수산자원관리를 위한 법적 규제 ― 미국의 2006년 어업보존관리재승인법상의 어획제한제도를 중심으로 ― = Legal Regulation for Fisheries Resources Management -Focused on Catch Shares of The Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Reauthorization Act of 2006-

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Reauthorization Act of 2006 included two significant and complementary new provisions for catch shares. The first provision required the establishment of a mechanism for specifying annual catch limits(ACL). The ACLs place a firm cap on fisheries removals at a level such that overfishing will not occur. Accountability measures were required to accompany the ACL mechanisms. The second provision was the elaboration of criteria and guidance authorizing a program of limited access privileges(LAP) to help rebuild overfished stocks, reduce overcapacity if it exists, and promote safety, fishery conservation and management, and social and economic benefits.
A LAP is a means to distribute and enforce exclusive percentages of an ACL among participants. Taken together, ACLs and LAPs combine the positive biological benefits of a firm cap on fishery removals with the additional benefits of achieving important economic and social objectives necessary to support sustainable fisheries, but without the negative aspects of the race-for-fish with ACLs alone. Thus, it is an opportune time to consider the complementary use of ACLs and catch shares to meet the nation’s unmet goals for fishery management.
Our Korean Fishery Source Management Act of 2009 was legislated recently as a basic act for the management of fishery resources. However it has no basic rule for fishery share and the concrete designs like ACLs and LAPs of MSRA to achieve the object of fishery conservation. Therefore the act should be changed in ways to establish the legal rule for fishery conservation and management and to perform accountability measures to support sustainable fisheries.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 남종오, "한국의 ITQ제도 도입 가능성에 관한 연구 : 뉴질랜드 성과 분석으 중심으로" 부경대학교 대학원 2000

2 박성쾌, "한국 수산업의 선진화에 대한 이론적 고찰" 한국해양수산개발원 25 (25): 111-150, 2010

3 류정곤, "총허용어획향(TAC) 실시대상 어종의 연차적 확대방안에 관한 연구" 해양수산부 2002

4 류정곤, "총허용어획량(TAC) 할당제도의 운영방안에 관한 연구" 한국해양수산개발원 1997

5 박성쾌, "자연자원 관리의 패러다임 전환" 2009

6 임경희, "일본의 해외수산협력 동향-ODA 사업을 중심으로-" 2009

7 신영태, "일본의 수산기본정책에 대한 검토" 한국해양수산개발원 14 (14): 1999

8 김대영, "어업여건 변화에 대응한 일본의 새로운 어업정책 방향" 2008

9 이상고, "신해양질서의 어업관리체계와 TAC제도 도입에 관한 연구" 30 (30): 1999

10 박환재, "수산자원의 효율적 관리정책" (4) : 2005

11 전재경, "수산자원관리법제연구" 한국법제연구원 2002

12 김정봉, "수산보전제 정책목표 실현을 위한 제언" 2007

13 김선표, "불법･비보고･비규제(IUU) 어업 근절을 위한 국제행동계획과 국내적 이행방안 연구" 한국해양수산개발원 2001

14 박민규, "미국 수산보존 및 관리법상의 수산자원의 보존 및 관리제도 연구" 한국해양수산개발원 20 (20): 51-96, 2005

15 남종오, "노르웨이의 개별어선할당량(IVQ)제도에 관한 연구" 한국해양수산개발원 24 (24): 133-180, 2009

16 이상고, "개방시대 자유시장원리적 어업관리제도에 관한 경제학적 연구-ITQ제도의 발상적 이론과 경제적 효율성 분석연구를 중심으로-" 1 (1): 1994

17 農林水産部 日本貿易振興機構, "平成21年度 米国の水産資源管理をめぐる最近の動向" 2010

18 Grumbine R. Edward, "What is Ecosystem Management?" 8 (8): 1994

19 Garet Hardin, "The Tragedy of the Commons" 62 : 1968

20 Peter Shelley, "The New England Fisheries Crisis : What Have We Learned?" 9 : 1996

21 Anthony D. Scott, "The ITQ as a Property Right: Where it came from. How it Works and Where it is Going, In Taking Ownership: Property Rights and Fisheries Manage- ment on the Atlantic Coast" Atlantic Institute for Market Studies 1996

22 Ragnar Arnason, "The ITQ Fisheries Management System: Advantages and Disadvantages, In Nordiske Fiskerisamfund I Fremtiden" Nord 1995

23 H. Scott Gordon, "The Economic Theory of a Common Property Resource: The Fishery" 62 : 1954

24 Lee G. Anderson, "The Design and Use of Limited Access Privilege Programs" NOAA 2007

25 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, "Rules and Regul- ations" 74 (74): 2009

26 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, "Proposed Rules" 76 (76): 2011

27 Ragnar Arnason, "Property rights in fisheries: Iceland’s experience with ITQs" 15 (15): 2005

28 Daniel E. Lane, "Property rights and governance in Canadian fisheries, Optimum" 29 (29): 1999

29 Ragnar Arnason, "Property Rights as an Organizational Framework in Fisheries: The Case of Six Fishing Nations, In Taking Ownership: Property Rights and Fisheries Management on the Atlantic Coast" Atalantic Institute for Market Studies 1996

30 Ragnar Arnason, "Property Rights as a Means of Economic Organization, In Use of Property Rights in Fisheries Management" FAO 1999

31 Jerry F. Franklin, "Preserving biodiversity; species, ecosystems or landscapes" 3 (3): 1993

32 Anthony D. Scott, "Moving Through The Narrows: From Open Access to ITQs and Self-Government, In Use of Property Rights in Fisheries Management" FAO 105-107, 1999

33 Anthony D. Scott, "Introducing Property in Fishery Management, In Use of Property Rights in Fisheries Management" FAO 1999

34 National Marine Fisheries Service, "Implementing the Sustainable Fisheries Act -Achievement from 1996 to Present-"

35 Trevor Branch, "How do individual transferable quotas affect marine ecosystems?" 10 : 2008

36 R. G. Newell, "Fishing Quota Markets" 49 : 2005

37 M. F. Sigler, "Effects of individual quotas on catching efficiency and spawning potential in the Alaska sablefish fishery" 58 : 2001

38 T. Essington, "Ecological indicators display reduced variation in North American catch share fisheries" 107 (107): 2010

39 장창익, "EEZ 선포에 따른 우리나라의 어업자원 관리대책에 대한 고찰" 11 (11): 1996

40 Gary D. Libecap, "Contracting for Property Rights" Cambridge University Press 1989

41 Anthony D. Scott, "Conceptual Origins of Rights Based Fishing, In Rights Based Fishing" Kluwer 1989

42 U.S. Commission on Ocean Policy, "An Ocean Blueprint for the 21st Century" 2004

43 James Lovelock, "A Look at Life on Earth" Oxford University Press 1979

44 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, "50 CFR Part 600 Magnuson - Stevens Act Provisions; Annual Catch Limits; National Standard Guidelines; Final Rule" 74 (74): 2009