관광 현상에 대한 이론 개발 고찰 = A Study on Theory-building for Tourism Phenomenon

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The ultimate goal of science is theory. Tourism research still lacks a conceptualization scheme, theoretical framework, and a cumulative knowledge. One of the reasons is that many tourism researchers have been preoccupied with the short-term goal of finding specific relations from accepting or rejecting a hypothesis to track and record a staggering expansion of the tourism industry. Thus, there is a need to guide an outline on the systematic process of theory- building in tourism studies. In this context, this paper provides the insight and conceptual framework for the building and understanding of tourism theory that will lead the tourism science into a discipline, not a field of study or a special form of leisure. In particular, the study discusses an emergent paradigm shift from tourism studies and researchers and identifies a virtue of good theory and scientific theory-building process. This conceptual paper could help researchers gain insights in terms of theory-building and its necessity with a sense of responsibility as a tourism researcher. The study makes a conceptual and theoretical contribution to expanding scientific domain of tourism knowledge.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이두희, "한국적 광고이론 개발의 토대" 8 (8): 231-258, 1993

2 김철원, "관광현상 규명을 위한 질적 연구방법의 고찰과 적용" 한국관광학회 33 (33): 11-30, 2009

3 장병권, "관광학과 인접학문간의 관계: 學問的 獨立과 融合의 관점에서" 한국관광학회 32 (32): 75-93, 2008

4 김사헌, "관광학 연구에 있어서 질적 연구방법론의 상황과 도전: 관광학회지 논문의 메타분석" 한국관광학회 31 (31): 13-32, 2007

5 한범수, "관광학 연구논문의 조사설계방법에 대한 비판적 고찰 : 한국관광학회 간행 관광학연구지를 중심으로" 25 (25): 13-33, 2001

6 이돈재, "東·西洋 學問的 관점에서 본 ‘觀光學’ 論議: 學問으로의 정립과 『관광학연구』誌의 역할" 한국관광학회 32 (32): 55-74, 2008

7 Goodman, N., "Ways of Worldmaking" Hackett PublishingCompany, Inc 1978

8 Tribe, J., "Tribes, Territories and Networks in the Tourism Academy" 37 (37): 7-33, 2010

9 Oppermann, M., "Triangulation : A Methodological Discussion" 2 : 141-146, 2000

10 Hall, M., "Tourism: Conceptualizations,Institutions, and Issues, In ACompanion to Tourism" Blackwell Publishing 3-21, 2004

11 Weick, K. E., "Theory Construction as Disciplined Imagination" 14 (14): 516-531, 1989

12 Torraco, R. J., "Theory Building Research Methods, In Human Resource Development ResearchHandbook: Linking Research and Practice" Berrett-Kohler 114-138, 1997

13 Dubin, R., "Theory Building" The Free Press 1978

14 Dann, G., "Theoretical Advances in the Sociological Treatment ofTourism, In The International Handbookof Sociology" Sage 367-384, 2000

15 Franklin, A., "The Trouble with Tourism and TravelTheory" 1 (1): 5-22, 2001

16 Dann, G., "The Theoretical State of the Art in the Sociology andAnthropology of Tourism" 10 : 3-15, 2005

17 Handfield, R. B., "The Scientific Theory-building Process : A Primer Using the Case of TQM" 16 : 321-339, 1998

18 Valentine, K., "The One-way Mirror ofLeisure Research : A Need for Cross-national Social ScientificPerspectives" 21 : 241-246, 1999

19 Popper, K. R., "The Logic of Scientific Discovery" ScienceEditions 1961

20 Wallace, W., "The Logic of Science in Sociology" AldineAtherton 1971

21 Dartnall, J., "The Literature of Tourism" 1 (1): 49-53, 1990

22 Echtner, C. M., "The Disciplinary Dilemma of TourismStudies" 24 (24): 868-883, 1997

23 Dann, G., "Sociology and Tourism" 18 (18): 155-169, 1991

24 Carter, R., "Resource Management inTourism Research: A New Direction?" 9 (9): 265-280, 2001

25 Goeldner, C. R., "Reflections on the Historic Role of Journals inShaping Tourism Knowledge" 16 (16): 44-51, 2005

26 Mannell, R. C., "Psychological nature of leisureand tourism experience" 14 : 314-331, 1987

27 Bergmann, G., "Philosophy of Science" The Universityof Wisconsin Press 1957

28 Bacharach, S. B., "Organizational Theories : Some Criteria for Evaluation" 14 (14): 496-515, 1989

29 Gioia, D. A., "Multiparadigm Perspectives on TheoryBuilding" 15 (15): 584-602, 1990

30 Dann, G., "Methodology in Tourism Research" 15 : 1-28, 1988

31 Hunt, S. D., "Marketing Theory : Critical Issues in the Philosophy ofMarketing Science" South-Western Publishing Co 1991

32 Swamidass, P. M., "Manufacturing Strategy : Its Assessment andPractice" 6 (6): 471-484, 1986

33 Tribe, J., "Indisciplined and Unsubstantiated" 27 (27): 809-813, 2000

34 Quine, W. V., "Hypothesis, In Introductory Readings in thePhilosophy of Science" Prometheus Books 1980

35 Kaplan, M., "Four Theoretical Approaches to Leisure-Past to Present" 20 (20): 523-532, 1997

36 Kerlinger, F. N., "Foundations of Behavioral Research" Holt, Rinehart & Winston, Inc 1986

37 Goetz, J. P., "Ethnography and Qualitative DesignIneducational Research" Academic Press 1984

38 Hammersley, M., "Deconstructing the Qualitative-QuantitativeDivide, What’s Wrong with Ethnography?" Routledge 1992

39 Xiao, H., "Case Studies in Tourism Research : AState-of-the-Art Analysis" 27 : 738-749, 2006

40 Corley, K. G., "Building Theory about TheoryBuilding: What Constitutes a Theoretical Contribution?" 36 (36): 12-32, 2011

41 Eisenhardt, K. M., "Building Theories from Case Study Research" 14 (14): 532-550, 1989

42 Csikszentmihalyi, M., "Beyond Boredom and Anxiety: The Experienceof Play in Work and Games" Jossey-Bass Publishers 1975

43 Moore, K., "Behavioral Conceptualizationof Tourism and Leisure" 22 (22): 67-85, 1995

44 Hedrick, T. E., "Applied Research Design : A Practical Guide" Sage Publications 1993

45 Leiper, N, "An Emerging Discipline" 27 (27): 805-809, 2000

46 Cohen, E., "A Phenomenology of Tourism Experiences" 13 : 179-201, 1979

47 Wacker, J. G., "A Definition of Theory : Research Guidelines forDifferent Theory-building Research Methods in Operations Management" 16 : 361-385, 1998