The relationship between religion and corruption: are the proposed causal links empirically valid?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

There is a growing interest in understanding how religion affects corruption. Many empirical studies have suggested that countries with strong hierarchical religions (such as Islam, Catholicism and Orthodox Christianity) are more likely to suffer from corruption. These results are, however, controversial, largely due to the lack of empirical validity of the causal (or theoretical) links that explain such a relationship: obedience to authority, negative culture reinforcement, amoral familism and trust intermediation. Using the fourth wave World Values Survey (n = 87,988) of 64 countries, this study constructed a general estimation equation model to evaluate these four causal links after controlling for heterogeneity of individuals’ religious beliefs among the 64 countries. We did not find strong evidentiary support for the causal explanations.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Alesina, A, "Who trusts others" 85 : 207-234, 2002

2 Husted, B. W, "Wealth, culture, and corruption" 30 (30): 339-360, 1999

3 La Porta, R, "Trust in large organizations" 87 (87): 334-338, 1997

4 Knack, S, "Trade intensity, country size and corruption" 4 (4): 1-18, 2003

5 Kim, S.-E, "The role of trust in the modern administrative state: An integrative model" 37 (37): 611-635, 2005

6 Banfield, E. C, "The moral basis of a backward society" Free Press 1958

7 Durkheim, É, "The elementary forms of the religious life" Free Press 1965

8 Treisman, D, "The causes of corruption: A cross-national study" 76 (76): 399-457, 2000

9 Weber, M, "The Protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism" Penguin Classics 2002

10 Ellison, C. G, "Obedience and autonomy: Religion and parental values reconsidered" 32 (32): 313-329, 1993

11 Hair, J. F, "Multivariate data analysis" Prentice Hall 2006

12 Glaeser, E. L, "Measuring trust" 115 (115): 811-846, 2000

13 Putnam, R. D, "Making democracy work: Civic traditions in modern Italy" Princeton University Press 1993

14 Robinson, R. V, "Is trust in others declining in America? An age-periodcohort analysis" 30 (30): 117-145, 2001

15 Wooldridge, J. M, "Introductory econometrics: A modern approach" South-Western Cengage Learning 2009

16 Sandholtz, W, "International integration and national corruption" 57 (57): 761-800, 2003

17 Lambsdorff, J. G, "International handbook on the economics of corruption" Edward Elgar 3-51, 2006

18 Swamy, A, "Gender and corruption" 64 (64): 25-55, 2001

19 Ko, K, "Evaluation of international corruption indexes: Should we believe them or not" 47 (47): 508-540, 2010

20 Sosis, R, "Does religion promote trust? The role of signaling, reputation, and punishment" 1 (1): 2005

21 Khatab, S, "Democracy in Islam" Routledge 2007

22 Lipset, S. M, "Culture matters: How values shape human progress" Basic Books 112-124, 2000

23 Mauro, P, "Corruption: Causes, consequences, and agenda for further research" 35 (35): 11-14, 1998

24 Sandholtz, W, "Corruption, culture, and communism" 15 (15): 109-131, 2005

25 Wraith, R, "Corruption in developing countries" George Allen & Unwin 1963

26 Quah, J. S. T, "Corruption in Asian countries: Can it be minimized" 59 (59): 483-494, 1999

27 Dreher, A, "Corruption around the world: Evidence from a structural model" 35 (35): 443-466, 2007

28 Arvate, P. R, "Corruption and the size of government: Causality tests for OECD and Latin American countries" 17 : 1013-1017, 2009

29 Uslaner, E. M, "Corruption and the new institutional economics" Routledge 76-92, 2004

30 Paldam, M, "Corruption and religion adding to the economic model" 54 (54): 383-413, 2001

31 Nye, J. S, "Corruption and political development: A cost-benefit analysis" 61 (61): 417-427, 1967

32 Rose-Ackerman, S, "Corruption and government: Causes, consequences, and reform" Cambridge University Press 1999

33 Hope, K. R, "Corruption and development in Africa: Lessons from country case-studies" St. Martin’s Press 1999

34 Klitgaard, R. E, "Controlling corruption" University of California Press 1988

35 Putnam, R. D, "Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community" Simon & Schuster 2000

36 Sandholtz, W, "Accounting for corruption: Economic structure, democracy and trade" 44 (44): 31-50, 2000

37 King, G, "A solution to the ecological inference problem: Reconstructing individual behavior from aggregate data" Princeton University Press 1997

38 You, J.-S, "A comparative study of inequality and corruption" 70 (70): 136-157, 2005

39 World Values Survey Association, "2005 World Values Survey"