Review on the succession process of Pinus densiflora forests in South Korea: progressive and disturbance-driven succession

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background: Most of the Pinus densiflora forests, occupying the largest area, have been restored in South Korea since the 1970s. As young pioneer forests, the succession process is under way. Since the forests are distributed nationwide and are vulnerable to disturbances, the process may differ depending on the geography and/or site conditions. Therefore, we reviewed the direction, the seral communities, and the late-successional species of progressive and disturbance-driven succession nationwide in the cool-temperate zone through meta-analysis and empirical observations. Main text: As a result of a meta-analysis of the direct succession and vertical structure, we found that the P. densiflora forest is in a directionally progressive succession, changing to the broadleaved forest after forming a mixed forest with its overwhelming successor, Quercus species (particularly Q. mongolica and Q. serrata). In dry stands in a relative sense, the Quercus species was favored occupying over 80% of the abundance of the succeeding species. Therefore, in dry stands, it is presumed that Quercus-dominated stage would last for a long time due to the current dominance and long life span, and eventually, it settles as Quercus-broadleaved forest with a site change. Contrary to this, it is presumed that in mesic stands where Quercus species do not occur or have low abundance, the late-successional broadleaved species settle early to form a co-dominant forest with multiple species. Due to geographical limits, the species composition of the two late-successional forests is different. Disturbances such as insect pests and fire retrogressed vulnerable P. densiflora forest for a while. However, it was mostly restored to the Quercus forest and is expected to be incorporated in the pathway of the dry stand. Conclusions: We revealed the succession process of P. densiflora forests according to geography and moisture and found that stand moisture had a decisive effect on the species and abundance of the successor. Although the P. densiflora forest is undergoing structural changes, the forest is still young; so within a few decades, physiognomy is not likely to change. Therefore, the decrease in the forest area may be due to other causes such as disturbances and forest conversion rather than due to succession.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이호영, "희양산 봉암사 산림유전자원보호구역 산림군락구조 특성" 한국환경생태학회 26 (26): 382-393, 2012

2 이규송, "화전 후 묵밭의 식생 천이에 따른 종다양성 및 식생 구조의 발달" 한국생태학회 29 (29): 227-235, 2006

3 안현철, "지리산 웅석봉지역의 산림군집구조" 한국환경생태학회 24 (24): 547-555, 2010

4 전주현, "중부지방소나무의 생장특성 및 경험적 임분수확모델 개발" 한국산림과학회 106 (106): 267-273, 2017

5 변성엽, "장군봉 천연림(소나무림, 신갈나무림)과 일본잎갈나무림의 식생구조 비교" 농업생명과학연구원 52 (52): 31-45, 2018

6 김갑태, "월출산국립공원 월각산-도갑재 지역의 산림 능선부 식생구조" 한국환경생태학회 20 (20): 122-129, 2006

7 오구균, "월출산국립공원 상록활엽수 분포 및 군집구조" 한국환경생태학회 20 (20): 81-93, 2006

8 최송현, "월출산국립공원 도갑사계곡의 식생구조" 한국환경생태학회 20 (20): 94-102, 2006

9 최송현, "월출산국립공원 금생골의 식생구조" 한국환경생태학회 20 (20): 464-472, 2006

10 오구균, "월악산국립공원의 산림군집구조 - 영봉 및 도락산 일원을 중심으로 -" 한국환경생태학회 19 (19): 90-98, 2005

11 백승준, "월악산국립공원 용하구곡의 식생구조 및 관리방안" 한국환경생태학회 27 (27): 487-497, 2013

12 이정윤, "월악산국립공원 영봉 일대 삼림식생의 군락분포에 관한 연구" 한국하천호수학회 48 (48): 51-60, 2015

13 김갑태, "월악산국립공원 덕주사-동창교 지역의 산림군집구조" 한국환경생태학회 19 (19): 75-82, 2005

14 김호진, "월악산국립공원 금수산 산림식생의 군집구조" 한국환경생태학회 31 (31): 202-219, 2017

15 이정윤, "월악산국립공원 금수산 및 도락산 일대 삼림식생의 군락분포에 관한 연구" 한국하천호수학회 48 (48): 129-138, 2015

16 강현미, "울진군(경북) 불영사계곡지역의 현존식생 및 식생구조" 한국환경생태학회 22 (22): 1-10, 2008

17 조현제, "우리나라 소나무림의 식생형과 종다양성 패턴" 한국산림과학회 100 (100): 118-123, 2011

18 윤정원, "우리나라 소나무 주요유형지별 식생구조와 환경요인" 산림과학연구소 30 (30): 167-178, 2014

19 신재권, "용현자연휴양림 일대의 산림군락분류와 식생구조" 한국환경생태학회 31 (31): 220-229, 2017

20 최영은, "오대산 국립공원 비로봉 일대 산지 삼림식생의 군락분포에 관한 연구" 한국하천호수학회 47 (47): 91-102, 2014

21 오희영, "역사문화적 관점에서의 치악산국립공원 구룡계곡 소나무림의 식생구조 및 관리방안" 한국환경복원기술학회 20 (20): 117-131, 2017

22 한봉호, "순천시 조계산 운수암 계곡부 식물군집구조" 한국환경생태학회 28 (28): 45-54, 2014

23 김정호, "송이생산지 보전 및 복원을 위한 소나무군락의 식생구조 분석 - 강원도 양양군 송이발생지역을 중심으로 -" 한국환경생태학회 26 (26): 730-740, 2012

24 이경재, "속리산국립공원 법주사지구 소나무림 식생천이와 식생관리 연구" 한국환경생태학회 23 (23): 208-219, 2009

25 이수동, "서울시소나무림의 생태적 특성에따른 관리방안 연구" 한국환경생태학회 23 (23): 258-271, 2009

26 이경재, "서울시 남산소나무림 생태적 특성 및 15년간(1990～2004년) 식생구조 변화분석" 한국환경생태학회 19 (19): 312-326, 2005

27 이혜선, "생태형태학적 특성에 의한 활엽수 주요 수종의 극상지수 추정" 강원대학교 대학원 2011

28 이시영, "산불발화지점의 임상 및 지형특성을 이용한 위험지수 개발" 한국화재소방학회 19 (19): 75-79, 2005

29 추갑철, "북한산국립공원 북한산성-인수봉 지역의 산림군집구조" 한국환경생태학회 22 (22): 98-105, 2008

30 이경재, "부산광역시 금정산 소나무림 식생구조 연구" 한국환경생태학회 27 (27): 462-472, 2013

31 최진우, "변산반도국립공원 소나무림 식물군집구조 및 관리방안 연구" 한국환경생태학회 23 (23): 447-459, 2009

32 최송현, "변산반도국립공원 내소사-내변산 구간의 식생구조분석" 한국환경생태학회 23 (23): 151-160, 2009

33 김봉규, "변산반도국립공원 내소사 지역의 능선부 식생구조" 한국환경생태학회 23 (23): 135-142, 2009

34 이수동, "백두대간 댓재에서 백봉령구간 마루금의 식물군집구조 특성" 한국환경생태학회 26 (26): 719-729, 2012

35 정상훈, "두타산 일대 천연림에서 요인분석에 의한 산림유형 분류" 농업생명과학연구원 46 (46): 21-30, 2012

36 이규송, "동해안 산불 피해지에서 산불 후 경과 년 수에 따른 식생 구조의 발달" 한국생태학회 27 (27): 99-106, 2004

37 최영은, "덕유산 국립공원 향적봉 일대 삼림식생의 군락분포에 관한 연구" 한국하천호수학회 46 (46): 289-300, 2013

38 최영은, "덕유산 국립공원 적상산 일대 삼림식생의 군락분포에 관한 연구" 한국하천호수학회 46 (46): 460-470, 2013

39 오장근, "덕유산 국립공원 거칠봉 일대 삼림식생의 군락분포에 관한 연구" 한국하천호수학회 46 (46): 449-459, 2013

40 이경재, "남한산성 소나무림의 19년간(1993~2011년) 식생구조 변화와 관리방안" 한국환경생태학회 26 (26): 559-575, 2012

41 박석곤, "남한 정맥 마루금의 산림식생유형 및 식생구조" 한국환경생태학회 29 (29): 753-763, 2015

42 박석곤, "낙동정맥 마루금 일대의 식생구조 특성" 한국환경생태학회 30 (30): 386-398, 2016

43 김동필, "낙동정맥 가지한~능동산 구간의 능선부 식생구조" 한국환경생태학회 18 (18): 279-287, 2004

44 이윤택, "고성 산불 이후 10년간의 식생 복원 동태" 강원대학교 대학원 2007

45 이상철, "경주국립공원 토함산습지 주변 지역의 현존식생과 식물군락구조" 한국환경생태학회 28 (28): 33-44, 2014

46 강현미, "경주국립공원 불국사 사찰림의 식생구조" 한국환경생태학회 26 (26): 787-800, 2012

47 신학섭, "강화도 마니산 산림식생의 군집구조 특성" 한국농림기상학회 16 (16): 11-21, 2014

48 한봉호, "강원도 대관령 목장 현존식생 및 식물군집구조" 한국환경생태학회 27 (27): 579-591, 2013

49 이상철, "가지산도립공원 통도사지구의 식물군락과 환경요인의 상관관계" 한국환경생태학회 28 (28): 715-724, 2014

50 이경재, "가야산국립공원 홍류동 계곡 소나무림의 생태적 특성 및 15년간(1989년～2004년) 식생구조 변화분석" 한국환경생태학회 20 (20): 188-199, 2006

51 서현수, "Vulnerability of Pinus densiflora to forest fire based on ignition characteristics" 한국생태학회 33 (33): 343-349, 2010

52 Lee KJ, "Vegetation structure analysis and ecological distance of Pinus densiflora community in Chayang-Chon area, Soraksan National Park" 11 (11): 493-505, 1998

53 Byun DW, "Vegetation pattern and successional sere in the forest of Mt. Odae" 21 (21): 283-293, 1998

54 Kim W, "The secondary vegetation of the burned area of a mountain in Dangji-Dong" 6 (6): 187-197, 1983

55 Nakagoshi N, "The role of fire in ecological systems" SPB Academic Publishing 91-119, 1987

56 Higo M, "The regeneration behavior of major component species in the secondary forest dominated by Pinus densiflora and Quercus serrata in central Japan" 76 (76): 1-10, 1995

57 Jo JC, "The plant community structure of Pinus densiflorain forest in Chuwangsan National Park" 8 (8): 121-134, 1995

58 Ahn HC, "The forest community structure and dynamics in Mt. Yeonhwa Provincial Park" 13 : 87-95, 2000

59 Kim W, "The early vegetational succession of the burned area in Dangji-Dong" 6 (6): 237-242, 1983

60 Nowacki GR, "The demise of fire and “mesophication” of forests in the eastern United States" 58 (58): 123-138, 2008

61 Lee KJ, "The analysis of the forest community structure of Tokyusan National Park-case study of Paekryunsa – Kumpotan" 7 (7): 135-154, 1994

62 Lee KJ, "The analysis of the forest community structure of Huibang Valley in Sobaeksan National Park" 6 (6): 113-126, 1993

63 NGII, "The National Atlas of Korea II" National Geographic Information Institute 2016

64 Korea Forest Research Institute, "The 6th national forest inventory report" Korea Forest Research Institute 2016

65 Korea Forest Research Institute, "The 5th national forest inventory report" Korea Forest Research Institute 2011

66 Barbour MG, "Terrestrial plant ecology" Benjamin Cummings, Inc 1999

67 Choung HL, "Syntaxonomy of the forest vegetation and surrounding Taegu, Korea" 23 (23): 407-421, 2000

68 전영문, "Syntaxonomy and Syngeography of Korean Red Pine (Pinus densiflora) Forests in Korea 한국 소나무림의 군락분류와 군락지리" 한국환경생태학회 21 (21): 257-277, 2007

69 Toyohara G, "Succession of secondary forests affected by pine wilt disease in western Japan followed on vegetation maps" 1 (1): 259-266, 1998

70 Kim GT, "Studies on the structure of forest community at Wangkoam, Kumunkwangi area in Chuwangsan National Park" 8 (8): 142-149, 1995

71 Park IH, "Structure of forest communities in Chiak Mountain National Park-case study of Guryong temple-Birobong area" 2 (2): 1-8, 1988

72 Korea Forest Service, "Statistical yearbook of forestry (No. 49)" Korea Forest Service 2019

73 Korea Forest Service, "Statistical yearbook of forestry (No. 39)" Korea Forest Service 2009

74 Sakamoto K, "Stand structure and dynamics of Pinus densiflora forests damaged by pine wilt disease in the southern part of Okayama prefecture" 21 (21): 18-28, 1995

75 Vesk PA, "Sprouting ability across diverse disturbances and vegetation types worldwide" 92 : 310-320, 2004

76 Mun HT, "Species composition and nutrient absorption by plants in the immediate postfire year" 20 : 27-33, 1997

77 Lee KS, "Seral changes in floristic composition during abandoned field succession after shifting cultivation" 18 (18): 275-283, 1995

78 Cho YH, "Secondary succession and species diversity of Pinus densiflora forest after fire" 15 (15): 337-344, 1992

79 Kim W, "Revegetation and secondary succession of the burned area in Mt. Sanseung" 7 (7): 203-207, 1984

80 Ro DK, "Report of the East Coast Fires in 2000 (I)" The Joint Association for the Investigation of the East Coast Fires 27-29, 2000

81 Lee CS, "Regeneration process after disturbance of the Pinus densiflora forest in Korea" 18 (18): 189-201, 1995

82 Kato J, "Quantitative analysis of a stand of Pinus densiflora undergoing succession to Quercus mongolica ssp. crispula: 1. A 31-year record of growth and population dynamics of the canopy trees" 21 (21): 503-509, 2006

83 Lee WT, "Plant sociological studies on the Pinus densiflora forest in Korea" 12 (12): 257-284, 1989

84 Lee WC, "Plant geography with special reference to Korea" Kangwon National University Press 2002

85 Cho HS, "Plant community structure of the Baekcheon valley in Taebaeksan Area, the Baekdudaegan" 15 (15): 369-378, 2002

86 Lee KJ, "Plant community structure of Pinus densiflora forests in Odaesan National Park" 9 (9): 115-125, 1996

87 Han BH, "Plant community structure of Donghaksa valley in Kyeryongsan National Park" 14 (14): 238-251, 2001

88 Lee KJ, "Plant community structure for five major valleys in Bukhansan National Park" 9 (9): 15-29, 1995

89 Lee KJ, "Plant community structure and ecological density of Pinus densiflora for. eracta community in Chunyang, Kyeongsangbuk-do" 15 (15): 379-393, 2002

90 Lee KJ, "Plant community structure analysis in Jujeongol Valley of Soraksan National Park" 10 (10): 283-296, 1997

91 Kamada M, "Pine forest structure in a human-dominated landscape system in Korea" 8 (8): 35-46, 1993

92 Mamiya Y, "Pathology of the pine wilt disease caused by Bursaphelenchus xylophilus" 21 : 201-220, 1983

93 Shin YS, "Natural regeneration of forests with different burn severity and initial regeneration following forest fire in the East Coast region" Kangwon National University 2015

94 PC-ORD, "Multivariate analysis of ecological data, version 6"

95 Choe B, "Management of future-oriented a natural forest through changes of plant community for twenty our years (1988~2012) in Soribong of Kwangnung forest, Korea" University of Seoul 2012

96 Lee DK, "Korean forests: lessons learned from stories of success and failure" Korea Forest Research Institute 35-57, 2010

97 Lee DK, "Korean forests: Lessons learned from stories of success and failure" Korea Forest Research Institute 2010

98 SPSS, "IBM SPSS statistics for windows, version 24.0"

99 Hong SK, "Human impacts on pine-dominated vegetation in rural landscapes in Korea and western Japan" 116 (116): 161-172, 1995

100 Korea Forest Service, "Growing forests together" Korea Forest Service 2018

101 Chun YW, "Forests and Korean culture" Book’s Hill publishers Co., Inc 1999

102 Finegan B, "Forest succession" 312 (312): 109-114, 1984

103 Park IH, "Forest structure in relation to altitude and part of slope in a valley and a ridge forest at Mt. Gaya area" 3 (3): 42-50, 1989

104 Choung Y, "Forest responses to the large-scale east coast fires in Korea" 19 : 43-54, 2004

105 Korea Forest Service, "Forest fire statistics" Korea Forest Service 2017

106 Lim JH. Vegetation changes, "Forest eco-atlas of Korea" Korea Forest Research Institute 20-23, 2010

107 Korea Forest Service, "Field survey on Pinus densiflora forests for the conservation" Korea Forest Service 2000

108 Seo H, "Enhanced vulnerability to fire by Pinus densiflora forests due to tree morphology and stand structure in Korea" 57 : 48-54, 2014

109 Kim W, "Effects of fire on forest vegetation in Mt. Samma" 22 (22): 145-153, 1999

110 Choung Y, "Ecology of common plant species in central Korean forests" Nature & Ecology 2019

111 Keeley JE, "Ecology and biogeography of Pinus" Cambridge University Press 219-250, 1998

112 Richardson DM, "Ecology and biogeography of Pinus" Cambridge University Press 1998

113 Richardson DM, "Ecology and biogeography of Pinus" Cambridge University Press 3-46, 1998

114 Korea Forest Service, "Ecological report on Goseong Fire regions" Korea Forest Service and Korea Forest Research Institute 1996

115 Cho YH, "Early vegetational recovery and species diversity of pine forest after fire in Mt. Todok" 14 (14): 15-23, 1991

116 Beon MS, "Early seedling growth of pine (Pinus densiflora) and oaks (Quercus serrata, Q. mongolica, Q. variabilis) in response to light intensity and soil moisture" 167 (167): 97-105, 2003

117 Abrams MD, "Disturbance-mediated accelerated succession in two Michigan forest types" 35 (35): 42-49, 1989

118 Lee CS, "Disturbance regime of the Pinus densiflora forest in Korea" 18 (18): 179-188, 1995

119 Choung HL, "Distribution patterns, floristic differentiation and succession of Pinus densiflora forest in South Korea : a perspective at nation-wide scale" 36 (36): 213-229, 2006

120 Park PS, "Development processes and growth pattern of Pinus densiflora stands in central eastern Korea" 123 (123): 453-462, 2010

121 Fujihara M, "Development of secondary pine forests after pine wilt disease in western Japan" 7 (7): 729-738, 1996

122 Eom BC, "Climatically potential natural vegetation and phytoclimatic map of Korea" Keimyung University 2019

123 Lee K, "Classification of forested vegetation and successional development in the central-eastern Korean Peninsula" Kangwon National University 2015

124 Cerny T, "Classification of Korean forests : patterns along geographic and environmental gradients" 18 (18): 5-22, 2015

125 Kim CH, "Classification analysis and gradient analysis on the forest vegetation of Mt. Mudung" 17 (17): 471-484, 1994

126 Lee CS, "Changes of landscape pattern and vegetation structure in rural area disturbed by fire" 21 (21): 389-399, 1998

127 Fujihara M, "Changes in the stand structure of a pine forest after rapid growth of Quercus serrata Thunb" 170 : 55-65, 2002

128 박필선, "Changes in forest disturbance patterns from 1976 to 2005 in South Korea" 한국산림과학회 98 (98): 593-601, 2009

129 Choung Y, "Biodiversity of burned forests is controlled by the sprouting ability of prefire species in Pinus densiflora forests" 127 : 356-362, 2019

130 Choi SH, "Analysis on the forest community structure of the area of Donghaksa-Nammaetap, Kyeryongsan National Park" 14 (14): 252-267, 2001

131 Kim JU, "Actual vegetation and potential natural vegetation of Seonunsan area, Southwestern Korea" 10 (10): 159-164, 1987

132 Lee EB, "Actual vegetation and potential natural vegetation of Pukhansan National Park, mid-western Korea" 20 (20): 439-450, 1997

133 Kim JU, "Actual vegetation and potential natural vegetation of Naejangsan national park, southwestern Korea" 11 (11): 145-152, 1988

134 Lee CS, "A study on the succession of pine forests damaged by pine gall midge" Seoul National University 1989

135 Lee JL, "A study on the growth between pine and oak mixed natural forest stands" 19 : 21-27, 1998

136 Krestov PV, "A phytosociological survey of the deciduous temperate forests of mainland Northeast Asia" 36 : 77-150, 2006

137 NIE, "4th National ecosystem survey guidelines"

138 Korea Forest Service, "2015 Forest basic statistics" Korea Forest Service 2016

139 배재수, "1910년 한반도 산림의 이해: 조선임야분포도의 수치화를 중심으로" 한국산림과학회 108 (108): 418-428, 2019