芥川龍之介와 谷崎潤一郎의 플롯논쟁 일고찰 = The study of plot argument between Akutagawa Ryunosuke and Tanizaki Junichiro

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The concept of the plot has been continuously changed up to today as Aristoteles has presented its concept for the first time, and still has not been clearly defined yet in a form of single explicit concept. However, one of the most differentiated factor in plot is developments of affair by cause and effect relationship, and secondly implementation of subject, and lastly formation of novel"s beauty of art. This is one of the most important factor in novel, and whether plot is good or not has correlation to evaluate whether the novel is good or not. Anti-Plot novel, which is primarily to destroy the story of today"s modern novel, but this can not denly that it has thought-provoking in even such novel.
With respect to the concept of such plot, there has been argument between Tanizaki Jynichiro and Akutagawa Ryunosuke who were two greatest literary men in Japan since 1927.
Tanizaki Jynichiro emphasized its interest and importance on Plot while Akutagawa Ryunosuke insisted novel without Plot is most artistic novel and pure art. The argument between theses two persons was ended in smoke, without winner due to Akutagawa Ryunosuke"s suicide. However, the argument has become important moment for those who study literature since then.
For this thesis, the concept of plot presented since Aristoteles era is to be examined, and plot arguments in Akutagawa Ryunosuke and Tanizaki Jynichiro will be discussed after. And finally, difference between novel with emphasis on Plot by Tanizaki Jynichiro and novel without emphasis on Plot by Akutagawa Ryunosuke will be examined.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 1. 서론
• 2. 소설에 있어서 플롯의 개념
• 3. 芥川竜之介와 谷崎潤一郎의 플롯논쟁
• 4. 시적정신과 플롯
• 5. 플롯이 있는 소설과 플롯이 없는 소설
• 6. 결론
• 參考文獻
• 要旨

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 한국소설학회, "현대소설 플롯의 시학" 태학사 36-, 1999

2 로널드 B. 토비아스, "인간의 마음을 사로잡는 스무가지 플롯, In 텍스트의 즐거음" 동문선 2003

3 김인호, "이야기의 힘, 새롭게 확장된 플롯의 역할" 한국서사학회 (5) : 22-, 2002

4 송현순, "아쿠타가와 류노스케 문학연구" 보고사 339-344, 2002

5 구인환, "소설의 작법" 95 : 73-83, 2004

6 E.M. 포스터, "소설의 이해" 문예출판사 98-100, 1990

7 구인환, "소설의 감상과 창작" 창조문예사 154-172, 2005

8 이혜경, "문학이론과 비평의 조율" 도서출판 동인 1996

9 이희승, "국어 대사전" 민중서림 4204-, 2004

10 蔡宜靜, "谷崎と芥川のシナリオ観-「筋のない小説」論争を中心に-" 現代社会文化研究 18-, 2003

11 "芥川竜之介全集 第十一巻" 岩波書店 506-, 1978

12 福田恒存, "芥川․谷崎の私小説論議, In 文藝" 河出書房 35-, 1956

13 平野謙, "現代日本文學論爭史" 未來社 141-157, 1969

14 高田瑞穗, "日本文学研究資料叢書ㆍ芥川龍之介Ⅰ" 有精堂 141-150, 1980

15 田中実, "小説の力" 大修館書店 156-, 2004

16 加藤典洋, "テクストから遠く離れて" 講談社 43-, 2004