근거 개념을 이용한 복수주어 관점에서의 집단적 믿음 = The Plural Subject Account of Group Beliefs Using Grounding Concept

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In this paper, we propose a plural subject account of group beliefs using grounding concept, which bridges the gap between the two main approaches of ACLs, the mentalistic accounts and the social commitment accounts. The key idea of this Gilbert’s plural subject account of group beliefs is to extend the grounding logic into the common ground framework for the semantics of ACLs which is fully verifiable, fully formalized and easily applicable. Thus, we formalize the proper group belief concept using common ground framework and we define the semantics of the primitive speech acts of FIPA-ACL such as inform, request and confirm as case studies. Also, we illustrate our framework on an e-commerce agent purchase negotiation and compare this proposed framework with two traditional semantics for ACLs.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Abstract
• Ⅰ. Introduction
• Ⅱ. Preliminaries
• Ⅲ. The Proposed Scheme
• Ⅳ. Conclusions
• REFERENCES

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 J. Pfau, "Towards a computational formalism for a grounding model of cultural transmission" 383-391, 2012

2 E. Lorini, "The logic of acceptance: Grounding institutions on agents' attitudes" 19 (19): 901-940, 2009

3 J. R. Searle, "Speech acts: An essay in the philosophy of language" Cambridge University Press 54-71, 1969

4 Hans Madsen Pedersen, "Speech Acts and Agents-A Semantic Analysis" 2002

5 R. Hakli, "Reasoning about collectively accepted group beliefs" 40 : 531-555, 2011

6 R. Fagin, "Reasoning about Knowledge" The MIT Press 1-4, 1995

7 M. Gilbert, "On Social Facts" Princeton University Press 204-214, 1989

8 M. Gilbert, "Modelling collective belief" 73 : 185-204, 1987

9 Daniel Vanderveken, "Meaning and Speech Acts Volume 1 Principles of language use" Cambridge University Press 169-189, 1990

10 B. Gaudou, "Language, Cognition, Interaction" 1-31, 2008

11 J. R. Searle, "Intentionality: An Essay in the Philosophy of Mind" Cambridge University Press 1-13, 1983

12 Tuomela, R., "Group beliefs" 91 : 285-315, 1992

13 B. Gaudou, "Grounding and the expression of belief" AAAI Press 211-219, 2006

14 B. Gaudou, "Formalizing social attitudes in modal logic" 2008

15 FIPA, "FIPA Contract Net Interaction Protocol Specification" Foundation for Intelligent Physical Agents

16 FIPA, "FIPA Communicative Act Library Specification" Foundation for Intelligent Physical Agents

17 H. H. Clark, "Contributing to Discourse" 13 : 259-294, 1989

18 D. R. Traum, "Computational theory of grounding in natural language conversation" University of Rochester 1994

19 Douglas N. Walton, "Commitment in Dialogue: Basic Concepts of Interpersonal Reasoning" State University of New-York Press 1995

20 Wray, K. Brad, "Collective belief and acceptance" 3 (3): 319-333, 2001

21 "Collective Intentionality"

22 M. Gilbert, "Collective Epistemology" 1 (1): 95-107, 2004

23 Tuomela, R., "Belief versus acceptance" 2 : 122-137, 2000

24 M. Gilbert, "Belief and acceptance as features of groups" 16 : 35-69, 2002

25 N. Bulling, "Agent, Beliefs, and Plausible Behaviour in a Temporal Setting" 1-23, 2007

26 B. Gaudou, "A logical framework for grounding-based dialogue analysis" 157 (157): 117-137, 2006

27 B. Gaudou, "A New Semantics for the FIPA Agent Communication Language based on Social Attitudes" 245-249, 2006

28 김지현, "A Multi-Agent MicroBlog Behavior based User Preference Profile Construction Approach" 한국컴퓨터정보학회 20 (20): 29-37, 2015