The Effect of Organizational Level on Employees’ Computer-Mediated-Communication (CMC) Use

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper addresses the research question, "Who is more likely to use email: high-level or low-level employees?" In discussing the question, this study reviews important literature on CMC, particularly focusing on methodological issues, and suggests two important implications. First, the findings of researchers such as Rice, Hughes, & Love (1989), Rice & Torobin (1992), and Markus (1994a; 1994b) are inconsistent with what information richness theory suggests (e.g., Daft & Lengel, 1986; Daft, Lengel, & Trevino, 1987). This contradiction might be explained by a methodological difference between the two groups of researchers – e.g., the "observational and experimental" method in Markus (1994a; 1994b) and the "projective" method used by Daft et al., 1987). Second, as the use of email becomes widespread, researchers’ interests have moved from testing whether or not managers are more likely to use email than lower level workers to identifying motivational differences between higher-level and lower-level employees in choosing the medium. This study concludes with some suggestions for overcoming the methodological limitations revealed in the previous researches.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Rice, R. E., "Usage and Outcomes of Electronic Messaging at an R & D Organization: Situational Constraints, Job Level, and Media Awareness" 5 : 141-161, 1989

2 Allen, T. J, "The Influence of Communication Technologies on Organizational Structure: A Conceptual Model for Future Research" 14 : 575-587, 1987

3 Hiltz, S. R., "Replacing Bales Problem Solving Experiments on a Computer Conference: A Pilot Study" Research Number Eight 1978

4 Walther, J. B., "Relational Aspects of Computer-mediated Communication: Experimental Observations over Time" 6 (6): 186-203, 1995

5 Sproull, L., "Reducing Social Context Cues: Electronic Mail in Organizational Communication" 32 : 1492-1512, 1986

6 Daft, R. L., "Organizational Information Requirements, Media Richness and Structural Design" 32 : 554-571, 1986

7 Daft, R. L., "Organization Theory and Design" South-Western College Publishing 1998

8 Walther, J. B., "Misattribution and Attributional Redirection in Distributed Virtual Groups" 2002

9 Daft, R. L., "Message Equivocality, Media Selection, and Manager Performance: Implications for Information Systems" 11 : 355-368, 1987

10 Russ, R. S., "Media Selection and Managerial Characteristics in Organizational Communications" 4 : 151-175, 1990

11 Rice, R. E., "Media Appropriateness: Using Social Presence Theory to Compare Traditional and New Organizational Media" 19 : 451-484, 1993

12 Culnan, M. J., "Handbook of Organizational Communication: An Interdisciplinary Perspective" Sage 420-443, 1987

13 Walther, J. B., "Handbook of Interpersonal Communication" 529-563, 2002

14 Hollingshead, A. B., "Group task performance and communication technology: A longitudinal Study of Computer-Mediated versus Face-to-Face Work Groups" 24 : 307-333, 1993

15 Markus, M. L., "Finding a Happy Medium: Explaining the Negative Effects of Electronic Communication on Social Life at Work" 12 : 119-149, 1994

16 Weisband, S., "Evaluating Self and Others in Electronic and Face-to-Face Groups" 84 : 632-639, 1999

17 Rice, R. E., "Electronic Message Systems in the University: A Description of Use and Utility" 33 : 131-152, 1983

18 Markus, M. L., "Electronic Mail as the Medium of Managerial Choice" 5 : 502-527, 1994

19 Sproull, L., "Do You Know Who You’re Talking to? In Connections Ch. 3" MIT Press 37-56, 1991

20 Walther, J. B., "Distributed Work: New Research on Working across Distance Using Technology" MIT Press 2002

21 Kling, R., "Cooperation, Coordination and Control in Computer-Supported Work" 34 : 83-88, 1991

22 Steinfield, C. W., "Computer-Mediated Communication in an Organizational Setting:Explaining Task-Related and Socioemotional Uses" 9 : 777-804, 1986

23 Rice, R. E., "Computer-Mediated Communication and Organizational Innovation" 37 : 67-94, 1987

24 Robey, D., "Computer Information Systems and Organization Structure" 24 : 679-687, 1981

25 Rice, R. E., "Communicator Style, Media Use, Organizational Level, and Use and Evaluation of Electronic Messaging" 6 : 3-33, 1992

26 Fulk, J., "Cognitive Elements in the Social Construction of Technology" 8 : 259-288, 1995

27 Carlson, J. R., "Channel Expansion Theory and the Experiential Nature of Media Richness Perceptions" 42 : 153-170, 1999

28 Carlson, P. J., "An Investigation of Media Selection among Directors and Managers: From “Self” to “Other” Orientation" 335-358, 1998

29 Rice, R. E, "Access to, Usage of, and Outcomes from an Electronic Messaging System" 6 : 255-276, 1988

30 El-Shinnawy, M, "Acceptance of Communication Media in Organizations:Richness or Features?" 41 : 242-253, 1998