Populism in power—A comparative analysis of populist governance

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In this paper, we seek to explore whether populism, when in power, is guided by a particular logic of governance that can be derived from the logic of populism itself. To this end, we develop an ideal type of populist governance and apply it to case studies of India, the United States, Venezuela, and Hungary. Methodologically, the cross-regional comparison with a Most Different Systems Design is carried out through a structured, focused comparison. We conclude that populism in power has a tendency toward autocracy that is inherent in populist governance logic. This may manifest itself “only” in democratic backsliding or regression, that is, in a deterioration of the quality of democracy, but it can also lead to autocratization.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Sharma M, "’We are here to change the constitution,’ says Union Minister In new controversy" NDTV

2 Kruchem T, "Wie Ungarns Oligarchen von der EU profitieren"

3 Long E, "Why Donald Trump still appeals to so many evangelicals"

4 Müller J-W, "Was ist Populismus?" Suhrkamp 2016

5 Müller J-W, "Was heißt: Populismus an der Macht? Osteuropa" 66 (66): 5-17, 2016

6 Löwenstein S, "Victor Orbán und seine Gegner"

7 Löwenstein S, "Vereint für Orbán"

8 Lust E, "Unwelcome Change. Coming to Terms with Democratic Backsliding" 21 : 93-113, 2018

9 Stanley B, "The thin ideology of populism" 13 (13): 95-110, 2008

10 McDonnell D, "The right-wing populism of India’s Bharatiya Janata Party(and why comparativists should care)" 26 (26): 484-501, 2019

11 Mudde, C, "The Populist Zeitgeist" 39 (39): 541-563, 2004

12 Weyland K, "The Oxford Handbook of Populism" Oxford Univ. Press 48-72, 2017

13 Ostiguy P, "The Oxford Handbook of Populism" Oxford Univ. Press 73-97, 2017

14 Urbinati N, "The Oxford Handbook of Populism" Oxford Univ. Press 571-589, 2017

15 Roberts K, "The Oxford Handbook of Populism" Oxford Univ. Press 287-304, 2017

16 Grimm D, "The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law" Oxford Univ. Press 98-132, 2012

17 Przeworski A, "The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry" Wiley 1970

18 Moffit B, "The Global Rise of Populism: Performance, Political Style, and Representation" Stanford Univ. Press 2016

19 Verenkotte C, "Stillschweigen über den “Staatsfeind”"

20 Pappas T, "Routledge International Handbook of Charisma" Routledge. Oxford Univ. Press 226-237, 2020

21 Levitsky S, "Routledge Handbook of Global Populism" Routledge 334-350, 2019

22 Diehl P, "Routledge Handbook of Global Populism" Routledge 129-143, 2019

23 Blokker P, "Routledge Handbook of Global Populism" Routledge 113-128, 2019

24 Arato A, "Routledge Handbook of Global Populism" Routledge 98-112, 2019

25 Urbinati N, "Routledge Handbook of Global Populism" Routledge 77-97, 2019

26 De la Torre C, "Routledge Handbook of Global Populism" Routledge 2019

27 Singh R, "Rise of right-wing populism in India" (7) : 13-16, 2018

28 Priester K, "Rechter und linker Populismus. Annäherung an ein Chamäleon" Campus 2012

29 Briceño H, "Rebelión en las elecciones Regionales y Municipales 2021" 16 (16): 53-80, 2021

30 Pappas T, "Populists in Power" 30 (30): 70-84, 2019

31 Bornschier S, "Populist Mobilization Across Time and Space : An Introduction" 23 (23): 301-312, 2017

32 Kestler T, "Populismus an der Macht. Strategien und Folgen populistischen Regierungshandelns" Springer VS 157-187, 2021

33 Pytlas B, "Populismus an der Macht. Strategien und Folgen populistischen Regierungshandelns" Springer VS 249-270, 2021

34 Lammert C, "Populismus an der Macht. Strategien und Folgen populistischen Regierungshandelns" Springer VS 127-156, 2021

35 Muno W, "Populismus an der Macht. Strategien und Folgen populistischen Regierungshandelns" Springer VS 2021

36 Lauth H-J, "Populismus an der Macht. Strategien und Folgen populistischen Regierungshandelns" Springer VS 23-59, 2021

37 Gottschlich P, "Populismus an der Macht. Strategien und Folgen populistischen Regierungshandelns" Springer VS 103-125, 2021

38 Ionescu G, "Populism: Its Meaning and National Characteristics" Macmillan 1969

39 Mudde C, "Populism in Europa and the Americas. Threat or Corrective for Democracy?" Cambridge University Press 2012

40 Muno W, "Populism around the World" Springer Nature 9-26, 2019

41 Panizza F, "Populism and the Mirror of Democracy" Verso 1-31, 2005

42 Pappas T, "Populism and Liberal Democracy. A Comparative and Theoretical Analysis" 2019

43 Stockemer D, "Populism Around the World" Springer 2019

44 Mudde C, "Populism : A Very Short Introduction" Oxford Univ. Press 2017

45 Taggart P, "Populism" Open Univ. Press 2000

46 Urbinati N, "Political Theory of Populism" 22 : 111-127, 2019

47 Mahapatra S, "Polarisation and politicisation: the social media strategies of Indian political parties" GIGA German Institute of Global and Area Studies - Leibniz-Institut für Globale und Regionale Studien, Institut für Asien-Studien 3 : 2019

48 Bermeo, N, "On Democratic Backsliding" 27 (27): 5-19, 2016

49 Roberts K, "Neoliberalism and the Transformation of Populism in Latin America" 48 : 82-116, 1995

50 Renwick A, "Im Interesse der Macht" 62 (62): 3-17, 2012

51 Diamond L, "Ill Winds: Saving Democracy from Russian Rage, Chinese Ambition, and American Complacency" Penguin Press 2019

52 Sartori G, "How to compare nations. Concepts, strategies, substance" Blackwell 14-34, 1994

53 Levitsky S, "How Democracies die" Crown 2018

54 Lauth H-J, "Handbuch Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft" Springer VS 123-139, 2016

55 Muno W, "Handbuch Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft" Springer VS 649-662, 2015

56 Schedler A, "Electoral authoritarianism. The dynamics of unfree competition" Lynne Rienner 1-23, 2006

57 Schäfer A, "Die demokratische Regression" Suhrkamp 2021

58 Schlemmer, T, "Die Macht der Populisten-Populisten an der Macht" 67 (67): 486-498, 2019

59 Schmitt C, "Der Begriffdes Politischen" Dunker & Humblot 1991

60 Muno W, "Democratic Backsliding and Public Administration" Cambridge Univ. Press 200-220, 2021

61 Levitsky S, "Democracy’s Past and Future : Why Democracy Needs a Level Playing Field" 21 (21): 57-68, 2010

62 Diamond L, "Democracy’s Arc : From Resurgent to Imperiled" 33 (33): 163-179, 2022

63 Graham M, "Democracy in America? Partisanship, polarization, and the robustness of support for democracy in the United States" 114 (114): 392-409, 2020

64 Dahl R, "Democracy and its critics" Yale University Press 1989

65 Rosanvallon P, "Das Jahrhundert des Populismus. Geschichte, Theorie, Kritik" Hamburger Edition 2020

66 Przeworski A, "Crises of Democracy" Cambridge Univ. Press 2019

67 Kopper Á, "Creating suspicion and vigilance. Using Enemy Images to Hinder Mobilization" 3 (3): 108-125, 2017

68 Sartori G, "Concept Misformation in Comparative Politics" 64 (64): 1033-1053, 1970

69 Levitsky S, "Competitive Authoritarianism: Hybrid Regimes After the Cold War" Cambridge Univ. Press 2010

70 Weyland K, "Clarifying a Contested Concept. Populism in the Study of Latin American Politics" 34 (34): 1-22, 2001

71 George A, "Case studies and theory development in social sciences" MIT Press 2004

72 Haggard S, "Backsliding. Democratic Regress in the Contemporary World" Cambridge University Press 2021

73 Basedau M, "Area Studies, Comparative Area Studies, and the Study of Politics : Context, Substance, and Methodological Challenges" 1 (1): 105-124, 2007

74 George A, "Alexander L. George: A Pioneer in Political and Social Sciences. Pioneers in Arts, Humanities, Science, Engineering, Practice" Springer 191-214, 2019