The Koreanization of the Australian Sex Industry: A Policy and Legislative Challenge

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

South Korea enacted legislation in 2004 that penalizes pimps, traffickers,and sex industry customers while decriminalizing people in prostitution and offering assistance to leave the sex industry. In contrast, Australia legally recognizes most sex industry activities. This article argues that Australia’s laissezfaire approach to the sex industry hampers South Korean government efforts to prevent the crime of sex trafficking. Since 2004, pimps and traffickers have moved their activities from South Korea to countries like Australia and the US that maintain relatively hospitable operating environments for the sex industry.
The Australian government should reconsider its approach to prostitution on the basis of its diplomatic obligations to countries like South Korea and the need to uphold the human rights of women in Asia who are being trafficked and murdered as a result of sexual demand emanating from Australia. Australia should coordinate its policy on prostitution with South Korea to strengthen the region’s transnational anti-trafficking response.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Swedish Institute, "n.d. Sweden takes action against trafficking. Stockholm:. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

2 Center for Women’s Human Rights, "n.d. Act on the punishment of procuring prostitution and associated acts, 2004. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

3 Pickering, S., "Working in Victorian brothels. Melbourne: Consumer Affairs Victoria. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

4 Sullivan, B., "When (some) prostitution is legal: The impact of law reform on sex work in Australia" 37 (37): 85-104, 2010

5 Laforteza, E., "What a drag! Filipina/white Australian relations in The Adventures of Priscilla Queen of the Desert. ACRAWSA E-journal, 2(2). Retrieved July 30, 2011"

6 Australian National Audit Office, "Visa management: Working holiday makers" 2006

7 MacKinnon, C., "Trafficking, prostitution, and inequality" 46 : 271-309, 2011

8 US Department of State, "Trafficking in persons report 2011. Washington, DC: Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons:. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

9 Maltzahn, K., "Trafficked" UNSW Press 2008

10 Farley, M., "Theory versus reality: Commentary on four articles about trafficking for prostitution" 32 (32): 311-315, 2009

11 Donovan, B., "The sex industry in Western Australia: A report to the Western Australian Government. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

12 O’Connor, M., "The links between prostitution and sex trafficking: A briefing handbook. Coalition Against Trafficking in Women/European Women’s Lobby. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

13 Jeffreys, S., "The industrial vagina: The political economy of the global sex trade" Routledge 2009

14 Jeffreys, S., "The idea of prostitution" Spinifex Press 1997

15 Frances, R., "The history of female prostitution in Australia, in Sex work and sex workers in Australia" University of New South Wales Press 1994

16 Claude, K., "Targeting the sex buyer. The Swedish example: Stopping prostitution and trafficking where it all begins. Stockholm: Swedish Institute. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

17 Waltman, M., "Sweden’s prohibition of purchase of sex: The law’s reasons, impact, and potential" 34 : 449-474, 2011

18 Center for Women’s Human Rights, "Stop prostitution! 2007 CWHR webzine. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

19 Rowe, J., "Shantusi: Surveying HIV and need in the unregulated sex industry, in Resourcing Health & Education in the Sex Industry" Inner South Community Health/RMIT University 2011

20 Jang, H., "Sex trafficking or shadow tourism: The lives of foreign sex workers in Australia" Lambert Academic Publishing 2010

21 Agustin, L., "Sex at the margins: Migration, labour markets and the rescue industry" Zed Books 2007

22 WHRCK, "See Women’s Human Rights Commission of Korea"

23 CWHR, "See Center for Women’s Human Rights"

24 Schloenhardt, A., "Return and reintegration of human trafficking victims from Australia" 23 (23): 1-31, 2011

25 Jeffreys, S., "Prostitution, trafficking and feminism: An update on the debate" 32 : 316-320, 2009

26 Leidholdt, D., "Prostitution and trafficking in women: An intimate relationship, in Prostitution, trafficking, and traumatic stress" The Haworth Maltreatment & Trauma Press 167-183, 2003

27 Farley, M., "Prostitution and trafficking in Nevada: Making the connections" Prostitution Research & Education 2007

28 Farley, M., "Prostitution and trafficking in Asia" 8 (8): 2005

29 Carson, L., "Prostitution and sex trafficking: What are the problems represented to be? A discursive analysis of law and policy in Sweden and Victoria, Australia" 34 : 63-87, 2011

30 Australian Government, "People trafficking. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

31 Segrave, M., "Order at the border: The repatriation of victims of trafficking" 32 (32): 251-260, 2009

32 Shin, G., "One alliance, two lenses: U.S.-Korea relations in a new era" Stanford University Press 2010

33 Women’s Human Rights Commission of Korea, "New on-site support strategies for minors at risk outcomes. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

34 Davidson, J. O., "Moving children? Child trafficking, child migration, and child rights" 31 (31): 454-477, 2011

35 Anti-human trafficking effort lauded, "March 6. New Straits Times"

36 Sullivan, M., "Making sex work: A failed experiment in legalised prostitution" Spinifex Press 2007

37 "Legislative Assembly for the Australian Capital Territory, Standing Committee on Justice and Community Safety. 2011, July 13. Transcript of evidence. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

38 Song, Y., "Japanese colonial rule and state-managed prostitution: Korea’s licensed prostitutes" 5 (5): 171-219, 1997

39 Drugs, "Inquiry into people trafficking for sex work – final report" Parliament of Victoria 2010

40 Marginson, M., "Increasing access for Filipina survivors of domestic violence" Domestic Violence and Incest Resources Centre and Office of the Status of Women 1996

41 Schloenhardt, A., "Human trafficking and sexual servitude in Australia" 32 (32): 27-49, 2009

42 Jang, J, "Human Trafficking for Sexual Exploitation between Korea and U.S.A. Korean Institute of Criminology. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

43 Kruger, P., "Groups urge action to stop sex trafficking. The World Today. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

44 Schloenhardt, A., "Global perspectives on human trafficking: Australia. Keynote address at the conference Combating Human Trafficking: Cooperating to Build Best Practices in B.C. and Beyond, Vancouver, British Columbia, October 29, 2008. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

45 Ramachandran, V., "Gender issues in higher education–advocacy brief. Bangkok: UNESCO. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

46 Jang, H., "Factors influencing labour migration of Korean women into the entertainment and sex industry in Australia. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

47 Dasi Hamkke Center, "Exposing the price tag: An in-depth look at the fight to eradicate the sex trade in South Korea" 2010

48 Australian Government, "Criminal Code Amendment (Trafficking in Persons Offences) Act 2005, No. 96. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

49 Derks, A., "Combating trafficking in South-East Asia: A review of policy and programme responses. Geneva: International Organization for Migration. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

50 Davidson, J. O., "Children in the global sex trade" Polity 2005

51 "Australia combats human trafficking through Indonesian partnership. M2 Presswire. 2007, August 27. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

52 Lovering, D., "Australia announces US$5.4 million plan to fight human trafficking in Southeast Asia" Associated Press Newswires 2003

53 Women’s Human Rights Commission of Korea, "Annual report" 2009

54 Government Offices of Sweden, "Against prostitution and human trafficking for sexual purposes. Sweden. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

55 Munro,V., "A tale of two servitudes: Defining and implementing a domestic response to trafficking of women for prostitution in the UK and Australia" 14 (14): 91-114, 2005

56 Kakar SR, "A retrospective case note review of sex worker attendees at sexual health clinics in the western suburbs of Sydney" 7 (7): 3-7, 2010

57 Piper, N., "A problem by a different name? A review of research on trafficking in South-East Asia and Oceania" 43 (43): 203-233, 2005

58 Australian Broadcasting Corporation, "2011, October 17. Sex slavery. Retrieved December 3, 2011"

59 Thomson, T., "2011, October 11. Death and drugs. Courier Mail"

60 McKenzie, N., "2011, October 10. Legal brothels’ sex slavery links. The Age. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

61 Bell, E., "2011, November 18. Industry calls for migrant sex worker visas. Yahoo News. Retrieved November 20, 2011"

62 Marriner, C., "2011, July 3. Low prices fuel exotic sex trade. The Age. Retrieved November 27, 2011"

63 Bucci, N. S., "2010, December 4. Korean sex trade growing, report says. The Canberra Times"

64 Kissane, K., "2008, May 14. Judge warns many could be snared by slavery laws. The Age. Retrieved November 20, 2011"

65 Ramachandran, A., "2008, December 23. Brothels said to operate in unit block where woman’s body found. The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

66 Jeffreys, E., "2008, April 4. Truth and visas will set Asian sex workers free. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

67 Women Lured into Australian Sex Trade, "2006, November 22. Chosun Ilbo. Retrieved December 3, 2011"

68 Lee, M., "2006, March 20. Study reveals Korean sex trade victims. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

69 Smiles, S., "2006, June 30. Police move to curb sex slavery. The Age. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

70 O’Brien, N., "2005, January 12. Use and abuse. The Australian"

71 Sohn, H., "2005, February 23. Prostitutes leave Korea to work. JoongAng Daily. Retrieved July 29, 2011"

72 Baker, M., "2003, July 19. Sex slaves sent home but an endless pool replaces them. The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved November 20, 2011"

73 Maltzahn, K., "2001, August 28. Trafficking in women for prostitution. Paper presented at the Australian Women Conference. Retrieved July 30, 2011"

74 Fredericks, K., "1993, March 24. The trade in Asian women. Green Left Weekly. Retrieved July 30, 2011"