An Analysis of Threshold Criteria and Conditions for Variable Speed Limit Deactivation

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The study demonstrates the relative effectiveness and trade-offs amongst various threshold conditions for Variable Speed Limits (VSL) deactivation in terms of the control stability and efficiency. Reduced speed limits must be restored when the traffic interruption is resolved in a prompt and safe manner. Most VSLs in practice rely on a threshold-based control, which determines the speed limit adjustment by comparing detector readings to pre-determined threshold conditions. We tested three types of algorithmic parameters including occupancy, average speed, and consistency-check conditions. The test was carried out using the actual detector data, collected from three different segments of Pacific Motorway in Brisbane, Australia. Our analysis revealed that occupancy could be the most effective threshold over average speed. Operational fluctuation of VSL can be significantly reduced by selecting appropriate occupancy threshold values. We also tested four different consistency check conditions including a conditional deactivation approach. This approach makes the deactivation decision conditional upon the traffic status in the immediate downstream segment toavoid flushing upstream traffic into an active or potential bottleneck downstream. The test results and findings of this study may be useful for practitioners and researchers for developing VSL deactivation rules and associated operational strategies.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Qian, G., "Variable speed limits for motorway off-ramp queue protection" IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems Magazine 2018

2 Youngjun Han, "Variable speed limit control at fixed freeway bottlenecks using connected vehicles" Elsevier BV 98 : 113-134, 2017

3 Peter Allaby, "Variable Speed Limits: Safety and Operational Impacts of a Candidate Control Strategy for Freeway Applications" Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) 8 (8): 671-680, 2007

4 Ullman, G., "Use of technology and data for effective work zone management: Work zone ITS implementation guide" FHWA, U.S. Department of Transportation 2014

5 Corben, B., "Technology to enhance speed limit compliance" 2001

6 Lenz, H., "Standing waves and the influence of speed limits" 2001

7 Bevrani, K., "Queue protection parameters’ fine-tuning for variable speed limits" 2011

8 Yang, X., "Optimal variable speed limit control for real-time freeway congestions" 96 : 2362-2372, 2013

9 Andreas Hegyi, "Model predictive control for optimal coordination of ramp metering and variable speed limits" Elsevier BV 13 (13): 185-209, 2005

10 Xiaopeng Li, "Measurement and estimation of traffic oscillation properties" Elsevier BV 44 (44): 1-14, 2010

11 Mazzenga, N. J., "Investigation of solutions to recurring congestion on freeways" Virginia Department of Transportation Research Report 2009

12 Nicholas J. Fudala, "Interaction between System Design and Operations of Variable Speed Limit Systems in Work Zones" SAGE Publications 2169 (2169): 1-10, 2010

13 Mauch, M., "Freeway traffic oscillations:observations and predictions" Elsevier 653-672, 2002

14 Zheng, Z., "Freeway traffic oscillations: Microscopic analysis of formations and propagations using wavelet transform" 717-731, 2011

15 Lin, P., "Exploring the effectiveness of variable speed limit controls on highway work-zone operations" 8 (8): 1-14, 2004

16 Chris Lee, "Evaluation of variable speed limits to improve traffic safety" Elsevier BV 14 (14): 213-228, 2006

17 Benjamin A. Zielke, "Empirical Measurement of Freeway Oscillation Characteristics" SAGE Publications 2088 (2088): 57-67, 2008

18 Markos Papageorgiou, "Effects of Variable Speed Limits on Motorway Traffic Flow" SAGE Publications 2047 (2047): 37-48, 2008

19 Mohamed Abdel-Aty, "Dynamic Variable Speed Limit Strategies for Real-Time Crash Risk Reduction on Freeways" SAGE Publications 2078 (2078): 108-116, 2008

20 Zhibin Li, "Development of a Control Strategy of Variable Speed Limits to Reduce Rear-End Collision Risks Near Freeway Recurrent Bottlenecks" Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) 15 (15): 866-877, 2014

21 Yadlapati, S., "Development and testing of variable speed limit logics at work zones using simulation" University of Virginia Research 2002

22 Sarintorn WINYOOPADIT, "Development and Comparative Evaluation of Ramp Metering Algorithms Using Microscopic Traffic Simulation" Elsevier BV 7 (7): 51-62, 2007

23 Liu, Z., "Design, specification, implementation and evaluation of a real-time queue warning system" University of Minnesota 2017

24 Stef Smulders, "Control of freeway traffic flow by variable speed signs" Elsevier BV 24 (24): 111-132, 1990

25 Zhibin Li, "Comparing the effects of ramp metering and variable speed limit on reducing travel time and crash risk at bottlenecks" Institution of Engineering and Technology (IET) 12 (12): 120-126, 2018

26 Yihang Zhang, "Combined Variable Speed Limit and Lane Change Control for Highway Traffic" Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) 18 (18): 1812-1823, 2017

27 Chris Lee, "Assessing Safety Benefits of Variable Speed Limits" SAGE Publications 1897 (1897): 183-190, 2004

28 M. Tazul Islam, "Assessing Mobility and Safety Impacts of a Variable Speed Limit Control Strategy" SAGE Publications 2364 (2364): 1-11, 2013

29 Mohamed Abdel-Aty, "Applying Variable Speed Limits and the Potential for Crash Migration" SAGE Publications 1953 : 21-30, 2006

30 Yu, R., "An optimal variable speed limits system to ameliorate traffic safety risk" 2014

31 Feng Zhu, "Accounting for dynamic speed limit control in a stochastic traffic environment: A reinforcement learning approach" Elsevier BV 41 : 30-47, 2014

32 Fang, J., "A novel VSL control strategy with traffic state prediction based collision probability assessment" 2014

33 Francesco Bella, "A Collision Warning System for rear-end collision: a driving simulator study" Elsevier BV 20 : 676-686, 2011

34 Jingxin Xia, "A Clustering Approach to Online Freeway Traffic State Identification Using ITS Data" 대한토목학회 16 (16): 426-432, 2012