구현주의 인지 vs. 계산주의 인지 = 윤보석 교수의 계산주의와 구현주의 양립론 비판

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In 2007 I wrote an article concerning the theory of embodied mind. In it, the computational theory of mind was mentioned marginally and briefly. Thereafter Prof. Bosuk Yoon cited in his article that was published in 2008, a sentence from my work and then raised some criticisms that I had misunderstood the computational theory of mind and, as a result of it, wrongly had taken the two positions for incompatible. Meanwhile Prof. Yoon, who belongs to the camp of the externalized computational theory of mind. argues that the computational theory of mind and the theory of embodied mind are both compatible. A major reason for this is that the computational theory of mind, just same as the theory of embodied mind, sees also body, environment and circumstances as needed for the explanation of the mind. In this article I raise some comments on his misinterpretation of my article and raise some reasons why his arguments are not convincing in reconciling the two positions. As a result, I try to show that the theory of embodied mind is much better than the extended computational theory of mind in explaining the mind or cognition. During this discussion, some core ideas of the theory of embodied mind will be presented.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이기흥, "현대에서의 구현주의적 전회" 철학연구회 (79) : 319-338, 2007

2 윤보석, "계산주의는 구현주의와 양립가능한가? 인간과 환경의 경계에 대한 한 고찰" 철학연구회 (83) : 187-209, 2008

3 Wilson, Robert A., "Wide Computationalism" 103 : 351-372, 1994

4 Glenberg, Arthur M., "What memory is for" 20 : 1-55, 1997

5 Marr D., "Vision: A Computational Investigation into the Human Representation and Processing of Visual Information" W. H. Freeman and Company 29-61, 1982

6 Pfeifer, R., "Understanding Intelligence" MIT Press 1999

7 Harnad, S., "The symbol grounding problem" 42 : 335-346, 1990

8 Clark A., "The extended mind" 58 : 10-23, 1998

9 Brown, J. S., "Situated Cognition and the Culture of Learning" 18 : 32-42, 1989

10 Lakoff, G., "Philosophy in the flesh, the embodied mind and its challenge to western thought" Basic Books 1999

11 Searle, J., "Minds, Brains and Programs" 3 : 417-457, 1980

12 Dreyfus, H. L., "Intelligence without representation-Merleau-Ponty’s critique of mental representation. The relevance of phenomenology to scientific explanatio" 1 : 367-383, 2002

13 Brooks, R. A., "Intelligence without representation" 47 : 139-159, 1991

14 McClamrock, Ron, "Existential Cognition, Computational Minds in the World" University of Chicago Press 1995

15 Proffitt, D. R., "Embodied Perception and the Economy of Action" 1 (1): 110-122, 2006

16 Anderson, M. L., "Embodied Cognition: A field guide" 149 : 91-130, 2003

17 Campos, J. J., "Early experience and emotional development: the emergence of fear of heights" 3 : 61-64, 1992

18 Smith, Linda B., "Development as a Dynamic System" 7 : 343-348, 2003

19 Turing, A., "Computing Machinary and Intelligence" 59 : 433-460, 1950

20 Hutchins E., "Cognition in the Wild" MIT Press 1995