베버리지 보고서의 사회보장 원칙과 가정에 대한 비판의 타당성 검토

국문 초록 (Abstract)

베버리지 보고서는 세계 제 2차대전 이후 국내외의 지지를 받아, 영국을 비롯한 많은 국가의 복지정책에 큰 영향을 미쳐왔지만, 그의 사회보장 원칙과 가정에 대한 비판도 끊임없이 제기되었다. 물론 베버리지 사회보험의 원칙과 가정이 실현될 가능성이 희박하다는데 이의를 제기할 사람은 없을 것이다. 그러나 본 연구결과 이러한 비판가운데 일부는 잘못된 이해와 해석, 베버리지의 의도와는 다른 방향으로 실행된 정책 혹은 최근상황을 기준으로 평가한 것도 있다. 이는 베버리지가 받아야 할 비판이상의 부당한 평가 역시 받고 있음을 보여주는 것이다. 따라서 앞으로는 베버리지가 사회보장제도를 고안했을 때에 적합했던 원칙과 가정을 비판하기보다, 변화된 상황을 고려하여 복지국가의 이념과 가치를 지키며, 사회적 연대와 보편주의를 고수할 수 있는, 사회보장의 원칙과 가정마련에 주력하는 것이 더 건설적이라고 생각한다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Beveridge report has been supported by domestic and overseas since the second world war and has considerately effected on welfare policy of many countries including UK. But criticism regarding his social security's principles assumptions continuously has been proposed since the 1990s. Certainly, no one might object to the truth that there might be no possibility to come true Beveridge's principles and assumptions. However according to this studies, some of these criticisms were based on wrong understanding, interpretation or recent situation and policy which was executed differently from Beveridge's meaning. It's shown that Beveridge has been more misestimated than what he has to be suffered. Therefore from now on, it is constructive to endeavor to set up the better principles and assumption of social security which can adhere to social solidarity and universalism as well as preserve and improve welfare state' ideology and value considering transformed circumstances rather than criticize Beveridge's principles and assumptions that was suitable for that time.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• [요약]
  
• 1. 서론
  
• 2. 베버리지 보고서에 나타난 사회보장제도의 특징
  
• 3. 베버리지 사회보장의 원칙과 가정에 대한 비판 및 타당성 검토
  
• 4. 결론
  
• 참고문헌
  
• Abstract

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김태성, "현대복지국가의 변화와 대응" 서울: 나남 2005

2 지은정, "영국의 노후소득보장체제-기초소득보장과 기초연금을 중심으로-" 101 : 96-110, 2005

3 Department of Work and Pension(DWP), "a guide to State Pensions"

4 International Labour Office(ILO), "Yearbook of Labour Statistics"

5 International Labour Office(ILO), "Yearbook of Labour Statistics"

6 Hyde Mark, "Work for those that can security for those that cannot : The United Kingdom's new social security reform agenda" 52 (52): 69-86, 1999

7 National Statistics, "Work and Pension Statistics, 2004"

8 Harris Jose, "William Beveridge: A Biography"

9 Department of Work and Pension(DWP), "Unemployment by duration and age(seasonally adjusted)"

10 National Statistics, "UK 2005"

11 Alcock Pete, "The advantages and disadvantages of the contribution base in targeting benefits: A social analysis of the insurance scheme in the United Kingdom" 49 (49): 31-49, 1996

12 Perrin Guy, "The Beveridge Plan: The main principles" 45 (45): 39-52, 1992

13 Disney Richard and Sarah Tanner, "The Abolition of the Earnings Rule for UK Pensioners" The Institute for Fiscal Studies WP 00/13

14 Rejda George E, "Social insurance and economic security. sixth edition"

15 Mckay Stephen, "Social Security in Britain"

16 Euzéby Alain, "Social Security : Indispensable Solidarity" 50 (50): 3-15, 1997

17 Beveridge William, "Social Insurance and Allied Services" London. HMSO 1942

18 Esping-Andersen Gøsta, "Social Foundations of Postindustrial Economies" New York. Oxford University Press. 1999

19 John Ring, "Security in Pension Provision: A Critical Analysis of UK Government Policy" 34 (34): 343-363, 2005

20 Department of Work and Pension(DWP), "Part time and temporary work by industry sector 2004/2005"

21 Veit-Wilson, "Muddle or Mendacity? The Beveridge Committee and the Poverty Line" 21 (21): 269-301, 1992

22 Walker Robert, "Making welfare work: UK activation polices under New labour" 56 (56): 3-29, 2003

23 Department of Work and Pension(DWP), "Households below Average Income2003/2004"

24 Hills John, "Heading for Retirement? National Insurance, State Pension, and the Future of the Contributory Principle in the UK" 33 (33): 347-371, 2004

25 Beveridge William, "Full Employment In A Free Societ" New York. W․W․NORTON & COMPANY․INC. 1945

26 Gilbert Neil, "From entitlement to incentives: The changing philosophy of social protection" 45 (45): 5-17, 1992

27 National Statistics, "Contributions and Qualifying years tables"

28 Veit-Wilson, "Condemned to Deprivation? Beveridge's Responsibility for the Invisibility of Poverty" 97-117, 1994

29 Alder Michael, "Combining welfare-to-work measures with tax credits : A new hybrid approach to social Security in the United Kingdom" 57 (57): 87-106, 2004

30 Harris Jose, "Beveridge's Social and Political Thought" 23-36, 1994

31 Baldwin Peter, "Beveridge in the longue duree" 45 (45): 53-72, 1992

32 Macnicol John, "Beveridge and Old Age" 73-96, 1994

33 Department of Work and Pension(DWP), "Benefit-Number in receipt by DWP objective 1991/92~2007/08"

34 Department of Work and Pension(DWP), "Benefit Expenditure, Great Britain, 1991/92~2005/06"

35 Department of Work and Pension(DWP), "Benefit Expenditure, Great Britain, 1948/49~1991/92"

36 Lowe Rodney, "A Prophet Dishonoursed in his Own Country? The Rejection of Beveridge in Britain, 1945-1970" 118-133, 1994