The Illusion of Thinking in Metacognitive Monitoring of University Students

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The article is based on the theoretical analysis of the concepts «illusion of thinking» and «metacognitive monitoring». The purpose of the paper is to find out the features of the illusion of thinking and to substantiate their importance in the metacognitive monitoring in the process of learning of university students. The role of illusion of thinking in metacognitive monitoring in the process of university students learning is analyzed.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Reder. L. M., "What Determines Initial Feeling of Knowing? Familiarity with Question Terms, Not with The Answer" 18 : 435-451, 1992

2 Schunn. C. D., "To Calculate or Not Calculate: A Source Activation Confusion (SAC) Model of Problem-Familiarity’S Role in Strategy Selection" 23 (23): 3-29, 1997

3 Kahneman. D., "Thinking, Fast and Slow" Farrar, Straus and Giroux 2011

4 Baron. J., "Thinking and Deciding" Cambridge University Press 2007

5 Thompson. V. A., "The Role of Answer Fluency and Perceptual Fluency as Metacognitive Cues for Initiating Analytic Thinking: Corrigendum" 130 (130): 140-, 2014

6 Holyoak. Keith J., "The Oxford Handbook of Thinking and Reasoning" Oxford University Press 2012

7 Roediger. H. L., "The Oxford Handbook of Memory" Oxford University Press 149-162, 2000

8 Thiede. K. W, "The Importance of Accurate Monitoring and Effective Self-Regulation During Multitrial Learning" 6 : 662-667, 1999

9 Mckay.R. T., "The Evolution of Misbelief" 32 : 493-561, 2009

10 Wilke. A., "The Encyclopedia of. Human Behavior 1" Academic Press 531-535, 2012

11 Metcalfe. J., "The Cue-Familiarity Heuristic in Metacognition" 19 (19): 851-861, 1993

12 Tversky. A., "The Belief in The Law of Small Numbers" 76 : 105-110, 1971

13 Finucane. M. L., "The Affect Heuristic in Judgments of Risks and Benefits" 13 : 1-17, 2000

14 Thomas. F., "Strategic Attention in Language Testing: Metacognition in A Yes/No Business English Vocabulary Test by Dieter Thoma" Peter Lang 2011

15 Henson. D., "Spy Secrets. How to Protect Your Life" Nash Format 2017

16 Belyaeva. E., "Rol Kognitivnyih Iskazheniy V Priobschenii Individa K Sotsialno-Kulturnoy Deyatelnosti [The Role of Cognitive Distortions in Involving the Individual in Socio-Cultural Activities]" 2016

17 Pasichnyk. I., "Psykholohiia Myslennia [The Psychology of Thinking]" Vydavnytstvo Natsionalnoho Universytetu «Ostrozka Akademiia» 2015

18 Ghrear. S. E., "Outcome Knowledge and False Belief" 7 : 118-, 2016

19 Avhustiuk. M., "Osoblyvosti Proiavu Iliuzii Znannia V Metakohnityv-Nomu Monitorynhu Navchalnoi Diialnosti [The Features of Manifestation of Illusion of Knowledge in Metacognitive Monitoring of Educational Activity]" 15 : 11-17, 2016

20 Stanovich. K. E., "On The Relative Independence of Thinking Biases and Cognitive Ability" 94 : 672-695, 2008

21 Kahneman. D., "On The Psychology of Prediction" 80 : 237-251, 1973

22 Evans. J. St. B. T., "On The Conflict Between Logic and Belief in Syllogistic Reasoning" 11 : 295-306, 1983

23 Pasichnyk. I., "Metakohnityvnyi Monitorynh Yak Rehuliatyvnyi Aspekt Metapiznannia [Metacognitive Monitoring as A Regulatory Aspect of Metarecognition]. Naukovi Zapysky Natsionalnoho Universytetu «Ostrozka Akademiia»"

24 Yeung. N., "Metacognition in Human Decision-Making: Confidence and Error Monitoring" 367 : 1310-1321, 2012

25 Wilson. T. D., "Mental Contamination and Mental Correc-Tion: Unwanted Influences On Judgments and Evaluations" 116 : 117-142, 1994

26 Koriat. A., "Mending Metacognitive Illusions: A Com-Parison of Mnemonic-Based and Theory-Based Procedures" 32 : 1133-1145, 2006

27 Schacter. D. L., "Memory Distortion: An Adaptive Perspective" 15 (15): 467-474, 2011

28 Kulakovskyi. T., "Kohnityvnyi Pidkhid U Vyvchenni Fenomenu Pidpryiemtsia [Cognitive Approach to The Study of the Entrepreneur's Phenomenon]" 2 (2): 2017

29 Popov. A., "Kognitivnyie Iskazheniya V Protsesse Prinyatiya Resheniy: Nauchnaya Problema I Gumanitarnaya Tehnologiya [Cognitive Distortions in The Decision-Making Process: A Scientific Problem and Humanitarian Technology]" 1 (1): 2014

30 Kashapova. E., "Kognitivnyie Iskazheniya I Ih Vliyanie Na Povedenie Individa [Cognitive Distortions and Their Influence On the Behavior of the Individual]" 2 (2): 15-26, 2015

31 Tversky. A., "Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases" 185 (185): 1124-1131, 1974

32 Hogarth. R, "Intuition: A Challenge for Psychological Research On Decision Making" 21 : 338-353, 2010

33 Thompson. V. A., "Intuition, Metacognition, And Reason" 63 : 107-140, 2011

34 Belyaeva. E, "Informatsionno-Psihologicheskoe Vozdeystvie Na Individa S Ispolzovaniem Kognitivnyih Iskazheniy V Sotsiokulturnyih Tselyah [Information-Psychological Impact On the Individual Using Cognitive Distortions for Socio-Cultural Purposes]" 1-3 (1-3): 463-466, 2016

35 Piattelli-Palmarini. M., "Inevitable Illusions: How Mistakes of Reason Rule Our Minds" John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 1994

36 Mcgregor. A., "ISASI 2017: «Lost Oppor-Tunities and Thinking Illusions»"

37 Yang. Y., "How to Eliminate Illusions in Quantified Reasoning" 28 : 1050-1059, 2000

38 Fischhoff. B, "Hindsight Is Not Equal to Foresight: The Effect of Outcome Knowledge On Judgment Under Uncertainty" 1 (1): 288-299, 1975

39 Gilovich. T., "Heuristics and Biases: The Psychology of Intuitive Judgment" Cambridge University Press 1-18, 2002

40 Griffin. D., "Heuristics and Biases: The Psychology of Intuitive Judgment" Cambridge University Press 230-249, 2002

41 Tversky. A., "Heuristics and Biases: The Psychology of Intuitive Judgment" Cambridge University Press 19-48, 2002

42 Gilovich. T., "Heuristics and Biases: The Psychology of Intuitive Judgment" Cambridge University Press 2002

43 Winne. P. H., "Handbook of Self-Regulation" Academic Press, Inc 531-566, 2000

44 Hacker. D. J., "Handbook of Metacognition in Education" Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group 2009

45 Serra. M. J., "Handbook of Metacognition and Education" Routledge 278-298, 2009

46 Bellamy. Linda J., "Getting Resilience into Safety Programs Using Simple Tools - A Research Background and Practical Implementation" Elsevier 172 (172): 171-184, 2018

47 Kahneman. D., "Fast and Slow Thinking" Nash Format 2017

48 Jee. B., "Expertise and The Illusion of Comprehension" 2006

49 Paley. J, "Error and Objectivity: Cognitive Illusions and Qualitative Research" 6 (6): 196-209, 2005

50 Glenberg. A. M., "Enhancing Calibration of Comprehension" 116 : 119-136, 1987

51 Denes-Raj. V., "Conflict Between Intuitive and Rational Processing: When People Behave Against Their Better Judgment" 66 : 819-829, 1994

52 Nickerson. R. S, "Confirmation Bias: A Ubiquitous Phenomenon in Many Guises" 2 (2): 175-220, 1998

53 Rüdiger. F. Pohl, "Cognitive Illusions: Intriguing Phenomena in Judgement, Thinking and Memory" Psychology Press 2017

54 Rüdiger. F. Pohl, "Cognitive Illusions: A Handbook On Fallacies and Biases in Thinking, Judgement and Memory" Psychology Press 2005

55 Nicholls. N., "Cognitive Illusions, Heuristics and Climate Prediction" 80 : 1385-1397, 1999

56 Barnes. James. H, "Cognitive Biases and Their Impact On Strategic Planning" 5 (5): 129-137, 1984

57 Blanco. F., "Causal Illusions in The Service of Political Attitudes in Spain and The UK. Frontiers in Psychology"

58 Perfect. Timothy. J., "Applied Metacognition" Cambridge University Press 2002

59 Thiede. K. W., "Accuracy of Metacognitive Monitoring Affects Learning of Texts" 95 : 66-73, 2003

60 Avhustiuk. M., "A. Iliuziia Znannia V Metakohnityvnomu Monitorynhu Navchalnoi Diialnosti Studentiv VNZ [Illusion of Knowledge in The Metacognitive Monitoring of Educational Activity of Students]"

61 Kliegr. T., "A Review of Possible Effects of Cognitive Biases On Interpretation of Rule-Based Machine Learning Models"

62 Kahneman. D, "A Perspective On Judgment and Choice: Mapping Bounded Rationality" 58 : 697-720, 2003