Labour perspectives on the new politics of skill and competency formation: International reflections

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Skill/competency approaches to workplace-based policy seek to assess and train for discrete individual competencies with the goal of increasing employability and productivity. These approaches have become increasingly prominent across a range of advanced capitalist countries. A substantial critique has emerged over this same period regarding issues of instrumentality and social control, as well as the failure of skill/compentancy approaches to articulate a meaningful understanding of human learning capacities. In this article, these critical perspectives are clarified further by a review of contributions to understanding the skill/competence question emerging from sociology of work literature. Building from these critiques, this article outlines recent experiences with and perspectives on skill/competency frameworks amongst different national labour movements. Included in this outline is a more detailed, comparative analysis of Norway and Canada; here we see the lofty 'new', 'knowledge economy' rhetoric - in two countries where one might expect to see it blossom in application - brought down to earth by the realities of industrial relations, employer intransigence and intra-labour movement differences. 'Skill/competence' proves to be a floating signifier that, amongst both employers and labour, stands as a proxy for 'power/control' struggles. Degenerating in this way, from a labour perspective, the new politics of skill/competency formation is seen to have spiraled toward irrelevance in Norway and Canada; awaiting, in both countries, a re-invigoration through attention to changes in the participatory structure of the labour process itself.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Courtney, S., "Why adults learn: Towards a theory of participation in adult education" Routledge 1992

2 Lafer, G., "What is ‘skill’? Training for discipline in the low-wage labour market, In The skills that matter" Palgrave Macmillan 109-127, 2004

3 Peetz, D., "Unions in a contrary world : The future of the Australian trade union movement" Cambridge University Press 1998

4 Pencavel, J., "Unionism viewed internationally" 26 (26): 65-97, 2005

5 Sawchuk, P. H., "Understanding the work/learning implications of ‘community unionism’ in Canada: The case of hotel workers organizing in Toronto" 2007

6 Waddington, J., "Trying to stem the flow: Union membership turnover in the public sector" 30 : 184-196, 1999

7 Rainbird, H., "Training in the workplace" Macmillan 2000

8 Cooney, R., "Trade unions and training: Issues and international perspectives" National Key Centre in Industrial Relations, Monash University 1-18, 2004

9 Teige, B., "Trade union involvement in lifelong learning in Norway, In Trade unions and training: Issues and international perspectives" National Key Centre in Industrial Relations, Monash University 162-174, 2004

10 Waddington, J., "Towards a reform agenda? European trade unions in transition" 31 (31): 317-330, 2000

11 Canadian Labour Congress, "To the house of commons standing committee on human resources, social development and the status of persons with disabilities"

12 Sawchuk, P. H., "The ‘unionization effect’ amongst adult computer learners" 24 (24): 639-648, 2003

13 Payne, J., "The unbearable lightness of skill : The changing meaning of skill in UK policy discourses and some implications for education and training" 15 (15): 353-369, 2000

14 Warhurst, C., "The skills that matter" Palgrave Macmillan 2004

15 Green, A., "The many faces of lifelong learning : Recent education policy trends in Europe" 17 (17): 611-626, 2002

16 Nonaka, I., "The knowledge-creating company: How Japanese companies create the dynamics of innovation" Oxford University Press 1995

17 Littler, C., "The development of the labour process in capitalist societies: A comparative analysis of work organization in Britain, the USA and Japan" Heinemann 1982

18 Wood, S., "The degradation of work? Skill, deskilling and the labour process" Hutchinson 1982

19 Martin, A., "The brave new world of European labour" Berghahn 1999

20 Payne, J., "The Norwegian competence reform and the limits of lifelong learning" 25 (25): 477-505, 2006

21 Spenner, K., "Temporal changes in work content" 44 (44): 968-975, 1979

22 Tinker, T., "Specters of Marx and braverman in the twilight of postmodernist labour process research" 16 (16): 251-281, 2002

23 Kelly, J., "Social partnership in Britain : Good for profits, bad for jobs and unions" 30 : 3-10, 1999

24 Shah, C., "Skills shortages: Concepts, measurement and policy Responses" 31 (31): 44-71, 2005

25 Jackson, N., "Skills formation and gender relations: The politics of who knows what" Deakin University Press 1991

26 OECD, "Review of national policies for education: Lifelong learning in Norway" OECD publications 2002

27 Martinez Lucio, M., "Regulating skill formation in Europe : German, Norwegian and Spanish policies on transferable skills" 13 (13): 323-340, 2007

28 Frenkel, S., "On the front live: Organization of work in the information economy" Cornell University Press 1999

29 Nergaard, K., "Norway trade union density stable. European Industrial Relations Observatory Online"

30 Vu, U., "Northern mine develops essential skills in its workforce" 18 (18): 8-10, 2005

31 Warhurst, C., "Mapping knowledge in work: Proxies or practices?" 20 (20): 787-800, 2006

32 Burawoy, M., "Manufacturing consent : Changes in the labour process under monopoly capitalism" University of Chicago Press 1979

33 Skule, S., "Learning-conducive work: A survey of learning conditions in Norwegian workplaces" CEDEFOP (Luxembourg Office for Official Publications of the European Communities) 2002

34 Forrester, K., "Learning for revival : British trade unions and workplace learning" 27 (27): 257-270, 2005

35 Braverman, H., "Labor and monopoly capital: The degradation of work in the twentieth century" Monthly Review Press 1974

36 Coffield, F., "Introduction: A critical analysis of the concept of a learning society, In Different visions of a learning society" Policy Press 1-38, 2000

37 Skule, S., "International briefing: Training and development in Norway" 6 (6): 263-276, 2002

38 Vince, R., "Ideas for critical practitioners, In Critical thinking in human resource development" Routledge 2005

39 Brown, P., "High skills : Globalisation, competitiveness and skill formation" Oxford University Press 2001

40 HRSDC, "Essential skills: Tools and applications"

41 Fenwick, T., "Essential skills, globalization and neo-liberal policy: Challenging skills-based agendas for workplace learning" 2005

42 Canadian Labour Congress, "Essential skills and the labour movement" Canadian Labour Congress 2005

43 HRSDC, "Essential skills" Human Resources and Skills Development of Canada

44 Livingstone, D. W., "Education-jobs gap (2nd ed.)" Broadview 2004

45 Olsen, M., "Education policy: Globalisation, citizenship and democracy" Sage publications 2004

46 Rikowski, G., "Education for industry : A complex technicism" 14 (14): 29-49, 2001

47 Thompson, P., "Disconnected capitalism: Or why employers can't keep their side of the bargain" 17 (17): 359-378, 2003

48 OECD, "Developing highly skilled workers: Review of Norway" OECD publications 2004

49 Mojab, S., "De-skilling immigrant women" 19 (19): 123-128, 1999

50 Hurd, R., "Contesting the dinosaur image: The US labour movement’s search for a future" 7 (7): 451-465, 2001

51 Zimbalist, A., "Case studies on the labor process" Monthly Review Press 1979

52 Hayes, B., "Canadian organizations move to develop workplace literacy and numerical skills" 18 (18): 7-10, 2005

53 Baldry, C., "Bright satanic offices: Intensification, control and team taylorism, In Workplaces of the Future" Macmillan 163-183, 1998

54 Waddington, J., "Articulating trade union organisation for the new Europe?" 32 (32): 449-463, 2001

55 Sawchuk, P. H., "Adult learning and technology in working-class life" Cambridge University Press 2003

56 Boreham, N., "A theory of collective competence : Challenging the neo-liberal individualisation of performance at work" 52 (52): 5-17, 2004

57 Anonymous, "$37M boost to sector councils" 17 (17): 3-, 2004