연구논문 : 재생가능에너지 의무할당제의 이론과 실제: RPS 도입국가들에 대한 분석을 바탕으로 = Theory and Practice of Renewable Portfolio Standards: Based on an Analysis of Nations with RPS

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Most countries have implemented renewable energy expansion policies in order to respond to climate change, strengthen energy security, and create job opportunities. This paper aims to identify conditions for successful renewable expansion by renewable portfolio standards (RPS) which is planned to be adopted by Korea in 2012, while carrying out a comparative case study for countries with RPS. For this purpose, five cases including the state of California, the state of Texas, Sweden, UK and Japan were selected and their historical achievement were analyzed in terms of expansion rates of RES-E, observance of mandatory quotas and cost-effectiveness. As a result, different from theoretical legitimacy, RPS was successful in only three cases such as the state of California, the State of Texas, and Sweden, other two cases such as the UK and Japan were not successful. This paper found the fact that sucess and failure of RPS depend on the scale and characteristics of renewables of individual country and institutional design of RPS. Consequently, RPS may achieve its policy goal only when these conditions are satisfied. This implies that Korea which does not have large-scale renewable sources needs to reconsider introduction of RPS or to complement RPS policy design for efficient renewable energy expansion.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 손성호, "해외 신재생에너지 의무할당제 시행사례 분석" 441-443, 2008

2 윤순진, "지속가능한 에너지체제로의 전환을 위한 에너지정책 개선방향: 재생가능에너지관련법･제도에 대한 비판적 검토룰 바탕으로" 14 (14): 269-300, 2003

3 이창호, "주요국의 신재생에너지 의무할당제(RPS) 운영사례" 59 (59): 22-27, 2010

4 홍정희, "재생가능에너지 활성화 정책 수단의 변경 타당성에 관한 연구: 발전차액 지원제도와 발전의무할당제도를 중심으로" 서울대학교 환경대학원 2009

5 윤순진, "재생가능에너지 산업을 통한 일자리 창출 에너지･환경･고용의 선순환" 131 : 20-27, 2008

6 김규판, "일본정부의 태양광발전 지원체계 및 시사점" 3 (3): 2-13, 2009

7 대한무역투자진흥공사, "일본 신재생에너지 산업 현황 및 전망" 2010

8 외환은행, "외환은행,2011"

9 최현경, "신･재생에너지 의무할당제도(RPS)와 발전차액지원제도(FIT)의 비교와 시사점" (1월) : 26-38, 2009

10 이창호, "신･재생에너지 의무할당제 (RPS) 시행방안 및 효과분석" 13-37, 2010

11 이창호, "신재생에너지 의무할당제(RPS) 국내운영방안수립" 2009

12 성낙환, "신재생에너지 의무할당제 영향과 기업의 대응" LG Business Insight 36-42, 2008

13 한국농촌경제연구원, "선진국 농업부문 바이오매스 이용활성화 정책과 시사" 2006

14 산림청, "산림기본통계" 2010

15 윤순진, "대규모 조력발전, 정말 친환경인가" (406) : 6-7, 2010

16 The Leaf Exchange, "http://www.theleafexchange.com"

17 SRECTrade, "http://www.srectrade.com/index.php"

18 Spectron Group Limited, "http://www.spectrongroup.com/market-data/market_analysis_RES/2011.php"

19 河野太郞, "http://korean.konotaro.org/2011/01/2011-01-07.php"

20 Department for Business Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, "UK Renewable Energy Strategy Consultation" Department for Business Enterprise and Regulatory Reform 2008

21 International Energy Agency, "Trends in photovoltaic applications survey report of selected IEA countries between 1992 and 2009" IEA 2010

22 Verhaegen, K., "Towards an international tradable green certificate system: The challenging example of Belgium" 13 (13): 208-215, 2009

23 Gross, R., "Time to stop experimenting with UK renewable energy policy, in ICEPT Working Paper" 2010

24 Commission of the European Communities, "The support of electricity from renewable energy sources - Accompanying document to the Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the promotion of the use of energy from renewables sources" CEC 57-, 2008

25 Swedish Energy Agency, "The electricity certificate system 2009, in ET2009: 40" Swedish Energy Agency 2009

26 Buckman, G., "The effectiveness of Renewable Portfolio Standard banding and carve-outs in supporting high-cost types of renewable electricity" Energy Policy, in Press 2011

27 European Commission, "The Support of renewable Energy Sources" 2005

28 Department of Energy, USA, 2011, Renewable Energy, "Texas Renewable Profile"

29 Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, "State of the World's Forests" 2009

30 Energy Information Agency, "State Electricity Profiles 2008" EIA 2010

31 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, "Special Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation" 2011

32 California Energy Commission, "Renewables Portfolio Standard 2006 Procurement Verification" 2010

33 United Kingdom, Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, "Renewables Obligation Annual Report 2009-2010" OFGEM 2011

34 United Kingdom, Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, "Renewables Obligation Annual Report 2007-2008" OFGEM 2009

35 Mitchell, C., "Renewable energy policy in the UK 1990-2003" 32 (32): 1935-1947, 2004

36 Iida, T., "Renewable energy policy and politics in Japan" ISEP 2007

37 International Energy Agency, "Renewable Information 2010" IEA 2010

38 Renewable Energy Policy Network for the 21st Century, "Renewable Global Status Report" REN21 2010

39 Sovacool, B., "Renewable Energy: Economically Sound, Politically Difficult" 21 (21): 18-29, 2008

40 조인승, "RPS시스템에서의 목표량부여방식 및 적용사례" 264-266, 2007

41 California Public Utilities Commision, "RPS Compliance Report"

42 Lauber, V., "REFIT and RPS: options for a harmonised Community framework" 32 (32): 1405-1414, 2004

43 Menanteau, P., "Prices versus quantities: choosing policies for promoting the development of renewable energy" 3 (3): 799-812, 2003

44 Horiuchi, C., "One policy makes no difference" 29 : 432-449, 2007

45 Schneider, M., "Nuclear Power in a Post-Fukushima World: 25 Years After Chernobyl Accident" Worldwatch Institute 2011

46 Ito, Y., "Newbuyback program for photovoltaic generation : Issue in the view of electric utilities industry policy"

47 Lipp, J., "Lessons for effective renewable electricity policy from Denmark, Germany and United Kingdom" 35 (35): 5481-5495, 2007

48 UNEP, "Green Jobs: Towards decent work in a sustainable, low-carbon world, in Review of International Experience with Renewable Energy Obligation Support Mechanisms" Energy Research Centre of the Netherlands Petten 2008

49 Global Wind Energy Council, "Global wind energy outlook 2010" GWEC 2010

50 이민식, "FIT와 RPS 제도비교 시사점" 산은경제연구소 2009

51 Wiser, R., "Evaluating experience with renewable portfolio standards in the United States" Lawrence Berkely National Laboratory 2004

52 International Energy Agency, "Electricity Information" IEA 2006

53 International Energy Agency, "Electricity Information" IEA 2010

54 Jacobsson, S., "EU renewable energy support policy: Faith or facts" 37 (37): 2143-2146, 2009

55 International Energy Agency, "Deploying Renewables-Principles for Effective Policies" IEA 2008

56 North Carolina Solar Center, "Database of State Incentives for Renewables & Efficiency"

57 IPCC, "Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change" Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Secretariat 2007

58 Jacobs, D., "Best Practice Examples -Quota Obligations and Tender Schemes" OSCE 2009

59 Bergek, A., "Are tradable green certificates a cost-efficient policy driving technical change or a rent-generating machine? Lessons from Sweden 2003-2008" 38 (38): 1255-1271, 2010