춤으로서 법의 기호학적 의미 = A Semiotic Analysis of Law as Dance

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Dance and law intersect with each other in the function of providing cure to individuals and integrating society. Dance and law originally were internal to each other. However, as modernization proceeds, dance was banished and became external to law. However, ballet can be understood as symbolizing modern rational law. It`s because the beauty produced by bodily movements of ballet which stick to the canon of the dance is equivalent to the geometrical and formative beauty of rational law, and the sublime beauty of ballet intersects with the universality of rational law. However, the sublime beauty of ballerina and the solemnization of individual bodies forced by rational law are the foundational causes of law`s failure to regulate diverse problems emerging in post-modern society. Law will be able to cope with those problems when it accepts the meaning symbolized by polysexuality of free dances. In postmodern society, law becomes one which dreams of innumerable choreographies. The image of human presupposed by such a law is a dancing ego, not a thinking ego. Contact improvisation, which is a representative postmodern dance, symbolizes the law of feeling which puts importance on the texture of a case, and its continuity of discontinuous contacts symbolizes a creation of chains of equivalence, which is the new type of social solidarity. Break dance which is another example of postmodern dances can be understood as intercultural bodymovement that makes possible the communication between mainstream culture and subculture, and between legal cultures different from each other. Such a body movement transforms absolutely inviolable modern human rights into the human rights of fabrical structure where several cultures intermingle equally. The interlegality of globalized era also becomes one of the meanings the intercultrual movements of break dance present.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 로버트 앳 우드, "포스트모던 춤과 탄츠테아터의 비평적 정의" (52) : 233-243, 2006

2 최봉철, "포스트모던 법철학: 윤리관과 정의관" 4 (4): 107-132, 2001

3 조은정, "춤의 텍스트로서 한국미술 이미지 읽기" 한국무용기록학회 11 : 157-188, 2006

4 권옥희, "춤의 미, 혹은 춤의 무용성(無用性)" (69) : 197-200, 2010

5 이애주, "춤과 과학 －우리춤의 온 과학적 속성－" 비교민속학회 (28) : 57-82, 2005

6 김채현, "춤, 행복으로 가는 치유의 행로" 220-223, 2007

7 이상돈, "인권법" 법문사 2005

8 민윤영, "에로스와 타나토스 사이의 법" 법학연구원 34 (34): 185-208, 2010

9 박영애, "성경에 나타난 춤의 의미 및 특성에 관한 연구" 한국무용기록학회 18 : 23-39, 2010

10 이상돈, "법미학" 법문사 2008

11 이소영, "법문학" 新英社 2005

12 한상희, "법과 일상생활의 문화비평적 재구성: ‘몸’담론분석을 통한 생활정치의 복원" 21 : 121-160, 2001

13 잭 앤더슨, "발레, 현대무용" 삶과 꿈 1996

14 지그문트 프로이트, "문명 속의 불만" 열린책들 2005

15 조기숙, "무용창작에서 ʻ새로움ʼ에 대한 철학적 고찰 - 미셀 포킨의 발레개혁을 중심으로" 한국무용기록학회 19 : 47-63, 2010

16 안나용, "매튜 본 <백조의 호수>의 문화코드 연구 - 문화기호학적 관점에서" 한국무용기록학회 16 : 107-143, 2009

17 윤희경, "로고스에 대한 몸의 반란: 1900년 전후 독일 회화에 나타난 춤" 서양미술사학회 (28) : 207-247, 2008

18 신상미, "도상학적 해석을 통한 최승희의 보살춤 창작기법 연구" 한국무용기록학회 10 (10): 65-84, 2006

19 신영사, "기초법학, 제2판" 법문사 2010

20 링컨 컬스타인, "고전 / 낭만 / 현대의 고전발레" (14) : 157-167, 1997

21 미셸 푸코, "감시와 처벌" 나남출판사 2003

22 Lior Barshack, "The body politic in dance, In Law, Text, Terror: : essays for Pierre Legendre" Routledge 47-60, 2006

23 Anca Giurchescu, "The Power of Dance and its Social and Political Uses" 33 : 109-121, 2001

24 Phillip E. Hammond, "The Internal Logic of Dance: A Weberian Perspective on the History of Ballet" 12 (12): 591-608, 1979

25 Pierre Legendre, "The Dance of Law, In Law and the Unconscious: A Legendre Reader" Macmillan Press 37-66, 1997

26 Roger I. Abrams, "The Dance and the Adjudication of Disputes" 51 : 901-910, 1998

27 Michel Foucault, "The Confession of the Flesh, In Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings by Michel Foucault" Pantheon Books 194-228, 1980

28 Helen Thomas, "The Body, Dance and Cultural Theory" Palgrave Macmillan 2003

29 Joan Chodorow, "The Body als Symbol-Dance/Movement in Analysis, In Authentic Movement" Jessica Kingsley Publisher 2000

30 Peter von Zima, "Textsoziologie" Eine kritische Einführung 1980

31 Amy Adler, "Symptomatic Cases: Hysteria in the Supreme Court’s Nude Dancing Decisions" 64 (64): 297-316, 2007

32 Costas Douzinas, "Sublime Law: On Legal and Aesthetic Judgements" 14 (14): 18-29, 2008

33 Julia Kristeva, "Semiotikè: Recherches pour une sémanalyse" 1969

34 Max Gluckman, "Politics, Law and Ritual in Tribal Society" Aldine Transaction 2006

35 신동룡, "Michel Foucault의 권력-지식론과 그 법이론적 함의에 관한 연구" 연세대학교 2000

36 Ernesto Laclau, "Metaphor and Social Antagonism, In Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture" University of Illinois Press 249-258, 1988

37 강성범, "LMA 분석을 통한 강선영류 태평무의 움직임 특성 연구" 한국무용기록학회 12 : 1-20, 2007

38 Ellie Ragland-Sullivan, "Jacques Lacan: Feminism and the Problem of Gender Identity" 11 (11): 6-20, 1982

39 Judith Butler, "Is Kinship Always Heterosexual?, In Left Legalism/Left Critique" Duke University Press 229-258, 2002

40 Gunther Teubner, "Globale Bukowina Zur Emergenz eines transnationalen Rechtspluralismus" 15 : 255-290, 1996

41 Gunther Teubner, "Global Law without a State" Dartmouth Publishing Group 1996

42 Halifu Osumare, "Global Breakdancing and the Intercultural Body" 34 (34): 30-45,

43 Judith Butler, "Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion der Identity" Routledge 1990

44 Suzanne K. Langer, "Feeling and Form, In A Theory of Art Developed from Philosophy in a New Key" Routledge & Kegan Paul 1959

45 Linda Hutcheon, "Death Drive: Eros and Thanatos in Wagner's Tristan und Isolde" 11 (11): 267-293, 1999

46 Joann W. Kealiinohomoku, "Dance, Myth and Ritual in Time and Space" 29 (29): 65-72, 1997

47 Jacques Derrida, "Choreographies: Interview, In Feminist Interpretations of Jaques Derrida" The Pennsylvania State University 23-41, 1997

48 Drucilla Cornell, "Beyond Accommodation; Ethical Feminism, Deconstruction, and the Law" Routledge 1991

49 Jacques Derrida, "Before the Law, In Act of Literature" Routledge 181-220, 1992