베트남 대학생의 학습역량 착각현상 분석 = Analysis of the Illusion of Competence in Vietnamese University Students' Learning

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study was to identify three kinds of the illusion of competence in learning process for the Vietnamese students who attend to the teachers college. First, as the result of identifying the concordance of ranking in 10 learning strategies on the frequency of use and the degree of the effectiveness of the 418 students who took the course A(Ho Chi Minh’s Thought; 163) and B(General Laws; 255), there was an illusion of competence that students frequently used low utility learning strategies, and they regarded these as the most effective. Second, there was the phenomenon called Dunning-Kruger effect that the highest performing students tended to underestimate their final test scores, whereas the lowest performing students overestimate their scores when they were asked to predict their final test scores a week before they took the test. Third, there were significant differences between predicted scores and actual scores in the group which spent a relatively moderate amount of learning time(1~2 hours) by comparison with the group that spent less than 1 hour and the group that spent more than 2 hours. This trend might be explained by the Dunning-Kruger effect regardless of the allocation of study time. It was confirmed that the actual scores and predicted scores did not increase in proportion with the time devoted to learning. Therefore, it is necessary to consider the quality of the learning time, and to identify the relationship between the study time and the actual scores based on it.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

이 연구는 베트남 대학생이 학습과정에서 경험하는 역량의 착각현상 3가지를 확인하고자 하였다. 첫째, A(호치민 사상)과목과 B(일상법)과목을 수강하는 163명과 255명(총 418명)을 대상으로, 10가지 학습전략에 대한 사용정도와 효과성정도 판단의 순위 일치도를 확인한 결과 유용성 낮은 전략을 가장 높은 순위로 사용하면서 그 효과성 또한 가장 높게 판단하는 역량의 착각현상을 확인하였다. 둘째, 기말시험 일주일 전, 예상성적을 묻고 실제성적과의 차이를 비교한 결과, 학업성취가 높은 학생들은 예상성적을 실제성적보다 과소추정하였으며 학업성취가 낮은 학생들은 예상성적을 실제성적보다 과대추정하는 경향인 더닝-크루거 효과를 확인하였다. 셋째, 학습투자시간과 예상성적 및 실제성적을 비교한 결과, 상대적으로 중간 정도(1~2시간 미만)의 학습시간을 투자한 경우가 보다 적은 시간(1시간 미만)을 투자한 경우뿐만 아니라 더 많은 시간(2시간 이상)을 투자한 경우와는 달리 두 성적간 유의미한 차이가 있었다. 이런 경향은 학습투자시간과 관계없이 학업성취수준이 낮은 학생은 예상성적을 과대추정하고 높은 학생은 과소추정하는 현상 때문으로 짐작된다. 학습투자시간에 비례하여 실제성적과 예상성적이 일관되게 높지 않음이 확인되어, 학습투자시간의 질적인 측면을 고려하는 방안과 그에 따른 실제성적과의 관련성을 확인할 필요가 있다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 석보영, "학습판단에 반영된 역량의 착각 현상 분석" 대한사고개발학회 15 (15): 27-48, 2019

2 석보영, "학습전략의 효과성 판단에서 역량의 착각 원인 분석" 대한사고개발학회 15 (15): 73-95, 2019

3 석보영, "학습전략 판단에서의 역량착각 현상에 대한 혼합연구" 경북대학교 2020

4 강이철, "시험치기 학습전략의 이론적 근거와 활용 실태" 대한사고개발학회 13 (13): 41-66, 2017

5 석보영, "성취목표 지향유형과 학습전략의 효과성 판단이 학습전략의 사용에 미치는 효과" 대한사고개발학회 16 (16): 1-29, 2020

6 Plant, E. A., "Why study time does not predict grade point average across college students : implications of deliberate practice for academic performance" 30 (30): 96-116, 2005

7 Schmidt, R. M., "Who maximizes what? A study in student time allocation" 73 : 23-28, 1983

8 Miller, T. M., "Unskilled but aware : Reinterpreting overconfidence in low-performing students" 37 (37): 502-506, 2011

9 Kruger, J., "Unskilled and unaware of it : How difficulties in recognizing one’s own incompetence lead to inflated self-assessments" 77 (77): 1121-1134, 1999

10 Einstein, G. O., "The testing effect : Illustrating a fundamental concept and changing study strategies" 39 (39): 190-193, 2012

11 Callender, A. A., "The limited benefits of rereading educational texts" 34 (34): 30-41, 2009

12 Grave, B. S., "The effect of student time allocation on academic achievement" 19 (19): 291-310, 2011

13 Lumsden, K. G., "The economics student reexamined : Male-female differences in comprehension" 18 : 365-375, 1987

14 Didia, D., "The determinants of performance in the university introductory finance course" 8 : 102-107, 1998

15 Gadzella, B. M., "Study skills, self-concept, and academic achievement" 54 (54): 923-929, 1984

16 Kornell, N., "Study efficacy and the region of proximal learning framework" 32 (32): 609-622, 2006

17 Allen, G. J., "Study behaviors and their relationships to test anxiety and academic performance" 30 (30): 407-410, 1972

18 Krohn, G. A., "Student effort and performance over the semester" 36 (36): 3-28, 2005

19 Bjork, R. A., "Self-regulated learning : Beliefs, techniques, and illusions" 64 (64): 417-444, 2013

20 Yip, M. C. W., "Relation of study strategies to the academic performance of Hong Kong University Students" 90 (90): 338-340, 2002

21 Nonis, S. A., "Performance of college students : Impact of study time and study habits" 85 (85): 229-238, 2010

22 Clayson, D. E., "Performance Overconfidence : Metacognitive effects or misplaced student expectations" 27 (27): 122-129, 2005

23 Sawilowsky, S., "New effect size rules of thumb" 8 (8): 467-474, 2009

24 Muller, A., "Neural correlates of the Dunning-Kruger effect" 53 (53): 460-484, 2021

25 Karpicke, J. D., "Metacognitive strategies in student learning : Do students practise retrieval when they study on their own" 17 (17): 471-479, 2009

26 Karpicke, J. D., "Metacognitive control and strategy selection : Deciding to practice retrieval during learning" 138 (138): 469-486, 2009

27 McCabe, J., "Metacognitive awareness of learning strategies in undergraduates" 39 (39): 462-476, 2010

28 Arcand, J. L., "Matching in community-based organizations" 98 (98): 203-219, 2012

29 Townsend, C. L., "Judgments of learning and improvement" 39 (39): 204-216, 2011

30 Morehead, K., "Instructor and student knowledge of study strategies" 24 (24): 257-271, 2015

31 Rakoff, D., "Incompetence is bliss"

32 Dunlosky, J., "Improving students' learning with effective learning techniques : Promising directions from cognitive and educational psychology" 14 (14): 4-58, 2013

33 Koriat, A., "Illusions of competence in monitoring one’s knowledge during study" 31 (31): 187-194, 2005

34 Susser, J. A., "From the lab to the dorm room : metacognitive awareness and use of spaced study" 41 (41): 345-363, 2012

35 Gurung, R. A. R., "Focusing on how student study" 10 (10): 28-35, 2010

36 Gortner L. A., "Factors associated with academic time use and academic performance of college students : A recursive approach" 41 (41): 544-556, 2000

37 Douglas, S., "Estimating educational production functions with correction for drops" 26 : 101-112, 1995

38 Jacoby, L. L., "Enhancing Human Performance, III" National Academy Press 57-80, 1994

39 Schuman, H., "Effort and reward : The assumption that college grades are affected by quantity of study" 63 (63): 945-966, 1985

40 Eliasson, A. H., "Early to bed, early to rise! Sleep habits and academic performance in college students" 14 (14): 71-75, 2009

41 Yip, M. C. W., "Differences between high and low academic achieving university students in learning and study strategies : A further investigation" 15 (15): 561-570, 2009

42 Chandler, P., "Cognitive load theory and the format of instruction" 8 (8): 293-332, 1991

43 Kennedy, E. J., "Blissful ignorance : The problem of unrecognized incompetence and academic performance" 24 (24): 243-252, 2002

44 Bjork, R. A., "Attention and performance XVII: Cognitive regulation of performance: Interaction of theory and application" MIT Press 435-459, 1999

45 Nonis, S. A., "Academic performance of college students : Influence of time spent studying and working" 81 (81): 151-159, 2006

46 Michaels, J. W., "Academic effort and college grades" 68 (68): 309-319, 1989