탈레반, 미진한 국민국가 형성, 그리고 아프가니스탄의 정치 불안정 = Taleban, Deficient Modern State Building, and Political Instability in Afghanistan

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

While acknowledging the negative impact of Islamism, this paper is based on hypothesis that Afghanistan s inherent problems, especially the deficient nation-state building, have a greater impact on political instability. To test this hypothesis, this study identified perspectives that explain various variables for political instability and evaluated the degree of Afghan nation-state formation. Furthermore, in order to determine which of the two independent variables, Islamism and nation-state building, had a more adverse effect on Afghan political instability, a quantitative analysis of books, articles, and reports related to instability of Afghanistan inside ‘Google Scholar’ was conducted to find the more appropriate independent variable The results of the analysis shows that academia also found that the incomplete nation-state formation is more influential on instability in Afghanistan than Islamism. In addition, a simple and straight-forward survey to understand the perspectives of local Afghan people revealed that the majority of locals also view that the deficient nation-state building has contributed more to ongoing instability than extreme Islamism.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 서론 Ⅱ. 아프가니스탄의 정치 불안정 성격 Ⅲ. 아프간 (국민)국가 형성의 한계 Ⅳ. 정치 불안정: 이슬람주의 vs. 국민국가 형성 Ⅴ. 결론 참고문헌

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 인남식, "탈레반 집권 후 아프가니스탄 내외 역학관계, IFANS 주요국제문제분석 제20호"

2 이웅현, "점령군 철수 이후 아프가니스탄의 ‘국가건설’ 문제: 근대화의 도식은 여전히 유효한가?" 사단법인 아시아문화학술원 9 (9): 527-540, 2018

3 이종철, "전후재건의 내생적(內生的) 영향 요인 고찰 - 아프가니스탄 사례를 중심으로" (사) 한국전략문제연구소 17 (17): 123-160, 2010

4 윤민우, "이슬람 극단주의와 강한 부족 전통의 통합작용이 아프가니스탄의 민족국가 건설의 혼란과 안보의 위기로서의 테러리즘과 마약 거래에 미친 영향" 위기관리 이론과 실천 8 (8): 155-176, 2012

5 최윤철, "아프가니스탄전쟁의 장기화 원인에 대한 연구 - 통일과정에 주는 함의를 바탕으로 -" 인문학연구원 77 : 325-361, 2019

6 윤민우, "아프가니스탄 지역 파슈툰 부족의 안보/치안시스템: 국가권력과 탈레반 테러세력 사이의 안보/치안서비스 경쟁" 한국경찰연구학회 10 (10): 85-119, 2011

7 정태식, "아프가니스탄 국가건설의 불안정에 대한 역사사회학적 일고찰: 미시적 정체성과 거시적 정체성의 대립을 중심으로" 사회과학연구원 3 (3): 35-66, 2010

8 김강석, "신냉전과 중동 정치 질서 변용: 레이건 대 아프가니스탄 전략의 공세적 변화와 급진 이슬람주의 형성" 중동연구소 37 (37): 31-56, 2018

9 정상률, "사우디아라비아 근대 국민국가 형성 연구 - Saud家와 와합주의자의 권력엘리트화를 중심으로" 인문과학연구소 37 (37): 187-214, 2016

10 김강석, "불완전 주권과 중동의 정치 불안정" 한국이슬람학회 30 (30): 91-112, 2020

11 Lusset, Bruce M, "World Handbook of Political and Social Indicators" Yale University Press 1964

12 Gurr Ted R., "Why Men Rebel" Princeton University Press 1980

13 Malejacq, Romain, "Warlord Survival: The Delusion of State Building in Afghanistan" Cornell University Press 2019

14 Saroha, Akshaya, "Understanding The Instability In Afghanistan" 23 (23): 118-129, 2019

15 Lederer, Edith M, "UN Security Council: Taliban Must Form Inclusive Afghan Govt" AP News

16 Sardania, Khalilollah, "The Social Challenges of Modern State-Building in Afghanistan" 3 (3): 37-63, 2021

17 Middle East Institute, "The Islamic State in Afghanistan: Examining its Threat to Stability" Policy Focus Series

18 Erfan, Abdul. H, "The Geopolitical Influential Components in the Afghan Crisis" 3 (3): 36-43, 2021

19 Issa, Alex, "The Fragmented Middle East: Persistent Insecurity" Rising Instability 2021

20 Rahman, Amini Abdul, "The Development of the Political System in Afghanistan: Current Perspective in the Context of National Consensus-Building" 12 : 1-10, 2019

21 Feierabend, Ivo. K, "The Comparative Study of Revolution and Violence" 5 (5): 393-424, 1973

22 Greentree, Todd, "Strategic Failure in Afghanistan" 44 (44): 117-140, 2021

23 Kohli, Atul, "State-Directed Development: Political Power and Industrialization in the Global Periphery" Cambridge University Press 2004

24 Schneider, Peter. R, "Social Mobilization, Political Institutions, and Political Violence: a cross-national analysis" 4 (4): 69-90, 1971

25 Trani, Jean-Francois, "Poverty, Vulnerability, and Provision of Healthcare in Afghanistan" 70 (70): 1745-1755, 2010

26 Ali, Hassanein, "Post-Arab spring: The Arab world between the dilemma of the nation-state and the rise of violent non-state actors (VNSAs)" 14 (14): 68-83, 2020

27 Bradford, James. T, "Poppies, Politics, and Power: Afghanistan and the global history of drugs and diplomacy" Cornell University Press 2019

28 Lipset, Seymour M, "Political Man: The Social Bases of Politics" Johns Hopkins University Press 1960

29 Shinoda, Hideaki, "Peace-building and State-building from the Perspective of the Historical Development of International Society" 18 (18): 25-43, 2018

30 Hibbs, Douglas A, "Mass Political Violence: A Cross-national Causal Analysis" Wiley 1973

31 Cavdar, Gamze, "Islamist Rationality: An Assessment of the Rational Choice Approach" 5 : 584-608, 2012

32 Alesina, Alberto, "Income Distribution, Political Instability, and Investment" 40 (40): 1203-1228, 1996

33 Hussain, Fayaz, "Implications of the Enigmatic Rise of Taliban: A Historical Perspective" 6 (6): 1-7, 2021

34 Wu, MengYun, "Impact of Terrorism and Political Instability on Equity Premium: Evidence from Pakistan" 492 : 1753-1762, 2018

35 Jabarkhail, Sami, "Human Resource Development: Why It Matters in the National Context of Afghanistan" 6 (6): 292-306, 2019

36 Lobel, Oved, "How Afganistan’s Fall to the Taliban Increases the Global Terrorism Threat" The Strategist

37 Berman, Sheri, "From the Sun King to Karzai: Lessons for State Building in Afghanistan" 89 (89): 2-8, 2010

38 Khan, Muhammad, "Ethnic Conflict and the Political Instability in Afghanistan" 4 (4): 2021

39 Muller, Edward. N, "Cross-national Variation in Political Violence: A rational action approach" 34 (34): 624-651, 1990

40 Rahmani, Zaid, "Corruption in Afghanistan:an Experience for Ukraine" (2) : 27-32, 2018

41 Powell, G. Bingham, "Contemporary Democracies: Participation, Stability and Violence" Havard University Press 1982

42 Hille, Charlotte, "Clans and Democratization: Chechnya, Albania, Afghanistan and Iraq" Brill 149-186, 2020

43 Ares, Macarena, "Changing Classes, Changing Preferences: how social class mobility affects economic preferences" 43 (43): 1211-1237, 2020

44 Call, Charles T, "Beyond the ‘Failed State’: Toward conceptual alternatives" 17 (17): 303-326, 2010

45 Pye, Lucian W., "Aspects of Political Development" Little, Brown & Co 1966

46 Andisha, Nasir A, "An Enduring Lesson from the History of Peacemaking in Afghanistan" 57 (57): 331-343, 2020

47 Lieven, Anatol, "An Afghan Tragedy: The Pashtuns, the Taliban and the State" 63 (63): 7-36, 2021

48 Cooper, Rachel, "Aid Dependency and Political Settlements in Afghanistan" K4D

49 Ibrahimi, S. Yaqub, "Afghanistan’s Political Development Dilemma:The Centralist State Versus a Centrifugal Society" 14 (14): 40-61, 2019

50 Wani, Zahoor Ahmad, "Afghanistan’s Neo-Taliban Puzzle" 41 (41): 220-237, 2021

51 Wyatt, Christopher M, "Afghanistan: The Failure to Integrate Dinm Daulat, Watan and Millat and the Fall of King Amanullah" 52 (52): 79-109, 2021

52 Nazir, Nurgiss, "Afghanistan: A Land of Diversity" 16 (16): 34-43, 2018