Entrepreneurship and an Apprentice-based Cluster: The Evolution of Houli’s Saxophone Cluster in Taiwan

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper analyses the relationship between entrepreneurship and an industrial cluster in general, by particularly examining one of Taiwan’s industrial clusters, Houli’s saxophone cluster. Our purpose is threefold. First, instead of investigating high-profile and chiefly government-directed clusters, such as science parks, we focu s on a small and medium enterprise (SME) cluster. Second, unlike most studies that usually show how clusters foster entrepreneurship, we emphasize the role of entrepreneurship in the formation of the cluster industry.We discuss how a skilled artisan turns into an entrepreneur and how an apprentice-based cluster is formed. Third, we show that what used to be the competitive advantages of Houli’s saxophone cluster a peculiar apprentice-based cluster and the supportive precision machine agglomeration in central Taiwan-turn into its weaknesses when globalization surged in the 1980s. A three-year stint in government support, attempting to revitalize Houli’s saxophone cluster by organizing a functional network and improving the technology, was unable to overturn the challenges from globalization. Although entrepreneurs learn to adapt to the changing environment, the current lackluster performance of Houli’s saxophone industry demonstrates that regardless of how much glory there was in the past, it is inevitable in a ‘‘living’’ economy that a cluster cannot avoid its own ebb and flow.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 OECD, "World Congress on Local Clusters-Proceedings" OECD 2001

2 Gartner,W.B, "Who is an entrepreneur? Is the wrong question" 12 (12): 11-32, 1988

3 Schumpeter,J, "Theory of Economic Development: An Inquiry into Profits, Capital Credit, Interest and the Business Cycle" Harvard University Press 1934

4 Hayek,F.A, "The use of knowledge in society" 35 (35): 519-530, 1945

5 Hsu, J.-Y, "The silicon valley-Hsinchu connection: Technical communities and industrial upgrading, in Clusters, Networks and Innovation" Oxford University Press 176-199, 2006

6 Sautet,F, "The role of institutions in entrepreneurship: Implications for development policy, in Mercatus Policy Series, Policy Primer No.1" Mercatus Center, George Mason University 2005

7 Minniti,M, "The role of government policy on entrepreneurial activity: Productive, unproductive, or destructive" 32 (32): 779-790, 2008

8 Hospers, G.-J., "The next silicon valley? On the relationship between geographical clustering and public policy" 5 : 285-299, 2009

9 Chung,Y.-Y, "The marketing pattern of how OEMs build up their common brand: The case of Houli’s saxophone manufactures" 2006

10 Lee, W.-H, "The cradle of Taiwan high-technology industry development - Hsinchu science park" 20 (20): 55-59, 2000

11 Buss,T.F, "The case against targeted industry strategies" 13 (13): 339-356, 1999

12 Numazaki,I, "The Laoban-led development of business enterprises in Taiwan: An analysis of the Chinese entrepreneurship" 35 (35): 440-457, 1997

13 Casson,M, "The Entrepreneur: An Economic Theory" Edward Elgar 2005

14 Tsai,P.-W, "The Development History of Houli’s Saxophone Industry" National Taiwan Normal University 2005

15 Porter,M.E, "The Competitive Advantage of Nations" The Free Press 1990

16 Weidenbaum,M, "The Chinese family business enterprise" 38 (38): 59-72, 1996

17 Archibugi, D, "Technology, Globalization and Economic Performance" Cambridge University Press 1998

18 Amsden,A.H, "Taiwan’s industrialization policy: Two views, two types of subsidy, in Taiwan’s Development Experience: Lessons on Roles of Government and Market" Kluwer Academic 1999

19 Ho,J, "Sweet music is made in Taiwan"

20 Markusen,A, "Sticky places in slippery space: A typology of industrial districts" 72 (72): 293-313, 1996

21 Parrilli, M. D, "SME Cluster Development: A Dynamic View of Survival Clusters in Developing Countries" MacMillan 2007

22 Observatory of European SMEs, "Regional Clusters in Europe, 3"

23 Grabher,G, "Rediscovering the social in the economics of interfirm relations, in Embedded Firm: On the Socioeconomics of Industrial Networks" Routledge 1993

24 ADB, "Promoting local economies through SME cluster approach" 26 February 2010

25 Marshall,A, "Principles of Economics" Macmillan 1890

26 Aldrich,H, "Organizations Evolving" Sage 1999

27 Eckhardt, J. T, "Opportunities and entrepreneurship" 29 (29): 333-349, 2003

28 Johnson,P, "New Firms: An Economic Perspective" Allen and Unwin 1986

29 Porter,M.E, "Location, competition, and economic development: Local clusters in a global economy" 14 (14): 15-34, 2000

30 OECD, "Innovative Clusters: Drivers of National Innovation Systems" OECD 2001

31 Gurerriere, P, "Industrial districts’ evolution and technological regimes: Italy and Taiwan" 24 (24): 899-914, 2004

32 Liu,S.J, "Industrial development and structural adaptation in Taiwan: Some issues of learned entrepreneurship" 45 (45): 338-348, 1998

33 Pyke, F, "Industrial Districts and Local Economic Regeneration" Institute for Labor Studies 1992

34 Boari,C, "Industrial Clusters, Focal Firms, and Economic Dynamism: A Perspective from Italy" World Bank 2001

35 Krugman,K, "Increasing returns and economic geography" 99 (99): 483-499, 1991

36 Pouder, R, "Hot spots and blind spots: Geographical clusters of firms and innovation" 21 (21): 1192-1225, 1996

37 Rodrik,D, "Growth Strategies" NBER 2003

38 Wade,R, "Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization" Princeton University Press 1990

39 World Economic Forum, "Global Competitiveness Report 2008-2009" 2008

40 Brookfield,J, "Firm clustering and specialization: A study of Taiwan’s machine tool industry" 30 (30): 405-422, 2008

41 Greenhalgh, S, "Families and networks in Taiwan’s economic development, in China, Korea and Taiwan, Vol. II" Edward Elgar 1995

42 Minniti,M, "Entrepreneurship and network externalities" 57 (57): 1-27, 2005

43 Mackie,J, "Entrepreneurship and institutions: The southeast Asian experience, in Institutions and Economic Change in Southeast Asia - The Context of Development from the 1960s to the 1990s" Edward Elgar 72-84, 1999

44 Rocha,H, "Entrepreneurship and development: The role of clusters" 23 (23): 363-400, 2004

45 Yu,T.F.-L, "Entrepreneurship and Economic Development in Hong Kong" School of Economics and Management University College, University of New South Wales, Australian Defense Force Academy Canberra 1996

46 Feldman, M, "Entrepreneurs as agents in the formation of industrial clusters, in Clusters and Regional Development Critical Reflections and Explorations" Routledge 2006

47 OECD, "Enhancing SME Competitiveness: The OECD Bologna Ministerial Conference OECD" OECD 2000

48 Feenstra, C, "Emergent Economies, Divergent Paths: Economic Organization and International Trade in South Korea and Taiwan" Cambridge University Press 2006

49 World Bank, "Electronic Conference on Clusters" World Bank 2000

50 Granovetter,M, "Economic action and social structure: The problem of embeddedness" 91 (91): 481-510, 1985

51 Ching, C.-H, "Differentiations in Taiwan’s regional industrial clusters: The impacts of China effects" 49 : 55-79, 2007

52 UNIDO, "Development of Clusters and Networks of SMEs" United Nations Industrial Development Organization 2001

53 Feldman, M., "Creating a cluster while building a firm: Entrepreneurs and the formation of industrial clusters" 39 (39): 129-141, 2005

54 Kirzner,I.M, "Competition and Entrepreneurship" University of Chicago Press 1973

55 Arthur,W.B, "Competing technologies, increasing returns, and lock-in by historical events" 99 : 116-131, 1989

56 Porter,M.E, "Clusters and the new economics of competition" 76 (76): 77-90, 1998

57 Desrochers, P, "Cluster-based economic strategy, facilitation policy and the market process" 17 (17): 233-245, 2004

58 Raines,P, "Cluster policy-does it exist? in Cluster Development and Policy, Chapter 3" Ashgate 22-33, 2002

59 Rosenfeld,A, "Bringing business clusters into the mainstream of economic development" 5 : 3-23, 1997

60 Sheih,G.-S, "Boss Island: The Subcontracting Network and Micro-Entrepreneurship in Taiwan’s Development" Peter Lang 1992

61 Boyd,R, "Black and Asian self-employment in large metropolitan areas: A comparative analysis" 37 (37): 258-274, 1990

62 Yu,T.F.-L, "An entrepreneurial perspective of institutional change" 12 (12): 217-236, 2001

63 Chou,P.-L, "A study on marketing strategy of saxophone industry in Taiwan" Shih Hsin University 2006

64 Chen,C.-Y, "A Research on the Development of the Saxophone Industry in Houli Region and K.H.S" National Taiwan Normal University 2006

65 Shane,S, "A General Theory of Entrepreneurship: The Individual-Opportunity Nexus" Edward Elgar 2003