인지연산문법의 역동적 원시소: 반반상대성이론에 대한 비판적 숙고 = Dynamic Primitives and Anti-Anti-Relativism in the theory of Cognitive and Applicative Grammar

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper presents a critical reflection on anti-anti-relativism proposed in the framework of the theory of Cognitive and Applicative Grammar(Descles 1997, 1998, etc.). The Cognitive and Applicative Grammar is a polystratal model, that extends the Shaumyan``s Universal Applicative Grammar. According to this theory, each natural language constructs specific cognitive representations across languages, but these cognitive representations are organized with the same elementary cognitive ingredients (invariants) : types (or different primitive categorizations); relations and operations (for instance topological operations). This paper seeks to offer a critical, reflective analysis of the basic elements of Descles’s approach to cognitive invariants.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 서종석, "역동적 원시소와 상식 행위론" 인문과학연구소 34 (34): 211-230, 2007

2 Desclés,J.-P, "Transitivité sémantique, transitivitésyntaxique" La transitivité 161-180, 1998

3 Talmy,L, "The windowing of attention in language, In Grammaticalconstructions" Their form and meaning 235-287, 1996

4 Fodor, J, "The Language of Thought" Crowell Company 1975

5 Croft, W, "Syntactic categories and grammatical relations:the cognitive organization of information" University of Chicago Press 1991

6 Dijk, Teun, "Strategies of Discourse Comprension" Academia Press 1983

7 Langacker,R.W, "Settings, participants, and grammatical relations, In Meanings and Prototypes" Studies in Linguistics Categorization 213-237, 1990

8 Wierzbicka,A, "Semantics primes ans universals" Oxford University Press 2003

9 Jackendoff, R, "Semantics and Cognition" MIT Press 1983

10 Le Ny, J.-F, "Science cognitive et compréhension du langage" Presses Universitaires de France 1989

11 Desclés,J.-P, "Réflexions sur les grammaires cognitives" 1 : 69-98, 1994

12 Benveniste,E, "Problèmes de la linguistique générale" Gallimard 1966

13 Lemmens,M, "Lexical Perspectives on Transitivity and Ergativity. Causative Constructions in English" John Benjamins Publishing Company 1998

14 Desclés,J.-P, "Les représentations cognitives du langagesont-elles universelles ?, In La réalité et lesigne : Essais sur le langage, logique et sens commun" Éditions Universit aires 53-81, 1998

15 Wierzbicka,A, "La quête des primitifs sémantiques : 1965–1992" 99 : 9-22, 1993

16 Langacker, R. W, "Foundations of Cognitive Grammar vol. 2,Descriptive Applications" Stanford University Press 1991

17 Talmy,L, "Force dynamics in language and cognition" 12 : 49-100, 1988

18 Quine,W.V.O, "Facts of the Matter, In Essays on the Philosophy of W. V. O. Quine" Harvester 1979

19 DeLancey, S, "Event construal and case role assignment" 17 : 338-353, 1991

20 Thomsen,O.N, "Dyirbal ergativity and embedding: Afunctional-pragmatic approach" 18 (18): 411-488, 1994

21 Langacker,R.W, "Concept, Image, and Symbol : The Cognitive Basisof Grammar" de Gruyter 1991

22 Desclés, J.-P, "Causalité, causativité,transitivité" Typology ofverbal categories 7-27, 1998

23 Chomsky,N, "Aspects of the theory of syntax" MIT Press 1965

24 Cienki, A, "9th and 20th century theories of case, Acomparison of localist and cognitive approaches" 1 : 23-162, 1995