Coping with Intersecting Vulnerabilities: Syrian Refugee Women Working in Textile Workshops in Istanbul

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study focuses on the intersecting vulnerabilities of Syrian women refugee workers in Istanbul and the practices they have developed and employed to cope with them. In the particular case of women refugee workers, the intersection of gender, labor, and refugee status creates overlapping vulnerabilities that invoke an understanding of the multidimensionality of women’s adverse experiences and coping practices. Thus, an exploratory research design was adopted to investigate how and to what extent the intersecting content of vulnerabilities is reflected in the coping practices of women refugee workers. In 2011, Turkey opened its doors to Syrian refugees fleeing the war in their country. However, with high unemployment rates and the prevalence of informal work, the situation Turkey offers refugees is far from an ideal employment context and can have devastating effects, particularly on women refugee workers. It is well known that they earn less than the minimum wage, work very long hours, and are exposed to ill treatment in the workplace. However, the ways in which they cope with these issues remain a mystery. To understand this, we used a qualitative method to collect data. We conducted semi-structured, in-depth interviews with 13 Syrian women working in textile workshops in the Zeytinburnu District of Istanbul. A feminist intersectional approach informed the content of this research. The findings show how intersecting vulnerabilities experienced by women refugee workers directly and greatly affect their coping practices. The findings further reveal that women refugee workers’ coping practices also have an intersectional content.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Braun-Lewensohn, O, "Women in refugee camps:Which coping resources help them to adapt?" 16 (16): 3990-, 2019

2 Makabenta, I. M, "WIT transactions on the built environment, Vol. 190: Disaster management" WIT Press 65-77, 2019

3 Kaya, A, "Vulnerability assessment of Syrian refugees in Istanbul. (The Diakonie Katastrophenhilfe and Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation-Support to Life Report)"

4 Tankink, M, "Voices of Trauma" Springer 191-210, 2007

5 Erez, E, "Violence against immigrant women and systemic responses:An exploratory study (Report submitted to National Institute of Justice)"

6 Mülteciler Derneği, "Türkiye’deki Suriyeli sayısı"

7 Oktay, F, "Türkiye’deki Suriyeli Kadınlar Raporu (AFAD Working Paper)"

8 Korkmaz, E. E, "Türkiye’de tekstil sanayisinin sosyal taraflarının mülteci işçilerin istihdamına bakışı" 56 (56): 93-120, 2018

9 Sosyal Güvenlik Kurumu, "Türkiye tekstil sektörünün istihdam verileri"

10 ILO, "Türkiye işgücü piyasasında Suriyeliler. (International Labour Organization Report)"

11 Reuters, "Turkish sweatshops Syrian children sew to survive"

12 European Commission Factsheet, "Turkey. (European Civil Protection and Humanitarian Aid Operations)"

13 Hurriyet Daily News, "Turkey will not send any refugees back: Turkish president"

14 Deutsche Welle, "Turk-Is: Aclik Siniri"

15 Gönül, S, "Toplumsal cinsiyet perspektifinden Türkiye’de Göç araştırmaları" GAR 80-100, 2020

16 Saygı, H, "Toplumsal Cinsiyet Perspektifinden Türiye’de GöçAraştırmaları" Su Gender 101-121, 2020

17 Uçar, C, "Toplumsal Cinsiyet Perspektifinden Türiye’de Göç Araştırmaları" Su Gender 38-56, 2020

18 Sevlü, H, "Toplumsal Cinsiyet Perspektifinden Türiye’de Göç Araştırmaları" Su Gender 56-80, 2020

19 Reinharz, S, "The interviewing: New lenses, new concerns" Sage Publications 73-91, 2003

20 Peri, G, "The human and economic implications of twenty-first century immigration policy" W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research 63-106, 2018

21 Brewis, J, "The ethics of researching friends: On convenience sampling in qualitative management and organization studies" 25 (25): 849-862, 2014

22 Clemens, M, "The economic and fiscal effects of grantingrefugees formal labor market access (TENT Report)"

23 The World Bank News, "Ten years on, Turkey continues its support for an ever-growing number of Syrianrefugees"

24 Acar, B, "Tekstil ve hazır giyim atölyelerinde çalışan genç yetişkin kadın işçilerin çalışma koşullarıve deneyimledikleri çok boyutlu sorunlar" 68 : 89-116, 2020

25 Barın, H, "Syrian women in Turkey: social struggles and solution proposals" 1 (1): 10-56, 2015

26 Caro, L. P, "Syrian refugees in the Turkish labour market (ILO Report)"

27 Rohwerder, B, "Syrian refugee women, girls, and people with disabilities in Turkey (Helpdesk Report)"

28 In Turkey, "Syrian child has to work to survive"

29 Mutlu, P, "Suriyeli göçmen işçilerin istanbul ölçeğinde tekstil sektörü emek piyasasına eklemlenmeleri ve etkileri" 56 (56): 69-92, 2018

30 Hofman, W. H. A, "Students or lower-skilled workers?"Displacement"at the bottom of the labour market" 45 (45): 127-146, 2003

31 Thoits, P. A, "Stress, coping, and social support processes: Where are we? What next?"

32 Lazarus, R. S, "Stress, appraisal and coping" Springer 1984

33 Krohne, H. W, "Stress and coping theories"

34 Herwig, R, "Strategies of resistance of Syrian female refugees in Şanlıurfa" 3 (3): 179-194, 2017

35 Directorate-General for Neighbourhood and Enlargement Negotiations, "Strategic mid-term evaluation of the facility for refugees in Turkey"

36 Beaman, L. A, "Social networks and the dynamics of labour market outcomes:Evidence from refugees resettled in the U.S" 79 (79): 128-161, 2012

37 Lamba, N. K, "Social capital and refugee resettlement: The social networks of refugees in Canada" 4 (4): 335-360, 2003

38 Leifer, M, "Singapore’s foreign policy: Coping with vulnerability" Routledge 2000

39 Locke, K. D, "Self-efficacy, values, and complementarity in dyadic interactions: Integrating interpersonal and social-cognitive theory" 33 (33): 94-109, 2007

40 Pittaway, E, "Refugees, Race, and Gender: The multiple discrimination against refugee women" 9 (9): 21-32, 2001

41 Pittaway, E, "Refugee women and girls in the comprehensive refugee response framework (working document)"

42 Snel, E, "Poverty, migration, and coping strategies: An introduction" 38 : 7-22, 2001

43 Kaya, M, "Ortadoğu KonferanslarıOrtadoğu’daki Çatışmalar Bağlamında Göç Sorunu Bildiri Kitabı" Kilis 7 Aralık Üniversitesi 155-171, 2016

44 Mamgain, V, "Offthe boat, now offto work: Refugees in the labour market in Portland Maine" 16 (16): 113-146, 2003

45 Yücel, A, "Needs assessment of Syrian women and girls under temporary protection status in Turkey"

46 Pombo, G, "Migrant women and gender violence, strategies and perspectives for interventions (IOM development report)"

47 Körükmez, L, "Mecburiyet, müzakere, değişim : Suriyeli kadınların çalışma deneyimleri ve toplumsal cinsiyet ilişkileri" GAR 2020

48 h, D. E, "Just methods: An interdisciplinary feminist reader" Paradigm Publishers 39-43, 2008

49 Jaggar, A. M, "Just Methods: An Interdisciplinary Feminist Reader" Paradigm Publishers 34-39, 2008

50 Collins, P. H, "It’s all in the family : Intersections of gender, race and nation" 13 (13): 62-82, 1998

51 The Irish Times, "Istanbul letter: Sweatshops, not school await refugee children"

52 Toksöz, G, "Irregular labour migration in Turkey and situation of migrant workers in the labour market (Research paper)"

53 Easton Calabria, E, "International refugee congress 2018 consultation report"

54 Senthanar, S, "How do Syrian refugee women seek and find work? A feminist grounded analysis of work integration experiences in Canada (Unpublished doctoral dissertation)"

55 Carr, D, "Handbook of social psychology" Springer Science 465-487, 2013

56 Saniye Dedeoglu, "Gendering Industrial Subcontracting Work: A Qualitative Study of Garment Ateliers in Istanbul" 아시아여성연구원 27 (27): 25-52, 2011

57 Oakley, A, "Gender, methodology and people’s ways of knowing: Some problems with feminism and the paradigm debate in social science"

58 Von Hase, I, "From evidence to action: Tackling gender-based violence against migrant women and girls (policy brief)"

59 Sprague, J, "Feminist methodologies for critical researchers: Bridging differences" Altamira Press 2005

60 Gouws, A, "Feminist intersectionality and the matrix of domination in South Africa" 31 (31): 19-27, 2017

61 Kanal, M, "Everyday Agency : Rethinking Refugee Women’s Agency in Specific Cultural Contexts" 12 : 726729-, 2021

62 Kent, G. G, "Effect of mutual acquaintance on the construction of conversation" 17 (17): 197-209, 1981

63 Folkman, S, "Dynamics of a stressful encounter : Cognitive appraisal, coping, and encounter outcomes" 50 (50): 992-1003, 1986

64 Duran, N, "Dual discrimination of Syrian Refugee Women in the labour markets in Europe and Turkey : Identifying the challenges" 75 : 43-67, 2018

65 Aydemir, Y, "Difficulties faced by women asylum-seekers in Turkey: Case of Batman province" 3 (3): 11-27, 2020

66 Parker, J. D, "Coping with coping assessment: A critical review" 6 (6): 321-344, 1992

67 Etikan, I, "Comparison of snowball sampling and sequential sampling technique" 1 (1): 6-7, 2016

68 Owton, H, "Close but not too close: Friendship as method(ology) in ethnographic research encounters" 43 (43): 283-305, 2013

69 Archer, L, "Challenging barriers to employment for refugees and asylum seekers in London (Research project)"

70 Kandiyoti, D, "Bargaining with patriarchy"

71 Carver, C. S, "Assessing coping strategies : A theoretically based approach" 56 (56): 267-283, 1989

72 Datta, N, "Addressing employment obstacles for young Syrian refugee women (Jobs Notes, Issue No.12)"

73 Staruch, R. M. T, "A report on the state of bullying & harassment within plastic surgery in the United Kingdom"