 2003 最新醫學 Vol.46 No.11-12

人蔘이 닭의 血中葡萄糖 및 遊離脂肪酸濃度에 미치는 影響

李神雄,李載欣,黃炳斗,琴基昌 충남대학교 의과대학 지역사회의학연구소 1974 충남의대잡지 Vol.1 No.1

Effect of Panax Ginseng on the plasma glucose and free fatty acid levels of the normal chicken and experimentally induced-hyperglycemic chicken, and on the release of glucose and glycogen contents in the chicken liver slices was investigated. 1) Plasma glucose levels was not influenced, but plasma FFA level decreased significantly by intravenous administration of Panax Ginseng in the normal chicken. 2) Epinephrine-induced hyperglycemic and hyperlipemic response and hyperglycemia induced by pancreatic ligation were inhibited by Panax Ginseng, and in the glucose tolerance test, Ginseng shortened the recovery time to normal glucose level. 3) In the chicken liver slices, Panax Ginseng inhibited the release of glucose from the specimen, but did not affect glycogen contents of the tissue.