Development and evaluation of punching shear database for flat slab-column connections without shear reinforcement

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

A large body of experiments have been conducted to date to evaluate the punching shear strength of flat slab-column connections, but it is noted that only a few of them have been considered for the development of the ACI Code provisions. The limited test results used for the development of the code provisions fall short of predicting accurately the punching shear strength of such connections. In an effort to address this shortfall and to gain an insight into the factors that control the punching shear strength of flat slab-column connections, we report a qualified database of 650 punching shear test results in this article. All slabs examined in this database were tested under gravity loading and do not contain shear reinforcement. In order to justify including any test result for evaluation punching shear database, we have developed an approved set of criteria. Carefully established set of criteria represent the actual characteristics of structures that include minimum compressive strength, effective depths of slab, flexural and compression reinforcement ratio and column size. The key parameters that significantly affect the punching shear strength of flat slab-column connections are then examined using ACI 318-14 expression. The results reported here have paramount significance on the range of applicability of the ACI Code provision and seem to indicate that the ACI provisions do not sufficiently capture many trends identified through regression of the principal parameters, and fall on the unsafe side for the prediction of the punching shear strength of flat slab-column connections.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Matthys, S., "Verification of the punching resistance of concrete slabs reinforced with FRP grids" Royal Institute of Technology 2000

2 Theodorakopoulos, D.D., "Ultimate punching shear strength analysis of slab-column connections" 24 (24): 509-521, 2002

3 Widianto, B.O., "Two-way shear strength of slab-column connections: Reexamination of ACI 318 provisions" 106 (106): 160-170, 2009

4 Beutel, R., "The effect of anchorage on the effectiveness of the shear reinforcement in the punching zone" 24 (24): 539-549, 2002

5 Abdullah, A., "Tests investigating the punching shear of a column-slab connection strengthened with non-prestressed or prestressed FRP plates" 48 : 1134-1144, 2013

6 Ebead, U.A., "Tension-stiffening model for FRP-strengthening RC concrete two-way slabs" 38 (38): 193-200, 2005

7 Regan, P.E., "Symmetric punching of reinforced concrete slabs" 38 (38): 115-128, 1986

8 Vaz, A.P.R., "Study the minimum shear reinforcement of reinforcement of reinforced concrete flats slabs" 2 (2): 1-24, 2009

9 Ozawa, M., "Study on the process on punching shear failure of RC slabs" Royal Institute of Technology 2000

10 Einpaul, J., "Study on influence of column size and slab slenderness on punching strength" 113 (113): 135-145, 2016

11 Mokhtar, A., "Stud shear reinforcement for flat concrete plates" 82 (82): 676-683, 1985

12 Nightingale, R.I., "Structural interaction of circular reinforced flat slabs" University of Arizona 1970

13 Radik, M.J., "Strengthening two-way reinforced concrete floor slabs using polypropylene fiber reinforcement" 23 (23): 562-571, 2011

14 Harajli, M.H., "Strengthening of interior slab-column connections using a combination of FRP sheets and steel bolts" 10 (10): 399-409, 2006

15 Faria, D.M.V., "Strengthening of flat slabs with post-tensioning using anchorages by bonding" 33 (33): 2025-2043, 2011

16 Soudki, K., "Strengthening of concrete slab-column connections using CFRP strips" 24 (24): 25-33, 2012

17 Sissakis, K., "Strengthening concrete slabs for punching shear with carbon fiber-reinforced polymer laminates" 104 (104): 49-59, 2007

18 Duarte, I., "Stengthening of Flat Slabs with Transverse Reinforcement, CCC 2008-Challenges for Civil Construction, Torres Marques" 2008

19 Bazant, Z.P., "Size effect in punching shear failure of slabs" 84 (84): 44-53, 1987

20 Scordelis, A.C., "Shearing strength of prestressed lift slabs" 55 (55): 485-506, 1958

21 Moe, J., "Shearing Strength of Reinforced Concrete Slabs and Footings under Concentrated Loads, Development Department Bulletin D 47" 1961

22 Corley, W.G., "Shearhead reinforcement for slabs" 65 (65): 811-824, 1968

23 Mowrer, R.D., "Shear strength of lightweight aggregate reinforced concrete flat plates" 64 (64): 722-727, 1967

24 Roll, F., "Shear resistance of perforated reinforced concrete slabs, ACI Publ., SP-30-4" 77-101, 1971

25 Regan, P.E., "Shear reinforcement against punching in reinforced concrete flat slabs" 79 (79): 24-31, 2001

26 Reineck, K.H., "Shear database for reinforced concrete members without shear shear reinforcement" 100 (100): 240-249, 2003

27 Hawkins, N.W., "Shear Strength of Slabs without Shear Reinforcement, Shear in Reinforced Concrete (SP-42)" 677-720, 1974

28 Sistonen, E., "Results of the New Reinforcing Technology Project" 2011

29 Talbot, A.N., "Reinforced Concrete Wall Footings and Column Footings, Engineering Experiment Station" 1913

30 Hasan, M., "Punchingshear strength of normal and high-strength two-way concrete slabs reinforced with GFRP bars" 17 (17): 1-12, 2013

31 Hassan, M., "Punching-shear strength of glass fiber-reinforced polymer reinforced concrete flat slabs" 40 (40): 951-960, 2013

32 Heinzmann, D., "Punching tests on reinforced concrete slabs with and without shear reinforcement" 109 (109): 787-794, 2012

33 Muttoni, A., "Punching tests of slabs with low reinforcement ratios" 106 (106): 87-95, 2009

34 Oliveira, D.R., "Punching strengths of flat plates with vertical or inclined stirrups" 97 (97): 485-491, 2000

35 Yitzhaki, D., "Punching strength of reinforced concrete slabs" 63 (63): 527-542, 1966

36 Hegger, J., "Punching strength of reinforced concrete footings" 106 (106): 706-716, 2009

37 Kruger, G., "Punching strength of RC flat slabs with moment transfer" Royal Institute of Technology 2000

38 Hoang, L.C., "Punching shear tests on RC slabs with different initial crack patterns" 14 : 1183-1189, 2011

39 Ozden, S., "Punching shear tests of normal- and high-strength concrete flat plates" 33 (33): 1389-1400, 2006

40 Alexander, S.D.B., "Punching shear tests of concrete slab-column joints containing fibre reinforcement" 89 (89): 425-432, 1992

41 Papanikolaou, K.V., "Punching shear testing of reinforced concrete slabs, and design implications" 57 (57): 167-177, 2005

42 Meisami, M.H., "Punching shear strengthening of two-way flat slabs with CFRP grids" 18 (18): 1-10, 2013

43 Binici, B., "Punching shear strengthening of reinforced concrete flat plates using carbon fiber reinforced polymers" 129 (129): 1173-1182, 2003

44 Teng, S., "Punching shear strength of slabs with openings and supported on rectangular columns" 101 (101): 678-687, 2004

45 Oukaili, N.K., "Punching shear strength of reinforced concrete flat plates with openings" 20 (20): 1-20, 2014

46 Esfahani, M.R., "Punching shear strength of interior slab-column connections strengthened with carbon fiber reinforced polymer sheets" 31 (31): 1535-1542, 2009

47 Nguyen-Minh, L., "Punching shear resistance of steel fiber reinforced concrete flat slabs" 14 : 1830-1837, 2011

48 Yamada, T., "Punching shear resistance of flat slabs: Influence of reinforcement type and ratio" 88 (88): 555-563, 1992

49 Cho, Y.S., "Punching shear reinforcing using studs with steel plates in reinforced concrete flat plates" 61 (61): 721-729, 2010

50 Gardner, N.J., "Punching shear provisions for reinforced and pressurised concrete flat slabs" 23 (23): 502-510, 1996

51 Kim, Y.J., "Punching shear of two-way slabs retrofitted with prestressed or non-prestressed CFRP sheets" 29 (29): 1206-1223, 2009

52 Rizk, E., "Punching shear of thick plates with and without shear reinforcement" 108 (108): 581-591, 2011

53 Liana, L.J., "Punching shear of reinforced concrete flat plates with openings" 110 (110): 547-556, 2013

54 Oliveira, D.C., "Punching shear in reinforced concrete flat slabs with hole adjacent to the column and moment transfer" 7 (7): 414-467, 2014

55 Costa, V.C.M., "Punching shear in reinforced concrete flat slabs column rectangularity" 5 (5): 36-46, 2012

56 Youm, K.S., "Punching shear failure of slab with lightweight aggregate concrete (LWAC) and low reinforcement ratio" 65 : 92-102, 2014

57 Yang, J.M., "Punching shear behaviour of two-way slabs reinforced with high strength steel" 107 (107): 468-475, 2010

58 Lovorovich, J.S., "Punching shear behaviour of slabs with varying span-depth ratios" 87 (87): 507-512, 1990

59 Li, X., "Punching shear behaviour of slab-column connections" The University of Sheffield 1997

60 Li, X., "Punching shear behaviour of slab-column connections" The University of Sheffield 1997

61 Swamy, R.N., "Punching shear behaviour of reinforced slab-column connections made with steel fiber concrete" 79 (79): 392-406, 1982

62 El-Ghandour, A.W., "Punching shear behavior of fiber reinforced polymers reinforced concrete flat slabs: Experimental study" 7 (7): 258-265, 2003

63 Kamaraldinm, K., "Punching shear and moment transfer in reinforced concrete flat slabs" The Polytechnic of Central 1990

64 Oliveira, D.R.C., "Punching resistance of RC slabs with rectangular column" 56 (56): 123-138, 2004

65 Alander, C., "Punching prevention in flat RC slabs" Royal Institute of Technology 2000

66 Ospina, C.E., "Punching of two-way concrete slabs with fiber-reinforced polymer reinforcing bars or grids" 100 (100): 589-598, 2003

67 Gouveia, N., "Punching of steel fibre reinforced concrete flat slabs" 2013

68 Regan, P.E., "Punching of slabs under highly concentrated loads" 2004

69 Ferreira, M.P., "Punching of reinforced concrete flat slabs with double-headed shear reinforcement" 111 (111): 363-274, 2014

70 Inacio, M.M.G., "Punching of high strength concrete flat slabs: Experimental investigation" 2013

71 Ramos, A.P., "Punching of flat-slabs with in-plane forces" 33 (33): 894-902, 2011

72 Broms, C.E., "Punching of flat plates-a question of concrete properties in biaxial compression and size effect" 87 (87): 292-304, 1990

73 Kinnuen, S., "Punching of Concrete Slab without Shear Reinforcement" 1960

74 Farghaly, A.S., "Prediction of punching shear strength of two-way slabs strengthened externally with FRP sheets" 15 (15): 181-193, 2011

75 Elshafey, A.A., "Prediction of punching shear strength of two-way slabs" 33 (33): 1742-1753, 2011

76 Rankin, G.I.B., "Predicting the punching strength of conventional slab-column specimens" 82 (82): 327-346, 1987

77 Habibi, F., "Post-punching shear response of two-way slabs" McGill University 2012

78 Ruiz, M.F., "Performance and design of punching shear reinforcement systems" 2010

79 Sagaseta, J., "Non-axis-symmetrical punching shear around internal columns of RC slabs without transverse reinforcement" 63 (63): 441-457, 2011

80 Mariam Hafidi, "Neuro-fuzzy optimisation to model the phenomenon of failure by punching of a slab-column connection without shear reinforcement" 국제구조공학회 47 (47): 679-700, 2013

81 Loo, Y.C., "Methods of punching shear strength analysis of reinforced concrete flat plates-a comparative study" 1 (1): 75-86, 1993

82 Caldenety, A.P., "Influence of stirrup detailing on punching shear strength of flat slabs" 49 : 855-865, 2013

83 Birkle, G., "Influence of slab thickness on punching shear strength" 105 (105): 180-188, 2008

84 Li, K.K.L., "Influence of size on punching shear strength of concrete slabs" McGill University 2000

85 Sakinis, D., "Influence of longitudinal reinforcement on the punching shear resistance of reinforced concrete slabs/Isilginio armavimo poveikis gelzbetonines plokstes praspaudziamajai laikomajai galiai" 1 (1): 73-79, 2009

86 Hughes, B.P., "Flat slabs with fibre or link reinforcement at slab-column connections" 110 (110): 308-321, 1995

87 "FIB Bulletin 12, Punching of Structural Concrete Slabs: Technical Report" Fib Federation Internationale du Beton 2001

88 Rizk, E., "Experimental validation of minimum flexural reinforcement for thick high-strength concrete plates" 108 (108): 332-340, 2011

89 Aziz, A.H., "Experimental study for punching shear behavior in RC flat plate with hybrid high strength concrete" 17 (17): 95-109, 2013

90 Marzouk, H., "Experimental investigation on the behaviour of high-strength concrete slabs" 88 (88): 701-713, 1991

91 Marzouk, H., "Experimental investigation on shear enhancement types for high-strength concrete plates" 94 (94): 49-58, 1997

92 Lips, S., "Experimental investigation of reinforced concrete slabs with punching shear reinforcement" 2010

93 Israel, R., "Experimental investigation of flat floor systems" 56 (56): 153-166, 1959

94 Grimaldi, A., "Experimental behaviour of fibre reinforced concrete bridge decks subjected to punching shear" 45 (45): 811-820, 2013

95 Cheng, M.Y., "Evaluation of steel fiber reinforcement for punching shear resistance in slabcolumn connections. Part I: Monotonically increased loading" 107 (107): 101-109, 2010

96 Hamada, S., "Evaluation of punching shear strength of reinforced concrete slabs based on database" 6 (6): 205-214, 2008

97 Pisanty, A., "Eurocodes and North American codes predictions of punching shear capacity in view of experimental evidence, Spec. Publ., SP-232" 257-276, 2005

98 Worle, P., "Enhanced shear punching capacity by the use of post installed concrete screws" 60 : 41-51, 2014

99 Kunz, J., "Enhanced safety with post-installed punching shear reinforcement" 2008

100 Broms, C.E., "Elimination of flat plate punching failure mode" 97 (97): 94-101, 2000

101 Lan, R.B., "Effectiveness of shear reinforcement in slabs under punching loads" 2002

102 Marzouk, H., "Effect of highstrength concrete slabs on the behaviour of slab-column connections" 95 (95): 227-237, 1998

103 Marzouk, H., "Effect of highstrength concrete columns on the behaviour of slab-column connections" 93 (93): 545-554, 1996

104 Ghannoum, C.M., "Effect of high-strength concrete on the performance of slab-column specimens" McGill University 1998

105 Stein, T., "Distinction between punching and flexural failure modes of flat plates" 104 (104): 357-365, 2007

106 Lawler, N., "Development of FRP shear bolts for punching shear retrofit of reinforced concrete slabs" 15 (15): 591-601, 2011

107 Grzegorz Ludwik Golewski, "Determination of fracture toughness in concretes containing siliceous fly ash during mode III loading" 국제구조공학회 62 (62): 1-9, 2017

108 Subedi, N.K., "Design of slab-column junctions in flat slabs" 156 (156): 319-331, 2003

109 Chana, P.S., "Design of shear reinforcement against punching" 70 (70): 159-164, 1992

110 CEB-FIP Model Code, "Design Code, Comitee Euro-International de Beton Bulletin D'Information, No. 203-305"

111 Michel, L., "Criteria for punching failure mode in RC slabs reinforced by externally bonded CFRP" 81 (81): 438-449, 2007

112 McHarg, P.J., "Benefits of concentrated slab reinforcement and steel fibers on performance of slab-column connections" 97 (97): 225-234, 2000

113 Derogar, S., "Behaviour of slab column connections under gravity loads" The University of Manchester 2014

114 Smadi, M.M., "Behaviour of highstrength fibrous concrete slab-column connections under gravity and lateral loads" 22 (22): 1863-1873, 2008

115 Bompa, D.V., "Behaviour of column-flat slab connection" Technical University of Clujnapoca 2011

116 Guidotti, R., "Behaviour and design of slab-column joints, Session 2B-1: Construction Technology" 2011

117 Osman, M., "Behavior of high-strength lightweight concrete slabs under punching loads" 97 (97): 492-498, 2000

118 Hunchate, S.R., "Beehavior of simply suported high performance concrete two way slabs in punching shear" 4 (4): 775-786, 2014

119 Chen, C.C., "An experimental study on the punching shear behaviour of RC slabs strengthened by GFRP" 2000

120 Alam, A.K.M.J., "An experimental study on punching shear behaviour of concrete slabs" 12 (12): 257-265, 2009

121 Reineck, K.H., "ACI-DAfStb database of shear tests on slender reinforced concrete beams without stirrups" 110 (110): 867-876, 2013

122 "ACI-ASCE Committee 326, Shear and diagonal tension, part 3-slabs and footings" 353-395, 1962

123 "ACI 318-14, Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete (ACI 318M-14) and Commentary (ACI 318RM-14)" American Concrete Institute 2014

124 Erdogan, H., "A new CFRP strengthening technique to enhance punching shear strength of RC slab-column connections" 2007