커뮤니케이션 네트워크와 시간압박이 집단만족도에 미치는 영향 = Impacts of Communication Networks and Time Pressure upon Group Satisfaction

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of communication networks on group satisfaction under situation of time-pressure in four-person groups. The communication networks were divided into wheel, circle and concom according to degree of participation. The time-pressure was manipulated by varying the use of time reminders.
The group satisfaction produced significant difference among three networks. The group satisfaction was presented more high in order of concom, circle and wheel network. The wheel network was classified into centralization network, whereas the circle and concom network were classified into decentralization network. The group satisfaction did not produced significant difference between circle and concom. But the group satisfaction produced significant difference between centralization network and decentralization network. That is, the decentralization network was present more high group satisfaction than the centralization network.
The communication networks affected differently on group satisfaction according to the degree of time-pressure. The group satisfaction was not presented significant difference among wheel, circle, and concom under low time pressure situation, whereas the group satisfaction was presented more high in order of concom, circle and wheel under high time pressure situation. The group satisfaction did not present significant difference between circle network and concom network according to the degree of time pressure. But the group satisfaction produced significant difference between centralization network and decentralization network according to the degree of time pressure. That is, the centralization network reduced group satisfaction but the decentralization network increased group satisfaction under high time pressure situation.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구에서는 집단에서 형성되는 의사소통의 패턴에 따라 집단만족도가 어떻게 달라지를 알아보고자 하였다. 네트워크를 참여도에 따라 바퀴형, 원형, 완전연결형의 세 가지 네트워크를 구분하여 집단만족도에 대한 효과를 연구하였는데, 커뮤니케이션 네트워크의 참여도가 높을수록 집단만족도가 높아진다는 사실을 규명하였다. 즉 의사소통의 통로가 모두 개방된 완전연결형이 가장 높은 집단만족도를 나타냈으며, 인접한 사람들과 의사소통을 할 수 있는 원형에서 그 다음으로 높은 집단만족도를 보였고, 한 사람에게 의사소통 경로가 집중되는 바퀴형에서 가장 낮은 집단만족도를 보였다. 그리고 이들 세 개의 네트워크를 집중형 네트워크와 분산형 네트워크로 분류하여 비교분석하였다. 즉 의사소통에 참여할 기회가 집단구성원 모두에게 동등하게 부여되는 원형과 완전연결형은 분산형 네트워크로 분류하고, 한 구성원에게 의사소통이 집중되는 바퀴형은 집중형 네트워크로 분류하였다. 그 결과, 분산형 네트워크의 원형과 완전연결형 간에는 집단만족도가 유의한 차이를 보이지 않았다. 그러나 집중형 네트워크와 분산형 네트워크 간에는 집단만족도가 유의한 차이를 보였다. 즉 분산형 네트워크가 집중형 네트워크보다 집단만족도가 훨씬 더 높게 나타났다. 본 연구의 결과는 이전의 독립성 가설에서 주장한 바와 같이, 집단구성원의 독립성이 높을수록 집단만족도 높아짐을 확인하였다. 또한 시간압박은 분산기억이론에서 주장한 바와 같이 ‘누가 무엇을 알고 있는지’에 대한 분산기억을 저해함으로써 만족도가 낮아지는 것으로 해석되었다

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Cohen, "” Journal of Communication" 116-124, 1961

2 Shaw, "” In L Papers from advances in experimental social psychology" Academic Press 351-361, 1978

3 Shaw, "” In L Advance in Experimental Social Psychology" 1964

4 Monge, "” In C A handbook for the study of human communication" 107-138, 1988

5 Fisher, "” In B" McGraw- Hill 1980

6 "” Academy of Management Review" 465-476, 1990

7 Gladstein, "” Academy of Management Journal" 613-627, 1985

8 Argote, "“To centralize or not to centralize The effects of uncertainty and threat on group structure and performance" 58-74, 1989

9 Clampitt, "“Time for reflection A factor analytic studt of the communication satisfaction instrument ” Paper presented to the International Communication Association" 1987

10 "“Theoretical functions for centrality measures ” American Journal of Sociometry" 35-41, 1991

11 Wheeless, "“The relationships of communication with supervisor and decision-participation to employee job satisfaction" 22-232, 1984

12 Hunt, "“The impact of a communication intervention on work- unit productivity and employee satisfaction ” Journal of Applied Communication Research" 57-68, 1983

13 Kelly, "“The effects of time scarcity and time abundance on group performance quality and interaction process ” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology" 542-571, 1992

14 Bourgeois, "“The effects of different organizational environments upon decisions about organizational structure ” Academy of Management Journal" 508-514, 1978

15 Ed, "“The concept of crisis as viewed by the United States Department of State ” In Hermann" Free Press 1972

16 MacKenzie, "“The Information of theoretic entropy function as a total expected participation index for communication network experiments" 249-254, 1966b

17 MacKenzie, "“Structure centrality in communications networks" 17-25, 1966a

18 Isenberg, "“Some effects of time-pressure on vertical structure and decision- making accuracy in small groups" 119-134, 1981

19 Shaw, "“Some effects of problem complexity upon problem solution efficiency in different communication nets ” Journal of Experimental Psychology" 211-217, 1954a

20 Shaw, "“Some effects of irrelevant information upon problem-solving by small groups ” Journal of Social Psychology" 33-37, 1958

21 Leavitt, "“Some effects of certain communication patterns on group performance ” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology" 38-50, 1951

22 Shaw, "“Some effects of unequal distribution of information upon group performance in various communication nets ” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology" 547-553, 1954b

23 Hermann, "“Some consequences of crisis which limit the viability of organizations" 61-82,

24 Schoonhoven, "“Problems with contingency theory Testing assumptions hidden within the language of contingency theory" 349-377, 1981

25 "“Mutual influence in expressive behavior" 101-132, 1981

26 Wofford, "“Meta-analysis of the antecedents of personal goal level and of the antecedents and consequence of goal commitment ” Journal of Management" 595-615, 1992

27 Campbell, "“Factors contributing to job satisfaction and job dissatisfaction in six occupation groups" 143-174, 1967

28 Kelly, "“Effects of time limits and task types on task performance and interaction of four-person groups ” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology" 395-407, 1985

29 Smart, "“Design for crisis decision units" 640-657, 1977

30 Hutte, "“Decision-making in a management game" 5-20, 1965

31 Hwang, "“Decision making under time pressure A model for information systems research" 1994197-203

32 Smart, "“Crisis responses of competing versus noncompeting organizations ” In C Studies on crisis management Institute For Research on Public Policy" 1978

33 Dunbar, "“Crisis development and strategic response in European corporations ” In C Studies in crisis management Institute For Research on Public Policy" 1978

34 Bavelas, "“Communication patterns in task-oriented groups ” In D" 461-482, 1950

35 "“Communication and attitudes toward work-related change ” Journal of Applied Communication Research" 1-6, 1983

36 Hubbell, "“An input-output approach to clique identification" 377-399, 1965

37 Bavelas, "“An Experimental Approach to Organizational Communication" -371, 1950

38 Billings, "“A model of crisis perception" 300-316, 1980

39 Downs, "“A factor analytic study of communication satisfaction ” Journal of Business Communication" 63-74, 1977

40 Downs, "“A case study of the relationship between communication satisfaction and organizational commitment in two Australian organizations University of Kansas" ” Unpublished master’s thesis 1991

41 Level, "“A case study of human communications in an urban bank" 1959

42 Richmond, "tolerance for disagreement and innovativeness as predictors of employee satisfaction A comparison of single-factor" 359-373, 1979

43 Connolly, "some alternative to omniscience in complex problem solving" 69-01, 1980

44 Soonhee, "rticipative management and job satisfaction: Lessons for management leadership" 62 : 2-, 2002

45 Smith, "ecision making under time pressure: an investigation of decision speed and decision quality of computer-supported groups" 11 (11): 97-126, 1997

46 Wright, "distractions and the use of evidence ” Journal of Marketing Research" Time pressures 429-443, 1974

47 Downs, "Unpublished University of Kansas" 1990

48 Moreland, "Transactive memory in dynamic organizations" Mahwah 135-162, 2003

49 Moreland, "Training people to work in groups" New York: Plenum Press 37-60, 1998

50 Kelly, "Time pressure and group performance: Exploring underlying process in the attentional focus model" 40 : 185-198, 2004

51 Perlow, "The time famine: Toward a sociology of work time" 44 : 57-81, 1999

52 Rodwell, "The relationship among work-related perceptions, employee attitudes and employee performance: The integral role of communication" 37 (37): 277-293, 1998

53 Winstead, "The quality of friendships at work and job satisfaction" 12 (12): 199-215, 1995

54 Shaw, "The psychology of small group behavior" McGraw-Hill 111-147, 1981

55 Hayne, "The Use of Pattern- Communication Tools and Team Pattern Recognition" 48 (48): 377-390, 2005

56 Orpen, "The Interactive effects of communication quality and job involvement on managerial job satisfaction and work motivation" 121 : 5-, 1997

57 vPavitt, "Small group communication: A Theoretical Approach" 1998

58 Maister, "Practice what you preach" The free press: New York 2001

59 Pettit, "Organizational communication: Is it a moderator of the relationship between job congruence and job performance/satisfaction?" 19 (19): 664-672, 2002

60 Parks, "Group discussion as affected by number of alternatives and by a time limit" 62 : 265-275, 1995

61 Kelly, "Group decision making: The effects of initial preferences and time pressure" 25 : 1342-1354, 1999

62 Goris, "Effects of communication direction on job performance and satisfaction: A moderated regression analysis" 37 (37): 348-368, 2000

63 Bronner, "Decision making under time pressure" Lexington 1982

64 Redding, "Communication within the organization An interpretative review of theory and research" Inc 1978

65 Hirokawa, "Communication and group decision-making effectiveness" Thousand Oaks 269-300, 1996

66 Thayer, "Communication and communication systems" III : 1969

67 Hayne, "Chunking and team pattern recognition" Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences 2004

68 Pettit, "An examination of organizational communication as a moderator of the relationship between job performance and job satisfaction" 3 (3): 81-98, 1997

69 Fry, "A test of a contingency model ” Academy of Management Journal" 221-246, 1984

70 Clampitt, "A review of the literature University of Kansas" Unpublished paper 1987

71 Janis, "A psychological analysis of conflict" Free Press 1977

72 Downs, "A cross-culture comparison of relationships between organizational commitment and organizational communication" Albuquerque, NM 1995

73 Wegner, "A contemporary analysis of the group mind ” In M Theories of Group Behavior" Springer- Verlag 1986185-205