일상적 대화의 도덕교육적 함의 = The Implications of Ordinary Conversation for Moral Education

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study is to investigate the implications of ordinary conversation for moral education. N. Noddings has presented for exploring a range of possible uses of conversation in moral education: the highly formal conversation of discourse ethics, the so-called "immortal conversation", and a form of ordinary conversation between adult and children. Conversation of the sort that keep concern for one`s partner paramount and still seek the better way are usually voluntary conversation between people who have some affection for one another. That may be the key and the reason that ordinary conversation of a certain kind is so valuable in moral education. When people have loving regard for one another, they can engage in constructive conflict, although it is by no means easy. To establish the relation in which people may come to have positive regard for one another, we need to engage in conversation about shared interests and everyday events. We may well learn more about the value and the strategies of such conversation by studying the different voice as it speak in sensitive interactions. Once the relation is established, when it has come unthinkable to do violence to this other with whom we disagree, we may be able to address the conflict itself. A compromise may be reached, and the force of the better argument may be acknowledged. Nevertheless, sometimes there will be no resolution. However, if they maintain their regard and remain pledged to do one another no harm, a great moral victory has been won. We can supplement ordinary conversation with healthy religious instruction, with powerful and sensitive intellectual training, with all sorts of common sense parenting techniques and we still cannot demand guarantees. Instead we must place our bets somewhere and remain in relations of care and trust with our children. We must have faith in the outcome.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 정호대, "하버마스의 보편화용론에 대한 비판적 고찰" 서강대학교 1997

2 고미숙, "인간교육을 위한 서사적 대화모형 연구" 교육문제연구소 (16) : 1-, 2002

3 김태오, "위대한 교육사상가들 Ⅵ(하버마스)" 교육과학사 2002

4 이규호, "앎과 삶" 좋은날 2001

5 이규호, "말의 힘" 제일출판사 1994

6 김종문, "도덕교육을 위한 학생활동 중심의 대화학습" 교육과학사 2003

7 김종문, "대화학습의 도덕교육" 교육과학사 1995

8 고미숙, "대화와 도덕교육" 26 : 21-46, 2001

9 양미경, "대화식 교과 지도의 원리와 실천 방안" 2 (2): 13-31, 2002

10 이을상, "담화윤리학과 그 문제들" 10 : 311-343, 1994

11 Clinchy,Blythe M, "Ways of Knowing and Ways of Being in Approaches to Moral Development" Teachers College Press 180-200, 1993

12 Surrey,Janet L, "The Self-in-relation in Women's Growth in Connection" The Guilford Press 51-66, 1991

13 Bernstein,R.J, "The New Consteelation" MIT Press 1992

14 Buber,M, "The Knowledge of Man" Harper & Row, Publishers, Inc. 1965

15 McCarthy,T, "The Critical Theory of Jűrgen Habermas" MIT Press 1978

16 박준영, "Richard Rorty의 “대화”와 “아이러니”에 대한 교육적 논의" 한국교육철학회 23 (23): 53-64, 2003

17 Rorty,R, "Philosophy and Mirror of Nature" Princeton University Press 1980

18 Oakley,J, "Morality and the Emotion" Routledge 1992

19 Habermas,J, "Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action" MIT Press 1990

20 Bubner,R, "Modern German Philosophy" Cambridge University Press 1981

21 Noddings,N, "Conversation as Moral Education" 23 (23): 107-117, 1994

22 Noddings,N, "Caring: A Feminine Approach to Ethics and Moral Education" University of California Press 1984

23 Sidorkin,A, "Beyond Discourse" State University of NewYork Press 1999

24 Buber,M, "Between Man and Man" Collins 1979