宗敎團體의 紛爭과 財産歸屬에 관한 硏究 = A Study on Dispute of Religious Entity and Property Reversion

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

These days our society has religious believers of 24.79 million people accounting for 53.1% of our total population, of them Buddhists occupy 22.8% of the total, Christians do 18.3%, and Catholics do 10.9%, so our society can be said to be a diversified one that the three major religion take up 98% of the entire religious population. The religious believers can lead only their religious life by mental life following religious creeds on an individual level, but furthermore they often form many types of groups and act through them socially. Consequently, a lot of conflicts can take place concerning the religious bodies, and those emerging as the legal disputes of religious entities include, the issues on the appointment of a man of cloth having the representative right of the organization, its division and resultant property reversion.
Hence, as a result of looking over the dispute and property reversion of a religious organization, the legal character of a Buddhist temple doesn't need to eliminate the existence of a pure non-corporation, but in general, it should be regarded as a special entity of in-between character having a non-corporate corporation and a non-corporate foundation. Thus, for the case of pure non-corporate corporation, the property reversion type of a temple can be said to be collectively owned, but that for most temples combined with a corporate factor and a property factor should be independently owned as that of a non-corporate foundation.
Most of our religious groups have been handed down from abroad, and since then, they have their own characteristics through he creed, organization and operation by their peculiar group. So it will not be desirable to apply the legal logic of corporation regulations on the civil code as they are since those provisions are those applicable to all kinds of groups. This can be comprehended from Japanese case holding back the application of the civil code provisions to religious entities at the time of enactment, then establishing the law of Religious Corporation and operating it. From our situation having such special law, as the dispute of religious entities cannot be denied, so it will be necessary to analogically apply the provision of a corporation on the civil code given the character of such a religious entity, come up with a norm through the leading cases, and on a long term basis, reflect the realities of a religious group and consider enact a special law fit for the religious group.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 序論
• Ⅱ. 宗敎團體의 紛爭
• Ⅲ. 宗敎團體의 性格
• Ⅳ. 宗敎團體의 財産歸屬
• Ⅴ. 結論
• 참고 문헌

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 연기영, "종교관계 법령의 문제점과 입법정책적 과제" 창작과 비평사 1990

2 安鍾赫, "사찰의 법인격" 서울地方辯護士會 2002

3 김제완, "단체법리의 재조명 : 종중재산의 법적 성격" 대한변호사협회 (355) : 134-159, 2006

4 최인석, "교회분열의 인정 여부 및 재산의 귀속" 釜山判例硏究會 19 : 2008

5 李完根, "교회분열의 법률관계, 民事法의 實踐的 課題(閑道 鄭煥淡敎授華甲記念論文集)" 법문사 2000

6 양형우, "교회분열에 따른 재산귀속" 한국재산법학회 24 (24): 59-93, 2007

7 渡部 蓊, "逐條解說 宗敎法人法," ぎょうせい, 平成13 2001

8 김 교 창, "準社團法人인 敎會의 分割" 한국법학원 (98) : 248-271, 2007

9 谷口知平, "本山ㆍ末寺と包括ㆍ被包括宗敎法人寺院 : 本山と宗派一體化の問題について" 龍谷大學 宗敎法硏究會 1983

10 金鎭鉉, "敎會의 法的 性質, 民法學의 現代的課題(梅石高昌鉉博士華甲紀念)" 博英社 1987

11 李學洙, "敎會의 分裂 및 그에 따른 敎會 財産의 歸屬에 관하여 現在의 大法院 判例가 취하는 態度에 대한 檢討" 釜山判例硏究會 Ⅰ : 1991

12 梁在模, "寺刹의 法的性質" 한양법학회 2003

13 金東潤, "寺刹의 法律關係," 민사실무연구회 12 : 2003

14 李伯圭, "寺刹의 實體와 宗團 變更" 민사판례연구회 19 : 1997

15 崔春根, "寺刹과 特定宗團과의 法律關係" 한국사법행정학회 6 : 1991

16 安武敏夫, "宗派離脫問題" 龍谷大學 宗敎法硏究會 1985

17 井上惠行, "宗敎法人法の基礎的硏究" 第一書房 1969

18 朴海成, "宗敎團體에 대한 法的 規律" 민사판례연구회 19 : 1997

19 蘇星圭, "宗敎團體를 둘러싼 紛爭과 法的 規律 方向" 한양법학회 2001

20 谷口知平, "宗敎團體の財産ㆍ離脫ㆍ懲戒をめぐる問題槪觀" 龍谷大學 宗敎法硏究會 1981

21 大石 眞, "宗敎團體と宗敎法人制度, ジュリスト No. 1081" 有斐閣 1995

22 竹田盛之輔, "宗敎團體と宗敎法人" 法務省民事局 44 (44): 1989

23 孫 晟, "傳統寺刹保存法의 宗敎法學的 硏究 : 法政策學的 接近" 동국대학교출판부 1993

24 洪光植, "佛敎會의 分裂과 財産歸屬" 釜山判例硏究會 Ⅰ : 1991