A Comparative Analysis of Urban Redevelopment from the Viewpoint of Ethical Redevelopment: Seoul’s Cheonggyecheon and the New York High Line

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Linear redevelopment has become more common in recent decades, especially on expensive real estate that is attractive for development. However, advocates may push forward because of the value.
Such projects may arouse strong sentiment among the public and are not easy contained to a single geographic area. All of this makes evaluation more difficult. The principles of ethical redevelopment are being used for redevelopment in the US and have been used in one Korean study to evaluate the qualitative traits of Seoul’s Seoullo 7017. This study used more detailed qualitative data to evaluate and compare Seoul’s Cheonggyecheon and New York’s High Line. The study calculated qualitative scene data from 665 High Line amenities and 1703 Cheonggyecheon amenities photographed on site in the first half of 2016. The scene sub-dimensions were matched to the ethical redevelopment principles and the scene scores were compared. Neither project was a complete match with the ethical redevelopment model, with the Cheonggyecheon only having a partial match for two of nine traits and the High Line partially matching five of nine traits. Ethical redevelopment shows potential for further qualitative evaluation of urban projects, especially large and linear projects that are not compact.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최근희, "서울시의 청계천복원정책과 영국 런던 도크랜드 재개발정책에 관한 비교연구" 한국도시행정학회 21 (21): 291-313, 2008

2 Wang, Hyejin, "Yunrijeog Jaegaebal Gwanjeomeseo Seoulyeog Gogi 7017 Saeob Bunseog" 23 : 75-90, 2016

3 Florida, Richard, "Who’s Your City?" Basic Books/Perseus 2008

4 Chad Anderson, "Urban scenes and urban development in Seoul : three cases viewed from a scene perspective" 인천대학교 대학원 2011

5 Lim, Heeji, Kim, "Urban Regeneration and Gentrification:Land Use Impacts of the Cheonggye Stream Restoration Project on the Seoul̓s Central Business District" 39 : 192-200, 2013

6 Florida, Richard, "The Urban Crisis" Basic Books/Perseus 2017

7 Spates, James L, "The Sociology of Cities" St Martin’s Press 1982

8 Florida, Richard, "The Rise of the Creative Class" Basic Books/Perseus 2002

9 Lee, Jong Youl, "The Restored Cheonggyecheon and the Quality of Life in Seoul" 20 (20): 3-22, 2013

10 Blum, Alan, "The Imaginative Structure of the City" McGill-Queen’s University Press 2003

11 Lynch, Kevin, "The Image of the City" MIT Press 1982

12 James Corner Field Operations, and Diller Scofidio + Renfro, "The High Line" Phaidon 2015

13 Clark, Terry Nichols, "The City as an Entertainment Machine" Elsevier 2004

14 Judd, Dennis R., "The City Revisited: Urban Theory from Chicago" University of Minnesota Press 2011

15 Byun, Miree, "Seoul Ssin (Scenes) Jido Gagseongeul Tonghan Seoul Gonggagteugseonghwa Jeonlyag Yeongu: Map of ‘Seoul Scenes’ and Its Use for Space Characterization" Seoul Development Institute 2010

16 Silver, Daniel Aaron, "Scenescapes: How Qualities of Place Shape Social Life" University of Chicago Press 2016

17 Irwin, John, "Scenes" Sage 1978

18 Grêt-Regamey, Adrienne, "River rehabilitation as an opportunity for ecological landscape design" 20 : 142-146, 2016

19 Place Lab, "Place Lab"

20 Davies, Jonathan, "Partnerships and Regimes" Ashgate Press 2001

21 LaFarge, Annik, "On the Highline" Thames and Hudson 2012

22 Place Lab, "National Initiative to ‘Reimagine the Civic Commons’ Selects Chicago for $5 Million Grant"

23 David, Joshua, "Highline: The Inside Story of New York City’s Park in the Sky" Farrar, Straus and Giroux 2011

24 Place Lab, "Harris School of Public Policy" University of Chicago 2015

25 Knudsen, Brian B., "Examining Walking, Politics and the Arts in Three Countries: The Relevance of Walking for Social Movements and Arts Activities in the U.S., Canada, and France" 2 (2): 41-59, 2015

26 Place Lab, "Ethical Redevelopment: Arts + Culture Build Cities"

27 Gates, Theaster, "Ethical Redevelopment Convening. Logan Center for the Performing Arts" University of Chicago 2016

28 Clark, Terry Nichols, "Can Tocqueville Karaoke? Global Contrasts of Citizen Participation, the Arts and Development" Emerald 2014

29 Silver, Daniel, Clark, "A Theory of Scenes"

30 Park, Myong Hyun, "A Study on the Successful Conflict Management Process of the Cheonggyecheon Restoration Project: Focused on the Negotiations between the Seoul Metropolitan Government and Merchant Groups" 12 (12): 3-50, 2006