On “infra-theory” or “infra-language”: A Clarification of Actor–Network Theory via Bruno Latour’s Case Studies

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The aim of this article is to examine the potential of Actor–Network Theory as a nonhuman social science theory through critical readings of Bruno Latour’s empirical studies. In previous studies on ANT, an important issue has been to categorize it in regard to the type of theory it represents. Following Latour’s description of ANT as an “infra- theory” or “infra-language,” this article deals with the question of the relationship of those two terms to ANT. To examine these concepts, we will review two of Latour’s case studies: the historical study on Louis Pasteur’s eradication of anthrax and the ethnography on the failure of the automated train operation system of the Paris metro. After exploring these cases, we conclude that ANT is a theory not for causal explanation but for the discovery of hidden factors.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Fuller, Steve, "Why Science Studies Has Never Been Critical of Science: Some Recent Lessons on How to Be a Helpful Nuisance and a Harmless Radical" 30 (30): 5-32, 2000

2 Winner, Langdon, "Upon Opening the Black Box and Finding it Empty: Social Constructivism and the Philosophy of Technology" 18 (18): 362-378, 1993

3 Miller, Daniel, "Turning Callon the Right Way Up" 31 (31): 218-233, 2002

4 Hartwick, Elaine R., "Towards a Geographical Politics of Consumption" 32 (32): 1177-1192, 2000

5 Woolgar, Steve, "The Turn to Technology in Social Studies of Science" 16 (16): 20-50, 1991

6 Riis, Søren, "The Symmetry between Bruno Latour and Martin Heidegger : The Technique of Turning a Police Officer into a Speed Bump" 38 (38): 285-301, 2008

7 Pinch, Trevor J., "The Social Construction of Technological Systems: New Directions in the Sociology and History of Technology" MIT Press 11-44, 1987

8 Law, John, "The Social Construction of Technological Systems: New Directions in the Sociology and History of Technology" MIT Press 105-128, 2011

9 Russell, Stewart, "The Social Construction of Artefacts : A Response to Pinch and Bijker" 16 (16): 331-346, 1986

10 Yearley, Steven, "The Relationship between Epistemological and Sociological Cognitive Interests: Some Ambiguities Underlying the Use of Interest Theory in the Study of Scientific Knowledge" 13 (13): 353-388, 1982

11 Latour, Bruno, "The Prince and the Wolf:Latour and Harman at the LSE" Zero Books 2011

12 Latour, Bruno, "The Pasteurization of France" Harvard University Press 1988

13 Law, John, "The New Blackwell Companion to Social Theory" Oxford:Blackwell Publishing 141-158, 2009

14 Pickering, Andrew, "The Mangle of Practice : Agency and Emergence in the Sociology of Science" 99 (99): 559-589, 1993

15 Schaffer, Simon, "The Eighteenth Brumaire of Bruno Latour" 22 (22): 174-192, 1991

16 Latour, Bruno, "Technological Choice: Transformations in Material Culture Since the Neolithic" Routledge and Kegan Paul 372-398, 1993

17 Amsterdamska, Olga, "Surely You are Joking, Monsieur Latour!" 15 (15): 495-504, 1990

18 Lynch, Michael, "Scientific Practice and Ordinary Action: Ethnomethodology and Social Studies of Science" Cambridge University Press 1992

19 Bourdieu, Pierre, "Science of Science and Reflexivity" Polity Press 2004

20 Hacking, Ian, "Science in Action: How to Follow Scientists and Engineers through Society. The Pasteurization of France. Bruno Latour, Alan Sheridan, John Law" 59 (59): 510-512, 1992

21 Latour, Bruno, "Science Observed: New Perspectives on the Social Study of Science" Sage Publications 141-170, 1983

22 Wajcman, Judy, "Reflections on Gender and Technology Studies : In What State is the Art?" 30 (30): 447-464, 2000

23 Latour, Bruno, "Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network Theory" Oxford University Press 2005

24 Harman, Graham, "Prince of Networks: Bruno Latour and Metaphysics" re.press 2009

25 Zelizer, Viviana A, "Pasts and Futures of Economic Sociology" 50 (50): 1056-1069, 2007

26 Lee, Nick, "Otherness and the Actor Network: The Undiscovered Continent" 37 (37): 772-790, 1994

27 Lynch, Michael, "Ontography : Investigating the Production of Things, Deflating Ontology" 43 (43): 444-462, 2013

28 Barnes, Barry, "On the ‘Hows’ and ‘Whys’ of Cultural Change(response to Woolgar)" 11 (11): 481-498, 1981

29 Barnes, Barry, "On the Margins of Science: The Social Construction of Rejected Knowledge" Routledge & Kegan Paul 49-66, 1979

30 Pierides, Dean, "Object-oriented Sociology and Organizing in the Face of Emergency : Bruno Latour, Graham Harman and the Material Turn" 63 (63): 662-679, 2012

31 Times Higher Education, "Most cited authors of books in the humanities"

32 MacKenzie, Donald, "Material Markets: How Economic Agents are Constructed" Oxford University Press 2009

33 Sayes, Edwin, "Marx and the Critique of Actor-network Theory : Mediation, Translation, and Explanation" 18 (18): 294-313, 2017

34 Hämäläinen, Nora, "Latour’s Empirical Metaphysics" 17 (17): 20-37, 2016

35 Latour, Bruno, "Laboratory Life: The Social Construction of Scientific Facts" Sage Publications 1979

36 Bloor, David, "Knowledge and Social Imagery" Routledge & Kegan Paul 1976

37 MacKenzie, Donald, "Interests, Positivism and History" 11 (11): 498-504, 1981

38 Barnes, Barry, "Interests and the Growth of Knowledge" Routledge and Kegan Paul 1978

39 Woolgar, Steve, "Interests and Explanation in the Social Study of Science" 11 (11): 365-394, 1981

40 Collins, Harry M., "Humans not Instruments" 4 (4): 138-147, 2010

41 Mialet, Hélène, "Hawking Incorporated: Stephen Hawking and the Anthropology of the Knowing Subject" The University of Chicago Press 2012

42 Geels, Frank W., "Feelings of Discontent and the Promise of Middle Range Theory for STS: Examples from Technology Dynamics" 32 (32): 627-651, 2007

43 Woolgar, Steve, "Critique and Criticism : Two Readings of Ethnomethodology" 11 (11): 504-514, 1981

44 Hutchins, Edwin, "Cognition in the Wild" MIT Press 1995

45 Latour, Bruno, "Chasing Technoscience: Matrix for Materiality" 15-26, 2003

46 Schmidgen, Henning, "Bruno Latour in Pieces: An Intellectual Biography" Fordham University Press 2015

47 de Vries, Gerard, "Bruno Latour" Polity Press 2016

48 Latour, Bruno, "An Interview with Bruno Latour" 1 (1): 247-268, 1993

49 More, Prachi., "Actors and Networks in the Megacity: A Literary Analysis of Urban Narratives" transcript Verlag 2017

50 Sayes, Edwin, "Actor-network Theory and Methodology : Just What Does it Mean to Say that Nonhumans Have Agency?" 44 (44): 134-149, 2014

51 Mol, Annemarie, "Actor-network Theory : Sensitive Terms and Enduring Tensions" 50 (50): 253-269, 2010

52 Michael, Mike, "Actor-Network Theory: Trials, Trails and Translations" Sage Publications 2017

53 Latour, Bruno, "Actor Network and After" Blackwell Publishing 15-25, 1999

54 Law, John, "Actor Network and After" Blackwell Publishing 1-14, 1999

55 Callon, Michel, "Actor Network and After" Blackwell Publishing 181-195, 1999

56 Khong, Lynnette, "Actants and Enframing : Heidegger and Latour on Technology" 34 (34): 693-704, 2003