Pervasiveness of Price Fixing in Korea: An Analysis of Causal Factors in Comparison with the United States

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Price fixing is one of the most serious forms of corporate crime, but is rarely recognized as such by the public. For consumers, price fixing has a direct impact, as it raises prices and reduces choices.
The scrutiny against, and prosecution of, such anticompetitive practice is important not only to protect the consumer but also to uphold free and open competition in the economy. Even though government administrators and policymakers fittingly perceive the illegality of the practice and its severity, the extent to which anticompetitive legislation is enforced varies greatly from country to country. For example, although South Korea is known to be a country with a relatively high level of cartel activities, its antitrust laws and actual prosecution of corporations engaging in price fixing have been found to be lax. On the other hand, the United States, the nexus of global trade and world markets but also a business-friendly country, is known to have relatively low-level cartel activity. The question is: What accounts for the fact that price fixing scandals have become a pedestrian phenomenon in South Korea? This paper provides a comparative analysis of the nature of price fixing in South Korea and the United States, arguing that price fixing occurs more frequently in Korea because of its lax laws against price fixing, as evidenced by moderate fines and penalties. The paper also identifies the factors that account for the lenient laws against anticompetitive activities in South Korea, and explores ways to improve mechanisms to deter those activities.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 설민수, "규제완화와 공정거래법의 적용 : 행정지도가 개입된 가격담합을 중심으로" 한국법학원 118 (118): 234-276, 2010

2 Kwon, Ohseung, "Why Should We Compete?" 9 : 2003

3 Levenstein, Margaret C., "What Determines Cartel Success?" 64 : 2006

4 Golub, Alla, "The Profitability of Price Fixing: Have Stronger Antitrust Sanctions Deterred?" 3 : 2005

5 Sullivan, E. Thomas, "The Political Economy of the Sherman Act: The First One Hundred Years" Oxford University Press 1991

6 Greenberg, Brad A., "The News Deal: How Price-Fixing and Collusion Can Save the Newspaper Industry—and Why Congress Should Promote It" 59 : 2011

7 Jones, Bryce J., "The Fall of the Per Se Vertical Price Fixing Rule" 13 (13): 2010

8 Marshall, Robert C., "The Economics of Collusion: Cartels and Bidding Rings" The MIT Press 2012

9 Kim, Na Young, "The Determinants of Leniency Program Application and Its Effects on Antitrust Enforcement" 18 (18): 2010

10 The New York Times, "Taiwan Company Fined $ 500 Million for Price-Fixing"

11 Kim, Nam-su, "Study of Price-Collusion and Consumer Remedial Scheme" Korea Consumer Agency 2007

12 Oh, Young-Jung, "Study of Characteristics of Recent Cartels and Its Restraint Way" 426 : 2012

13 Kim, Hyeonsoo, "Several Topics in Cartel Leniency Program Implementation" 12 (12): 2010

14 The Korea Herald, "Samsung, LG Fined for Fixing Prices of Home Appliances"

15 Hur, Sun, "Requirements for Determining Illegality of Price Fixing and Hard Cartel: Focusing on the Deliberation by The Fair Trade Commission Regarding the Limitation of Competition" (117) : 2005

16 Lee, Min Ho, "Recent Developments in the Treatment of Collusion by Korean Courts" 4 (4): 2005

17 Gift, Paul, "Price Fixing and Minimum Resale Price Restrictions Are Two Different Animals" 12 (12): 2009

18 김은기, "PRICE FIXING IN THE UNITED STATES AND KOREA: A COMPARISON OF LEGAL FRAMEWORKS, PUNISHMENT, AND IMPACT" 한국부패학회 17 (17): 17-37, 2012

19 Dong-A Ilbo, "Nongshim: We Didn’t Engage in Price-Fixing … There is No Reason for It"

20 Ministry of Legislation, Republic of Korea, "Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act"

21 The Korea Times, "Lotte Chilsung Fined for Collusion"

22 McMurray, Nathan, "Losing Face. The North Face Hit with a Huge Fine for Retail Price Fixing"

23 Letwin, William, "Law and Economic Policy in America: The Evolution of the Sherman Antitrust Act" University of Chicago Press 1981

24 U.S. Department of Justice, "Korean Company Pays Second Largest Criminal Antitrust Fine in U.S. History"

25 The Korea Herald, "Insurers Fined W365b for Price-Fixing"

26 Kim, Doo Jin, "Improving Efficiency through Antitrust Dual Enforcement" 57 (57): 2008

27 Connor, John M., "Global Price Fixing" Springer 2008

28 Sprigman, Christopher, "Fix Prices Globally, Get Sued Locally? U.S. Jurisdiction over International Cartels" 72 (72): 2005

29 People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy, "Fines Levied against Price Fixing Last Year Amounts to Only 2% of the Revenue"

30 Kim Iljoong, "Fair Trade Law and Criminal Punishment: An Empirical Investigation on the Determinants of Criminal Accusation in Korea" 22 (22): 2011

31 Zingales, Nicole, "European and American Leniency Programmes: Two Models towards Convergence?" 5 (5): 2008

32 Mann, Richard A., "Essentials of Business Law" Thomson/South-Western West 2004

33 U.S. Department of Justice, "DENSO Corporation Executive Agrees to Plead Guilty to Automobile Parts Price-Fixing and Bid-Rigging Conspiracy: Executive Agrees to Serve 14 Months in U.S. Prison"

34 Kwon, Soo-jin, "Criminal Sanctions against Cartels" Korean Institute of Criminology 2011

35 Rose-Ackerman, Susan, "Corruption: A Study in Political Economy" Academic Press 1978

36 The Korea Times, "Conglomerates Fined 2.4 Tril, Won for Int’l Price Rigging"

37 Kaplow, Louis, "Competition Policy and Price Fixing" Princeton University Press 2013

38 "Citizens’ Coalition for Economic Justice"

39 Osborne, Dale K., "Cartel Problems" 66 (66): 1976

40 The Korea Times, "Cable Firms Fined for Collusion"

41 BBC News, "BA’s Price-Fix Fine Reaches £270m"

42 Wells, Wyatt C., "Antitrust and the Formation of the Postwar World" Columbia University Press 2002

43 Freyer, Tony A., "Antitrust and Global Capitalism, 1930-2004" Cambridge University Press 2006

44 Hylton, Keith N., "Antitrust Law: Economic Theory and Common Law Evolution" Cambridge University Press 2003

45 Posner, Richard A., "Antitrust Law" University of Chicago Press 2002

46 Ashenfelter, Orley C., "Anatomy of the Rise and Fall of a Price-Fixing Conspiracy: Auctions at Sotheby’s and Christie’s" 1 (1): 2005

47 Choi, Yun Jeong, "An Empirical Analysis of the Corporate Leniency Program in Korea: Its Amendments in 2005" 18 (18): 2011

48 Office of Fair Trading, "Agreements and Concerted Practices: Understanding Competition Law"

49 Stigler, George J., "A Theory of Oligopoly" 72 : 1964

50 High, Jack C., "A Century of the Sherman Act: American Economic Opinion, 1890-1990" University Publication Association 1992

51 Korea Fair Trade Commission, "2013 Yearbook"