파레토 최적화와 최소최대 후회도 방법을 이용한 부정류 계산모형의 안정적인 매개변수 추정 = Robust parameter set selection of unsteady flow model using Pareto optimums and minimax regret approach

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

A robust parameter set (ROPS) selection framework for an unsteady flow model was developed by combining Pareto optimums obtained by outcomes of model calibration using multi-site observations with the minimax regret approach (MRA). The multi-site calibration problem which is a multi-objective problem was solved by using an aggregation approach which aggregates the weighted criteria related to different sites into one measure, and then performs a large number of individual optimization runs with different weight combinations to obtain Pareto solutions. Roughness parameter structure which can describe the variation of Manning’s n with discharges and sub-reaches was proposed and the related coefficients were optimized as model parameters. By applying the MRA which is a decision criterion, the Pareto solutions were ranked based on the obtained regrets related to each Pareto solution, and the top-rated one due to the lowest aggregated regrets of both calibration and validation was determined as the only ROPS. It was found that the determination of variable roughness and the corresponding standardized RMSEs at the two gauging stations varies considerably depending on the combinations of weights on the two sites. This method can provide the robust parameter set for the multi-site calibration problems in hydrologic and hydraulic models.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구에서는 부정류 계산모형의 안정적인 매개변수를 선정하기 위하여, 다수 지점의 관측치를 고려한 모형보정의 결과로부터 얻은 파레토 최적화와 최소최대 후회도 방법(minimax regret approach, MRA)을 결합하는 방법을 제안하였다. 여러 지점의 관측치를 고려한 모형의 보정은 다목적 최적화 문제로서, 통합접근법을 적용하여 최적해를 구하였다. 통합접근법은 여러 지점에 대한 가중치를 결합하여 하나의 목적함수를 얻고, 여러 번의 개별 최적화를 수행함으로써 다수의 파레토 최적해들을 구하는 방법이다. 이때 유량에 따른 조도계수의 가변성을 나타내는 두 개의 매개변수로 구성된 관계식을 이용하여 두 구간에 대한 매개변수들을 모형의 추정 대상 매개변수로서 최적화하였다. 이후 각기 다른 홍수사상에 대해 보정과 검증을 수행하였으며 각각에 대한 평가지표의 후회도를 정량화하였고 이를 결합한 결합후회도를 산정하였다. 이를 기준으로 파레토 최적해들의 순위를 결정하였다. 계산결과 추정된 모형의 가변조도계수와 그로부터 얻은 두 개 지점에서의 표준화된 RMSE들은 두 지점에 대한 가중치의 조합에 따라 선택되는 매개변수 값에 따라 달라짐을 알 수 있었다. 본 연구에서 제시한 방법은 수문 및 수리모형의 다수의 관측지점의 자료를 이용한 매개변수 산정문제에 있어서 안정적인 해를 도출할 수 있다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김한준, "가변 조도계수 부정류 계산 모형" 한국수자원학회 37 (37): 1055-1063, 2004

2 Hunter, N. M., "Utility of different data types for calibrating flood inundation models within a GLUE framework" 9 (9): 412-430, 2005

3 Hwang, E. J., "Unsteady flow model for the Main Reach of the Han River: Calibration" 30 (30): 549-559, 1997

4 Liggett, J. A., "Unsteady flow in open channels" Water Resour. Publications 89-182, 1975

5 Kim, Y., "Robust parameter estimation framework of a rainfall-runoff model using pareto optimum and minimax regret approach" 7 : 1246-1263, 2015

6 Loomes, G., "Regret theory: An alternative theory of rational choice under uncertainty" 92 (92): 805-824, 1982

7 Cunge, J. A., "Practical aspects of computational river hydraulics" Pitman 1980

8 Ramesh, R., "Optimal estimation of roughness in open-channel flows" 126 (126): 299-303, 2000

9 Chow, V. T., "Open channel hydraulics" McGraw-Hill 1959

10 Holly, F. M., "Numerical simulation of unsteady water and sediment movement in multiply connected networks of mobile-bed Channels" Iowa Inst. of Hydr. Res. 1990

11 Seibert, J., "Multiscale calibration and validation of a conceptual rainfallrunoff model" 25 (25): 59-64, 2000

12 Soon Thiam Khu, "Multiobjective calibration with Pareto preference ordering: An application to rainfall-runoff model calibration" Wiley-Blackwell 41 (41): W03004-, 2005

13 Dung, N. V., "Multi-objective automatic calibration of hydrodynamic models utilizing inundation maps and gauge data" 15 : 1339-1354, 2011

14 Loulou, R., "Minimax regret strategies for greenhouse has abatement: Methodology and application" 25 : 219-230, 1999

15 Kim, Y., "Iterative framework for robust reclaimed wastewater allocation in a changing environment using multi-criteria decision making" 29 (29): 295-311, 2015

16 Stevenson, W. J., "Introduction to management science with spreadsheets" McGraw-Hill 2007

17 Shinma, T. A., "Incorporating multi-event and multi-site data in the calibration of SWMM" 79 : 75-84, 2014

18 Khatibi, R. H., "Identification problem of open-channel friction parameter" 123 (123): 1078-1088, 1997

19 Ministry of Construction and Transportation, "Han River Master Plan Report" 2002

20 Liu, Y. B., "Floods, from Defence to Management" Taylor-Francis Group 317-326, 2005

21 Atanov, G. A., "Estimation of roughness profile in trapezoidal open channel" 125 (125): 309-312, 1999

22 Coon, W. F., "Estimation of roughness coefficients for natural stream channels with vegetated banks" U.S. Geological Survey Water-Supply 133-, 1998

23 Chung, E. S., "Development of fuzzy multicriteria approach to prioritize locations of treated wastewater use considering climate change scenarios" 146 : 505-516, 2014

24 Rouse, H., "Critical analysis of open channel resistance" 91 (91): 1-25, 1965

25 Horritt, M. S, "Calibration of a two-dimensional finite element flood flow model using satellite imagery" 36 (36): 3279-3291, 2000

26 Kim, Y., "An index-based robust decision making framework for watershed management in a changing climate" 473 : 88-102, 2014

27 Jun, K. S., "A study on unsteady flow model including weir flow simulation" 29 (29): 153-165, 1996