Political Development in Hong Kong: The Failure of Democratization

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Democratization in Hong Kong has come to a dead end following the rejection of an electoral reform proposal by the Legislative Council on June 18, 2015. The measure was voted down because pan-democrats had been deeply disappointed by the fact that the reform proposal by the Chinese government would have only allowed pre-screened candidates and thus denied Hong Kongers a true choice. This followed more than two months of street occupations in which protesters demanded real universal suffrage to no avail. This paper seeks to demonstrate how the “China factor” has inhibited the democratization process in four distinct phases of political development. Since World War II, one of the main reasons for the lack of democratization was opposition by the Chinese government. In the late 1980s, the prospect of political reforms in China raised hopes for political change in Hong Kong. This was, however, crushed in 1989, which empowered a democracy movement in Hong Kong. Since the transfer of power from Britain to China in 1997, despite protests for democracy, there has been very little progress toward meaningful democratization. Moreover, in recent years, there has even been a slow process from liberal to illiberal authoritarianism which is accompanied by growing conflicts and even violence as political freedoms are being curtailed.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Lian, Joseph Yizheng, "Why the ‘Fishball Revolution’ Must Prompt New Thinking" 2016

2 Lau Siu-kai, "Utilitarian Familism: The Basis of Political Stability in Hong Kong" Chinese University of Hong Kong 74-, 1978

3 Lam, Wai-man, "Understanding the Political Culture of Hong Kong: The Paradox of Activism and Depoliticization" ME Sharpe 2004

4 Ng, Jason, "Umbrellas in Bloom: Hong Kong’s Occupy Movement Uncovered" Blacksmith Books 2016

5 Lau, Stuart, "Top Justice Officials Back Independence of Hong Kong Courts"

6 Ortmann, Stephan, "The Umbrella Movement and Hong Kong’s Protracted Democratization Process" 46 (46): 32-50, 2015

7 Preston, Peter W., "The Politics of China-Hong Kong Relations: Living with Distant Masters" Edward Elgar 2016

8 Cai Yongshun, "The Occupy Movement in Hong Kong: Sustaining Decentralized Protest" Routledge 2016

9 So, Alvin Y., "The New Middle Class and the Democratic Movement in Hong Kong" 20 (20): 384-398, 1990

10 Sing, Ming, "The Legitimacy Problem and Democratic Reform in Hong Kong" 15 (15): 517-532, 2006

11 Chan, Anita, "The LegCo Election: What Happened, What it Means for Hong Kong’s Future, and Why you Should Care"

12 Ma Ngok, "The Hong Kong Special Administrative Region in Its First Decade" City University of Hong Kong Press 49-74, 2007

13 Hook, Brian, "The Government of Hong Kong: Change Within Tradition" 95 : 491-511, 1983

14 Cheng, Joseph Yu-shek, "The Emergence of Radical Politics in Hong Kong: Causes and Impact" 14 (14): 199-232, 2014

15 Scott, Ian, "The Disarticulation of Hong Kong’s Post-Handover Political System" 43 : 29-53, 2000

16 Chan, Ming K, "The Challenge of Hong Kong’s Reintegration with China" Hong Kong University Press 1-30, 1997

17 So, Alvin Y., "The Challenge of Hong Kong’s Reintegration with China" Hong Kong University Press 49-83, 1997

18 Staff Reporters, "Talks Fail to Narrow Gap between Student Leaders and Hong Kong Government"

19 Tai, Benny YT, "Tale of the Unexpected: Tung’s Resignation and the Ensuing Constitutional Controversy" 35 (35): 7-16, 2005

20 Fong, Brian, "State-Society Conflicts under Hong Kong’s Hybrid Regime" 53 (53): 854-882, 2013

21 Kwong, Ying-ho, "State-Society Conflict Radicalization in Hong Kong-The Rise of ‘Anti-China’ Sentiment and Radical Localism" 47 (47): 428-442, 2016

22 Lau Siu-kai, "Society and Politics in Hong Kong" Chinese University Press 1982

23 Butenhoff, Linda, "Social Movements and Political Reform in Hong Kong" Praeger 1999

24 Lim, Teresa, "Sealing Hongkong’s Fate"

25 Lee, Eddie, "Pro-Beijing Group Member Asks Hong Kong Court to Disqualify 11 Lawmakers over Legco Oaths"

26 Kuan Hsin-chi, "Power Dependence and Democratic Transition: The Case of Hong Kong" 128 : 774-793, 1991

27 Ortmann, Stephan, "Politics and Change in Singapore and Hong Kong: Containing Contention" Routledge 2010

28 Fung, Anthony YH, "Political Economy of Hong Kong Media: Producing a Hegemonic Voice" 17 (17): 159-171, 2007

29 Ma Ngok, "Political Development in Hong Kong, State, Political Society, and Civil Society" Hong Kong University Press 2007

30 Lam, Jermain TM, "Political Decay in Hong Kong after the Occupy Central Movement" 42 (42): 99-121, 2015

31 Lau Siu-Kai, "Partial Democratization,’ Foundation Moment’ and Political Parties in Hong Kong" 163 : 705-720, 2000

32 Baldwin, Claire, "One in Six Support Hong Kong Independence from China–Poll"

33 Chan, Kin-man, "Occupying Hong Kong" 12 (12): 1-7, 2015

34 Petersen, Carole J., "National Security and Fundamental Freedoms: Hong Kong’s Article 23" Hong Kong University Press 13-62, 2005

35 Lee, Francis L. F., "Media, Social Mobilisation and Mass Protests in Post-Colonial Hong Kong: The Power of a Critical Event" Routledge 2010

36 Cheung, Charles Chi-wai, "Media Power in Hong Kong: Hyper-Marketized Media and Cultural Resistance" Routledge 2016

37 Sautman, Barry, "Localists and ‘Locusts’ in Hong Kong:Creating a Yellow-Red Peril Discourse" 2 : 2015

38 Fong, Brian, "In-Between Liberal Authoritarianism and Electoral Authoritarianism: Hong Kong’s Democratization Under Chinese Sovereignty, 1997-2016"

39 Case, William, "Hybrid Politics and New Competitiveness: Hong Kong’s 2007 Chief Executive Election" 25 (25): 365-388, 2008

40 Lam, Oiwan, "How the Pro-Beijing Sing Pao Newspaper Turned Against CY Leung" Hong Kong Free Press 2016

41 Cheung, Gary Ka-wai, "Hong Kong’s Watershed: The 1967 Riots" Hong Kong University Press 2009

42 Sing, Ming, "Hong Kong’s Tortuous Democratization: A Comparative Analysis" Routledge Curzon 2004

43 So, Alvin Y., "Hong Kong’s Problematic Democratic Transition: Power Dependency or Business Hegemony?" 59 (59): 2000

44 Tiezzi, Shannon, "Hong Kong’s Legislature Rejects Beijing-Backed Election Plan" The Diplomat

45 Lo, Sonny Shiu-Hing, "Hong Kong’s Indigenous Democracy: Origins, Evolution and Contentions" Palgrave Macmillan 2015

46 Sing, Ming, "Hong Kong’s Democrats Hold Their Own" 20 (20): 98-112, 2009

47 Karacs, Sarah, "Hong Kong’s Air Quality Falls After Occupy Clearance Puts Traffic Back on the Roads" South China Morning Post

48 Cheng, Joseph Y. S., "Hong Kong: In Search of a Future" Oxford University Press 1984

49 Ma Ngok, "Hong Kong's Democrats Divide" 22 (22): 54-67, 2011

50 Yuen, Samson, "Hong Kong after the Umbrella Movement: An Uncertain Future for ‘One Country Two Systems" 2015 (2015): 49-53, 2015

51 Yeung SC, "Hong Kong Youth Start Entertaining Idea of Independence" 2014

52 Cheung, Tony, "Hong Kong Will Move on Controversial Security Law, CY Leung Says, as Beijing Bars Independence Activists from Legco" South China Morning Post

53 Fitzpatrick, Liam, "Hong Kong Makes History with First Pro-Independence Rally"

54 Yew Chiew Ping, "Hong Kong Identity on the Rise" 54 (54): 1088-1112, 2014

55 Chan, Thomas, "Hong Kong Bomb Plot a Conspiracy to Smear Us, Localists Claim, Ahead of Reform Vote" South China Morning Post

56 Undergrad, "Hoeng Gong Man Zuk Leon (Hong Kong Nationalism)" Hong Kong University Students’ Union 2014

57 Chin Wan, "Heung Gong Sing Bong Lun (Hong Kong as a City-State)" Enrich Publishing 2011

58 Yeung, Paul, "HK’s Political System Not a ‘Separation of Powers,’"

59 Pepper, Suzanne, "Elections, Political Change and Basic Law Government:The Hong Kong System in Search of a Political Form" 162 : 410-438, 2000

60 Ng, Ellie, "Elected Localist Lawmakers Barred from Hong Kong Legislature as Gov’t Wins Legal Challenge" Hong Kong Free Press 2016

61 Cheng, Joseph Y. S., "Democracy in Eastern Asia: Issues, Problems and Challenges in a Region of Diversity" Routledge 224-245, 2014

62 Tsang, Steve Yui-sang, "Democracy Shelved: Great Britain, China, and Attempts at Constitutional Reform in Hong Kong, 1945-1952" Oxford University Press 1988

63 Lo, Shiu-hing, "Decolonization and Political Development in Hong Kong:Citizen Participation" 28 (28): 613-629, 1988

64 Ku, Agnes Shuk-mei, "Contradictions in the Development of Citizenship in Hong Kong: Governance without Democracy" 49 (49): 505-527, 2009

65 Lo, Sonny Shiu-hing, "Competing Chinese Political Visions: Hong Kong Vs. Beijing on Democracy" Praeger 2010

66 Lim, Teresa, "Colony’s Slow Road to Democracy"

67 Ma Ngok, "Civil Society in Self-Defense: The Struggle Against National Security Legislation in Hong Kong" 14 (14): 465-482, 2005

68 Scott, Ian, "Chapter One: An Overview of the Hong Kong Legislative Council Elections of 1991" 13 (13): 11-37, 1991

69 Cheung, Tony, "CY Leung’s Hong Kong Independence Criticism Sparks Controversial Book Sales Rush"

70 Zhang Baohui, "Beijing’s 2007 Political Reform Plan and Prospects for Hong Kong’s Democratization" 17 (17): 442-464, 2010

71 Zheng Yongnian, "Beijing Responds to Hong Kong’s Democratization Movement: From Bureaucratic Control to Political Leadership" 33 (33): 235-256, 2007

72 Holliday, Ian, "After 1997: The Dialectics of Hong Kong Dependence" 34 (34): 254-270, 2004

73 King, Ambrose, "Administrative Absorption of Politics in Hong Kong:Emphasis on the Grass Roots Level" 15 (15): 422-439, 1975

74 Cheng, Kris, "61% of HKU Students Would Support Independence in a Referendum, Survey Finds"

75 Lo, Clifford, "10 Activists Held in ‘Plot to Detonate Bombs’ as Hong Kong Debates Reform Bill"