학생 자살 후 교사의 애도 경험에 관한 개념도 연구: 어려움 및 도움 요인 = Factors that Help and Hinder South Korean Teachers’ Bereavement Following Student Suicide: A Concept-Mapping Approach

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study aimed to identify the factors that helped and hindered secondary school teachers who experienced student suicide using the concept-mapping approach. Seven South Korean middle and high school teachers were interviewed from which 113 core statements were elicited. The participants sorted these core statements into categories by meaning. Multidimensional scaling and hierarchical cluster analysis were conducted to identify the underlying structure of the teachers’ experiences. Four hindering factor clusters emerged: (1) regret over failing to prevent the suicide, (2) an apathetic atmosphere in the school, (3) a sense of helplessness related to suicide survivors, and (4) approach-avoidance conflicts related to suicide survivors. Six helpful factor clusters emerged: (1) cooperation and care offered between suicide survivors, (2) focusing on the present, busy life, (3) spiritual activity, (4) social support, (5) overcoming grief through altruistic behaviors, and (6) sympathy for the deceased. Two dimensions were found for both the hindering and helpful factors. The hindering factor dimensions were external systeminternal experiences and related to suicide survivorsrelated to suicide decedents. The helpful factor dimensions were distancing from the lossapproaching the loss and professional activitiespersonal activities. The present study empirically explored and described the underlying structure of teachers’ bereavement experiences after student suicides.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 학생의 자살 이후, 중․고등학교 교사들이 상실에 대처하는 과정에서 어떤 어려움과 도움 요소를 경험하는지 개념도 방법을 활용하여 확인하였다. 이를 위해 학생의 자살을 경험한 중․고등학교 교사 7명을 대상으로 개별 면접을 시행하였고, 진술 내용을 기초로 총 113개의 핵심 문장을 추출하였다. 이 문장들은 참여자들에 의해 비슷한 의미를 가진 것끼리 분류되었으며, 이를 바탕으로 다차원척도분석과 군집분석을 실시하였다. 분석 결과, 교사들의 애도 과정에서의 어려움 요인은 ‘자살사별자 관련 및 자살 학생 관련’ 축과 ‘외부시스템 및 내적 경험’ 축의 2차원으로 구조화되었으며, 총 4개의 군집으로 분류되었다. 각각의 군집은 ‘자살을 예방하지 못한 후회,’ ‘자살 사건에 대한 학교의 무관심,’ ‘자살사별자 관련 무력감,’ ‘자살사별자 관련 접근-회피 갈등’으로 명명되었다. 교사들의 적응과정에서 도움 요인은 ‘직업적 활동 및 개인적 활동’ 축과 ‘상실 경험 분리 및 상실 경험 밀착’ 축의 2차원으로 구조화되었고, 총 6개의 군집으로 나타났다. 각각의 군집은 ‘자살사별자 간 협조와 보살핌,’ ‘바쁜 일상과 현재에 집중,’ ‘영성 활동,’ ‘사회적 지지,’ ‘이타적 행동을 통한 애도,’ ‘고인에 대한 연민’으로 명명되었다. 본 연구는 그동안 관심을 받지 못했던 교사 집단의 학생 상실 경험을 조명하고, 이들이 애도 과정에서 경험하는 어려움 요인과 도움 요인의 개념적 구조를 당사자의 관점에서 생생하게 규명하였다는 데 의의가 있다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 정형수, "한국 성인의 사별에 의한 복합비애경험 개념도연구" 한국심리학회 33 (33): 81-107, 2014

2 교육과학기술부, "학생자살 위기관리 프로토콜"

3 이승연, "학교장면에서의 자살 사후중재" 한국상담학회 8 (8): 161-180, 2007

4 김지연, "초심상담자와 상담전문가가 겪는 어려움과 극복방안에 대한 개념도 연구" 한국상담학회 10 (10): 769-792, 2009

5 한국청소년상담복지개발원, "청소년 자살 사후개입 매뉴얼 개발: 학교장면에서의 개입을 중심으로"

6 김병찬, "중학교 교사들의 교직문화에 대한 질적 사례 연구" 한국교육행정학회 21 (21): 1-28, 2003

7 박미정, "중증장애학생의 죽음에 대한 특수교사의 상실 경험" 한국특수교육문제연구소 16 (16): 265-286, 2015

8 정신영, "자살시도 병사의 위험요인과 보호요인에 관한 개념도 연구" 한국상담학회 13 (13): 113-133, 2012

9 명소연, "자살사건 외상대응과정에 대한 사례연구: A고등학교 교사경험을 중심으로" 한국상담심리학회 30 (30): 23-54, 2018

10 최명민, "자살로 사별한 노년기 배우자의 상실경험: 농촌지역 노인을 중심으로" 한국정신건강사회복지학회 44 (44): 76-105, 2016

11 민경화, "상담학 연구에서 개념도(Concept Mapping)방법의 적용" 한국상담학회 8 (8): 1291-1307, 2007

12 오희정, "사회는 교사에게 어떤 역할을 기대하는가?: 2007~2016년 신문자료 내용분석을 통한 교사 역할기대 경향 연구" 한국교원교육학회 34 (34): 139-166, 2017

13 강혜원, "미묘한 성차별(Gender Microaggression)에 대한 개념도 연구: 20대 여성을 중심으로" 한국여성정책연구원 106 (106): 63-92, 2020

14 대구광역시서부교육지원청, "대구광역시서부교육지원청 Wee센터 자살위기개입매뉴얼"

15 박광배, "다차원척도법" 교육과학사 2000

16 윤성근, "내담자의 자살에 대한 정신건강 전문가의 정서적 경험과 보호요인: 개념도 연구법을 활용하여" 한국상담심리학회 27 (27): 519-541, 2015

17 한국자살예방협회, "교사용 학생자살 위기대응 매뉴얼"

18 이범응, "교사와 교직생활" 지식과 감성 2015

19 최윤정, "고학력 기혼여성의 진로단절 위기 경험에 대한 개념도(Concept Mapping) 연구 -진로지속 여성과 중단 여성 간의 비교-" 한국상담학회 8 (8): 1031-1045, 2007

20 김현수, "개념도 및 언어네트워크 분석을통한 효과적인 생활지도의 내용과 방법" 이화여자대학교 일반대학원 2018

21 Levkovich, I., "“I Keep it Together at Work but Fall Apart at Home”:The Experience of Israeli Homeroom Teachers Coping With the Death of a Student in their Class" 0030222819899501-, 2020

22 Finlayson, M., "workplace responses and psychologists’ needs following cli ent suicide" 79 : 18-33, 2019

23 Hjelmeland, H., "Why we need qualitative research in suicidology" 40 (40): 74-80, 2010

24 Causer, H., "What is the experience of practitioners in health, education or social care roles following a death by suicide? A qualitative research synthesis" 16 (16): 3293-3316, 2019

25 Dyregrov, K., "What do we know about needs for help after suicide in different parts of the world? A phenomenological perspective" 32 (32): 310-318, 2011

26 Spiegelman, J. S., "Therapeutic and legal issues for therapists who have survived a client suicide:Breaking the silence" Haworth Press 35-57, 2005

27 Stroebe, W., "The role of loneliness and social support in adjustment to loss : a test of attachment versus stress theory" 70 (70): 1241-1249, 1996

28 Trochim, W., "The reliability of concept mapping" 6 : 1993

29 Gulfi, A., "The impact of patient suicide on the professional reactions and practices of mental health caregivers and social workers" 31 (31): 202-210, 2010

30 Kõlves, K., "The impact of a student’s suicide : Teachers’ perspectives" 207 : 276-281, 2017

31 Stroebe, M., "The dual process model of coping with bereavement : Rationale and description" 23 (23): 197-224, 1999

32 Stroebe, M., "The dual process model of coping with bereavement : A decade on" 61 (61): 273-289, 2010

33 Cerel, J., "The continuum of"survivorship" : Definitional issues in the aftermath of suicide" 44 (44): 591-600, 2014

34 Hart, L., "Teachers perceptions of effects of a student’s death : A phenomenological study" 66 (66): 301-311, 2013

35 Sisask, M., "Teacher satisfaction with school and psychological well-being affects their readiness to help children with mental health problems" 73 (73): 382-393, 2014

36 Cohen, J. A., "Supporting children with traumatic grief : What educators need to know" 32 (32): 117-131, 2011

37 Pitman, A., "Support needs and experiences of people bereaved by suicide : qualitative findings from a cross-sectional British study of bereaved young adults" 15 (15): 666-687, 2018

38 Maples, M. F., "Suicide by teenagers in middle school : A postvention team approach" 83 (83): 397-405, 2005

39 Dunne, E. J., "Suicide and its aftermath:Understanding and counseling the survivors" WW Norton 1987

40 Lamb, F., "Suicide and its aftermath: Understanding and counseling the survivors" WW Norton 245-260, 1987

41 Lepore, S. J., "Social constraints, intrusive thoughts, and depressive symptoms among bereaved mothers" 70 (70): 27-2821, 1996

42 Juth, V., "Social constraints are associated with negative psychological and physical adjustment in bereavement" 7 (7): 129-148, 2015

43 Hannon, M. D., "School counselors, multiple student deaths, and grief : A narrative inquiry" 97 (97): 43-52, 2019

44 Ballou, M. B., "Rethinking mental health and disorder: Feminist perspectives" Guilford Press 2002

45 Mancini, A. D., "Resilience in the face of potential trauma : Clinical practices and illustrations" 62 (62): 971-985, 2006

46 Andriessen, K., "Postvention in action: The international handbook of suicide bereavement support" Hogrefe Verlag 2017

47 Giorgi, A., "Phenomenology and psychological research" Duquesene University Press 12-28, 1985

48 Oexle, N., "Perceived social support and mental health after suicide loss" 41 (41): 65-69, 2019

49 Kübler-Ross, E., "On Death and Dying" The Macmillan Company 1969

50 Fine, C., "No time to say goodbye: Surviving the suicide of a loved one" Harmony 2011

51 Kruskal, J. B., "Multidimensional scaling by optimizing goodness of fit to a nonmetric hypothesis" 29 (29): 1-27, 1964

52 Kim, J. E., "Korean teachers’ bereavement experience following student suicide : A phenomenological study" 40 (40): 287-293, 2019

53 Mangurian, C., "Improving support of residents after a patient suicide : a residency case study" 33 (33): 278-281, 2009

54 Rytterström, P., "Impact of suicide on health professionals in psychiatric care mental healthcare professionals’ perceptions of suicide during ongoing psychiatric care and its impacts on their continued care work" 29 (29): 982-991, 2020

55 Goodyear, R. K., "Ideographic concept mapping in counseling psychology research : Conceptual overview, methodology, and an illustration" 52 (52): 236-, 2005

56 Wurst, F. M., "How therapists react to patient’s suicide : findings and consequences for health care professionals’wellbeing" 35 (35): 565-570, 2013

57 Westefeld, J. S., "High school suicide : Knowledge and opinions of teachers" 12 (12): 33-44, 2007

58 Miller, D. N., "Handbook of School-Based Mental Health Promotion" Springer International Publishing 261-277, 2018

59 Bonanno, G. A., "Grief processing and deliberate grief avoidance : a prospective comparison of bereaved spouses and parents in the United States and the People’s Republic of China" 73 (73): 86-98, 2005

60 Worden, J. W., "Grief counseling and grief therapy: A handbook for the mental health practitioner" Springer Publishing Company 2018

61 Jordan, J. R., "Grief after suicide: Understanding the consequences and caring for the survivors" Routledge 2011

62 Christianson, C. L., "Constructing bridges of support : School counsellors’ experiences of student suicide" 42 (42): 209-221, 2008

63 Kane, M., "Concept mapping for planning and evaluation" Sage Publications 2007

64 Rodgers, R. F., "Clinical handbook of bereavement and grief reactions" Humana Press 1-18, 2018

65 Parrish, M., "Clinical challenges following an adolescent’s death by suicide : Bereavement issues faced by family, friends, schools, and clinicians" 33 (33): 81-102, 2005

66 Maple, M., "Carers’ Motivations for, and Experiences of, Participating in Suicide Research" 17 (17): 1733-1748, 2020

67 Andriessen, K., "Can postvention be prevention?" 30 (30): 43-47, 2009

68 Hart, S. R., "Best practices in school crisis prevention and intervention" National Association of School Psychologists 525-548, 2012

69 Currier, J. M., "Bereavement, religion, and posttraumatic growth : A matched control group investigation" 5 (5): 69-77, 2013

70 Kristensen, P., "Bereavement and mental health after sudden and violent losses : A review" 75 (75): 76-97, 2012

71 Abrutyn, S., "Are suicidal behaviors contagious in adolescence? Using longitudinal data to examine suicide suggestion" 79 : 211-227, 2014

72 Shields, C., "Angels of courage : The Experiences of mothers who have been bereaved by suicide" 80 (80): 175-201, 2019

73 Suicide Prevention Resource Center, "After a suicide: A toolkit for schools"

74 Paul, S. M, "Advancing education and support around death, dying, and bereavement : Hospices, schools, and health promoting palliative care" The University of Edinburgh 2015

75 McManus, E., "Addressing the bereavement needs of children in school : An evaluation of bereavement training for school communities" 22 (22): 72-85, 2019

76 Sturrock, K., "A multidimensional scaling stress evaluation table" 12 : 49-60, 2000

77 중앙자살예방센터, "2020 자살통계 자료집"

78 경향신문, "10대가 아프다. 대구 자살 여중생 담임교사의 심경고백"

79 노형진, "(SPSS 및 EXCEL을활용한)다변량분석 이론과 실제" 지필미디어 2016