음악학의 21세기 전개: 각성과 도전을 통한 혁신적 변화의 양상들 = 21st Century Development in Musicology: Innovative Changes Through Awakening and Challenges

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper asks what is happening in musicology in the 21st century. It is no different than asking how the flow of innovation – the shift of the paradigm based on philosophy and science around the 21st century, the fourth revolution of economy, capital and knowledge - is emerging in musicology. Since 1885, when musicology first entered the European academic world, it had formed a knowledge base of those days, over which the 150 years of activities of scholars have been accumulated. Musicological scholarship has developed eventually into a dichotomized system of disciplines: one is historical musicology focusing on the historical flow of Western art music and the other is ethnomusicology, covering stylistically heterogeneous non-Western music, thus having been struggling to search for common method to deal with all. The system maintained so long as such that, two disciplines became compartmentalized without any common ground competing for hegemonic power.
With the reflection, retrospection, and critical discussions on this situation, 21st century musicologists are now setting new disciplinary goals with the spirit of the age of global society seeking creative activities rather than processing accumulated compartmental knowledge. Recognizing the huge gap in the accomplished knowledge, the 21st century musicologists are attempting to crossover the disciplinary boundary. They are also explores research that is relevant to the new age, mobilizes new methods and technologies, and connects and collaborates while working. This innovation movement in 21st century musicology is now calling for a new identity and professionalism for musicologists.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이미경, "한국 서양음악학계의 반성적 성찰에 대한 논의 검토" 음악연구소 18 (18): 115-136, 2014

2 쿠르트작스, "탈(脫)서양중심의 음악학 10장" 동아시아 529-545, 2000

3 캐머런 스미스, "진화에 관한 열 가지 신화"

4 홍정수, "음악학의 범위와 방법과 목표. 귀도 아들러" 5 (5): 219-233, 1993

5 김춘미, "음악학연구회 5주년: 회고와 전망" 8 : 67-73, 1992

6 커먼, "음악을 생각한다: 음악학·음악이론·음악철학의 역사" 궁리 2006

7 채현경, "우리 음악을 위한 새로운 음악학--Integrative Musicology" 세계음악학회 (1) : 13-29, 1999

8 강서희, "신음악학 30년 평가와 과제" 18 (18): 113-125, 2015

9 Johnson, Julian, "Who Needs Classical Music? Cultural Choice and Musical Value" Oxford University Press 2002

10 Babbitt, Milton, "Who Cares if You Listen?" 8 (8): 126-, 1958

11 Sandow, "Where We Stand: The Classical Music World Today"

12 Koldau, Linda Maria, "What is ’professional musicology - and does it have a future" 3 : 71-98, 2016

13 Pipko, Michael, "What is Music? The Ontological Status of Musical Works" 8 (8): 2017

14 Griffiths, Dai, "What Was, or Is, Critical Musicology?" 5 : 1992

15 Brown, Clive, "We’re playing classical music all wrong - composers wanted us to improvise"

16 Cook, Nicholas, "We’re all God knows what now"

17 Born, Georgina, "Western Music& Its Others: Difference, Representation, and Appropriation in Music" University of California Press 2000

18 DeDios Anjeline, "Western Music by Its Others: Overseas Filipino Musicians and the Geographies of Migrant Creative Labor"

19 MacMillan, Kyle, "Violinist Zukerman decries sad state of classical music"

20 Huovinen, Erkki, "Varieties of Musicological Empiricism" 1 (1): 12-27, 2006

21 Volk, "Unfolding the Potential of Computational Musicology" 2011

22 Adler, Guido, "Umfang, Methode und Ziel der Musikwissenschaft" 1 : 5-20, 1885

23 Dixon, "Towards a Distributed Research Environment for Music Informatics and Computational Musicology" 39 (39): 291-294, 2010

24 Savage, Patrick, "Toward a New Comparative Musicology" 2 (2): 148-197, 2013

25 Stobart Henry, "The new (ethno)musicologies" owman & Littlefield

26 Honing, Henkjan., "The comeback of systematic musicology: new empiricism and the cognitive revolution" 2004

27 Kramer, Lawrence, "The Musicology of the Future" (spring) : 6-18, 1992

28 Talbot, Michael, "The Musical Work: Reality or Invention?" Liverpool University Press vii-260, 2000

29 Steingo, Gevin, "The Musical Work Reconsidered" 97 : 81-112, 2014

30 Pryer, Anthony, "The Embodiment of Authority: Perspectives on Performance, Interdisciplinary Studies of Music" Peter Lang 199-214, 2013

31 Dunsby, Jonathan, "The Dawn of Music: Semiology Essays in Honor of Jean-Jacques Nattiez" Boydell & Brewer 2017

32 Clayton, Martin, "The Cultural Study of Music: A Critical Introduction" Routledge 57-68, 2003

33 Parncutt, Richard, "The Conference on Interdisciplinary Musicology Promoting unity in diversity"

34 Breuer, Benjamin, "The Birth of Musicology from the Spirit of Evolution" University of Pittsburgh 2011

35 Glanakon, Hong Hong, "Teaching Undergraduate Music Theory through World Music" University of Missouri-Kansas City 2018

36 Leman Marc, "Systematic and Comparative Musicology: Concepts, Methods, Findings. Hamburger Jahrbuch für Musikwissenschaft, 24" Peter Lang 89-115, 2008

37 Parncutt, Richard, "Systematic Musicology and the History and Future of Western Musical Scholarship" 1 (1): 1-32, 2007

38 McCutcheon, Douglas, "Susan McClary and the epistemology of “new” musicological narrative, 1983-2007" University of Pretoria 2012

39 Schneider, Albrecht, "Springer Handbook of Systematic Musicology" 1-24, 2018

40 Baggi, Denis L., "Role of Computer Technology in Music and Musicology"

41 McClary, Susan, "Reshaping a Discipline: Musicology and Feminism in the 1990s" (Summer) : 399-426, 1993

42 Krause, Amanda Elizabeth, "Research About Listening: Everyday Music Interactions" Curtin University 2014

43 Lochhead, Judy, "Reconceiving Structure in Contemporary Music: New Tools in Music Theory and Analysis" Taylor & Francis 2016

44 Jeffery, Peter, "Re-Envisioning Past Musical Cultures: Ethnomusicology in the Study of Gregorian Chant" Chicago Studies in Ethnomusicology 1992

45 Cook, Nicholas, "Product or Process? Music and Performance"

46 Feld, Steven, "Perspectives on a 21st Century Comparative Musicology: Ethnomusicology or Transcultural Musicology" Intersezioni Musicall Book IM05 2017

47 Kendell, Roger, "Perspective of Systematical Musicology" University of California 2005

48 Day, Rebecca, "On the ‘Elvis-and-Darmstadt realization’, or why the fate of musicology rests somewhere ‘in-between’"

49 Solomos, Makis, "New Musicology. Perspectives critiques. Filigrane. Musique, esthétique, sciences, societé"

50 Stock, Jonathan P. J., "New Musicologies, Old Musicologies: Ethnomusicology and the Study of Western Music" (62) : 40-68, 1997

51 Sullivan, Blair, "Musicology. Principal Methodologies For Musicological Research"

52 Garaz, Oleg, "Musicology as an Evolutionary System of the Musical Thinking Categories" 30 (30): 67-96, 2011

53 Bohlman, Philip V., "Musicology as a Political Act" 11 (11): 411-436, 1993

54 Wiering, Frans, "Musicology Musical Similarity and Music Cognition"

55 European Science Foundation, "Musicology (Re-)Mapped" Standing Committee for the Humanities(SCH) 2012

56 Bellmann, Jonathan D., "Musical Voyages and Their Baggage: Orientalism in Music and Critical Musicology" 94 : 417-438, 2011

57 Lewis, Richard, "Musical Scholarship and the Future of Academic Publishing"

58 Cook, Nicholas, "Music, Imagination, and Culture" Clarendon 1990

59 Gabrielson, Alf, "Music performance research at the Millennium" 31 : 2003

60 Hemetek, Ursula, "Music of Minorities: ”The Others from Within? On terminology and the history of research in Austria"

61 Kramer, Lawrence, "Music as Cultural Practice 1800-1900" University of California Press 1900

62 Upton, Elizabeth Randell, "Music and Performance in the Later Middle Ages" Palgrave Macmillan 2013

63 Brand, Benjamin, "Music and Culture in the Middle Ages and Beyond: Liturgy, Sources, Symbolism" Cambridge University Press 2016

64 Powell, Mike, "Music Criticism Is Not ’Life style Reporting’: A Respons"

65 Gioia, Ted, "Music Criticism Has Degenerated Into Lifestyle Reporting"

66 Koscarov, Ljupco, "Multicultural and Intercultural Aspects of Music and Education" 11 (11): 43-53, 2012

67 Crawford, Tim, "Modern methods for musicology: prospects, proposals, and realities" Ashgate Publishing 2009

68 Schwarz, David, "Keeping score: Music, disciplinary, Culture" University Press of Virginia 1997

69 Peters, Camille Cecelia, "Introduction: Music journal of the future?" 10 (10): 4-7, 2007

70 Haumann, Nieis Trusbak, "Introduction to Cognitive Musicology: Historical-Scientific presuppositions in the psychology of Music"

71 Taylor, Tim, "In Etnomusicologia e studi di popular music quale possibile convergenza? LIBRI A SAN VIO" Giorgio Cini Foundation onlus

72 Rose, Simon, "Improvisation, music and learning: interpretive Phenomenological Analysis" Glasgow Caledonian University 2012

73 Meer, Wim van der, "I Buried Ethnomusicology: Commentary on recent developments at the musicology department in Amsterdam"

74 Wöllner, Clemens, "How to quantify individuality in music performance" 4 : 361-, 2013

75 Kerman, Joseph, "How We Got into Analysis, and How to Get Out" 7 (7): 311-331, 1985

76 Lukaniuk, Bohdan, "History of the term ethnomusicology" XV : 129-154, 2010

77 Nooshin, Laudan, "Happy Families: Convergence, Antagonism and Disciplinary Identities or ‘We’re all God knows what now’ (Cook 2016)" City University London 2016

78 Mugglestone, Erica, "Guido Adler’s The Scope Method And Aim Of Musicology" 13 : 1-21, 1981

79 Scott, Derek B., "From the Erotic to the Demonic On Critical Musicology" Oxford Scholarship Online 2003

80 Kellner, Douglas, "Frankfurt School and British Cultural Studies, The Missed Articulation"

81 Born. GEORGINA, "For a Relational Musicology" 135 (135): 205-243, 2007

82 Schyff, Dylan van der, "Evolutionary Musicology Meets Embodied Cognition" 11 : 2017

83 Mauch, "Evolution of Popular Music: USA 1960–2010" 2 : 150081-, 2017

84 Clarke, Eric, "Empirical Musicology: Aims, Methods, Prospects" Oxford University Press 2004

85 Kizinska, Karolina, "Elements of sociology of music in todays historical musicology"

86 Bergeron, Katherine, "Disciplining Music: Musicology and Its Canons" University of Chicago Press 1992

87 Cobussen, Marcel, "Deconstruction in Music. Interactive Dissertation" Department of Art and Culture Studies, Erasmus University Rotterdam

88 Korsyn, Kevin Ernest, "Decentering Music: A Critique of Contemporary Musical Research" Oxford University Press 221-, 2003

89 Trehub, Sandra, "Cross-cultural perspectives on music and musicality" 370 : 20140096-, 2015

90 Gramit, David, "Critical Musicology, the Aesthetic Experience, and the Music Department" 19 (19): 19-33, 1998

91 Thompson, Kathy, "Critical Discourse Analysis of World Music as the ‘Other’" (19) : 2002

92 McClary, Susan, "Conventional Wisdom: The Content of Musical Form" University of California Press 2000

93 Kerman, Joseph, "Contemplating Music: Challenges to Musicology" Harvard University Press 1985

94 Alastair, Williams, "Constructing Musicology" Routledge 2001

95 Bader Rolf, "Concepts, Experiments, and Fieldwork: Studies in Systematic Musicology and Ethnomusicology" Peter Lang GmbH, Internationaler Verlag der Wissenschaften 2010

96 Marsden, "Computational Music Analysis" Computational Music Analysis 3-28, 2016

97 Albright, Charlie, "Classical’ music is dying...and that’s the best thing for classical music"

98 Sharif, Mag. Malik, "Charles Seeger and Twenty-First-Century Musicologies: A Critical Assessment of His Meta-Musicological Thinking" University of Music and Performing Arts Graz 2017

99 Latartara, John, "Analysis, Performance, and Images of Musical Sound: Surfaces, Cyclical Relationships, and the Musical Work" (84) : 84-, 2007

100 Reitisma, Kimberly, "A New Approach: Feminist Musicology Studies of Susan McClary & Marcia J. Citron" 10 (10): 2014

101 Lee, Gavin, "A Home at Disciplinary Margins: Reflections of an Ethno/Musicologist from Elsewhere"

102 박미경, "93음악학연구회 여름학술대회 참석 보고" (6) : 372-275, 1993