프랑스 헌법원판결과 법률에 대한 조약우위의 원칙 = The Fundamental Rule of Treaty-Predominance to Laws in France

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In fifth republic of France (l958), article 61 of the Constitution authorized the Conseil d'Etat to judge the unconstitutionality of laws. The Conseil d'Etat has judged the unconstitutionality of laws on the authority of this power.
Presently, the Preamble of the Constitution acknowledge the trial-norrnity of' the Declaration of Rights of Human and Citizen in 1789', the Fundamental Rule acknowledged by the Third Republic Laws and the Preamble of the Constitution in 1946.
These is called the Constitutional-Block in a lump. But it is the Protection-Treaty of Human Rights and the Fundamental Liberties in Europe(called in next the Europe Treaty of Human Rights).
This Treaty regulated the establishment of the Committee of Human Rights in Europe, the Court of Human Rights in Europe and the Committee of the Ministerial in Europe, in Strasburg.
Also this Treaty levy the duty of the respect of the Human Rights for the contracting parties in the Treaty and aim at the remedy of the infringement of the Human Rights that not can be remedied by all remedy systems of the contracting parties in the Treaty.
But the Conseil d'Etat in France and the Court of the Human Rights jointly aimed at the protection of Human Rights, nevertheless be different from the method of investigation.
Well known, the former adopt the metaphysical unconstitutionality, the latter is the concrete unconstitutionality in the matter of the infringement of Human Rights.
The Treaty of Human Rights in Europe consists of the Constitution(the Constitution-Block). Therefore, I regard that accelerate the function of the protection of Human Rights if the Conseil d'Etat can judged the suitability-inspect of the Laws to Treaty.
But the Article 55 of the Present Constitution regulated the Treaty-Predominance to Laws. It is important that how interpretate the Treaty-Predominance to Laws.
Therefore, this thesis aimed at the Rule of the Treaty-Predominance to Laws and aimed that whether or not the Constitution-Block included the Treaty of Human Rights in Europe by investigating the cases of the suitability of the Laws to the Treaty of the Conseil d'Etat.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• I. 서론
• II. 현행법의 법률에 대한 조약우위의 원칙의 성립과정
• III. 법률에 대한 조약우위의 원칙과 헌법원판결의 동향
• IV. 결론

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 建石眞公子, "法律に對する條約優位原則の裁判的保障(1)" 1993

2 高野雄一, "新版 國際法槪論 下" 1985

3 La Documentations francaise, "volume III" 1988

4 Dominique Rousseau, "Versun ordre jurdictionnel europeen des droits et livertes?" 1997

5 Assemblee nationale, "Val-d'Oise,cinquieme circonscription" 1988

6 L.Favoreu, "Recueil de jurisprudence constitutipnelle" 1994

7 L.Favoreu, "Les grandes decisions du Conseil constitutionel,9 ed." 1997

8 B.GENEVOIS, "Le juge de l'election,le traite et la loi- A propos de la decision du Conseil constitutionnel d u" 1988

9 B.GENEVOIS, "Le juge de l'election,le traite et la loi" 1988

10 Patrick Frydman, "Le juge administratif,le traite et la loi posterieure" 1989

11 Jean Rivero, "Le constitutionnel et les libertes,2ed." 1987

12 F.Luchaire, "Le conseil constitutionnel et la souverainete nationale" 1991

13 F.Luchaire, "La protection constitutionnelle des droits et des libertes" 1987

14 F.Luchaire, "La loi relative a l'entree et au sejour des etrangers et au droit d'asile devant le Conseil constitutionnel" 1998

15 Jacques Robert, "La loi et les traites" 1975

16 Brono Genvois, "La liberte individuelle,le droit d'asile et les eonventions internationales" 1987

17 Roger Pinto, "La constitution de la Republque francaise,2 ed." 1987

18 Patrick Gaia, "Jurisprudence du Conseil constitutionnel" 1991

19 Charlotte Denizeau, "Existe-t-il un bloc de constituionnalite?" 1997

20 Benard Chantebout, "Droit constitutionnel et science politique,13 ed." 1996

21 Decision no.96-375DC, "Decision no.96-375DC" 1996

22 Decision no.92-312, "Decision no.92-312DC" 1992

23 Decision no.91-298 DC, "Decision no.91-298 DC" 1991

24 Decision no.89-268 DC, "Decision no.89-268 DC" 1991

25 Decision C.C.no 88-1082/1117, "Decision C.C.no 88-1082/1117" 1988

26 D.Rousseau, "Chronique de jurisprudence constitutionnelle" 1997

27 Cour de cassation, "Chambre mixte" 1975

28 Conseil d'Etat, "Assemblee" 1989