자가 응답식 자료에 근거한 유병률 및 건강기대수명 연구의 신뢰도 분석: 건강보험 표본코호트 DB와의 비교 = Reliability of self-reported data for prevalence and health life expectancy studies: comparison with sample cohort DB of National Health Insurance Services

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Korea Health Panel (KHP) data and Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES) data are collected by self-assess and self-report for individual's health status and medical use. Previous studies have claimed that the reliability for prevalence rates and health life expectancies obtained from these data should be validated. National Health Insurance Services in Korea recently released a sample cohort DB that contain all data related to the use of medical facilities for all entire Korea citizens. It has been shown that disease-specific prevalence rates calculated from these data are representative and reliable for the entire population. In this paper, we evaluate the reliability of prevalence rates derived from self-reported data such as KHP and KNHANES by comparing to the prevalence rates from the sample cohort DB. We found that both KHP and KNHANES underestimate prevalence rates and in turn overestimate health life expectancies. Moreover, the general trends of health life expectancies might be distorted (except for the sample cohort DB) because of sampling and non-sampling errors.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김혜령, "한국 50세 이상 성인의 골관절염 유병률과 관련요인" 한국보건간호학회 27 (27): 27-39, 2013

2 이승희, "총조사 오차(Total Survey Error)의 패러다임으로 이해하는 표본조사" 통계청 15 (15): 44-74, 2010

3 박유성, "우리나라 자료에 적합한 생명표 작성방법에 대한 연구" 한국통계학회 24 (24): 769-789, 2011

4 김상아, "우리나라 당뇨병의 유병률과 관리 상태" 대한내과학회 68 (68): 10-17, 2005

5 박유성, "우리나라 공식인구의 신뢰성 및 문제점에 대한 고찰" 한국조사연구학회 11 (11): 71-95, 2010

6 허남욱, "국민건강영양조사를 이용한 한국인 관절염의 유병률 현황과 연도별 변화" 대한류마티스학회 15 (15): 11-26, 2008

7 박유성, "국민건강보험 표본코호트 DB를 이용한 건강보험 재정추계" 한국통계학회 28 (28): 663-683, 2015

8 National Health Insurance Service (NHIS), "User guide for Korea Health Panel data"

9 Laslett, L. J., "The worldwide environment of cardiovascular disease: prevalence, diagnosis, therapy, and policy issues" 60 : S1-S49, 2012

10 Crossley, T. F., "The reliability of self-assessed health status" 21 : 643-658, 2002

11 Jung, Y., "The life expectancy and health-adjusted life expectancy of Koreans" 193 : 5-18, 2012

12 Jung, Y., "The criteria and models of prioritization on health related research programs" 128 : 105-113, 2007

13 Groves, R. M., "Survey Methodology" Wiley-Interscience 2004

14 Groves, R. M., "Survey Errors and Survey Costs" John Wiley & Sons 1989

15 Park, I., "Study on Health Insurance Financial Outlook"

16 Kalton, G., "Panel Surveys" Wiley-Interscience, Wiley 249-270, 1989

17 Bailar, B. A., "Panel Surveys" Wiley-Interscience 1-24, 1989

18 US Department of Health and Human Services, "National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey: sample design, 2011–2014"

19 S¨arndal, C., "Model Assisted Survey Sampling" Springer 2003

20 Centers for Disease Control & Prevention, "Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey raw data user guide"

21 Jagger, C., "International Handbook of Adult Mortality" Springer 551-568, 2011

22 Shenker, N., "Improving on analyses of self-reported data in a large-scale health survey by using information from an examination-based survey" 29 : 533-545, 2010

23 Korean Society of Hypertension, "Hypertension treatment guidelines"

24 Mathers, C. D., "Healthy life expectancy in 191 countries, 1999" 357 : 1685-1691, 2001

25 Salomon, J. A., "Healthy life expectancy for 187 countries, 1990–2010 : a systematic analysis for the Global Burden Disease Study 2010" 380 : 2144-2162, 2013

26 Lee, T. W., "Health promotion behaviors and quality of life among communitydwelling elderly in Korea : a cross-sectional survey" 43 : 293-300, 2006

27 Davis, B. A., "Estimating cohort health expectancies from crosssectional surveys of disability" 20 : 1097-1111, 2001

28 Cambois, E., "Did the prevalence of disability in France really fall in the 1990s? A discussion of questions asked in the French health survey" 62 : 315-337, 2007

29 Buratta, V., "Determining Health Expectancies" John Wiley & Sons 187-202, 2003

30 Lee, J., "Construction of an appropriate sampling design and a sample database using the National Health Information Database"

31 Lee, J., "Cohort Profile: the National Health Insurance Service-National Sample Cohort (NHIS-NSC), South Korea" 2016

32 Sullivan, D. F., "A single index of mortality and morbidity" 86 : 347-354, 1971

33 Rogers, A., "A multistate analysis of active life expectancy" 104 : 222-226, 1989

34 Park, Y. S., "A balanced multi-level rotation sampling design and its efficient composite estimators" 137 : 594-610, 2007

35 Newman, S. C., "A Markov process interpretation of Sullivan’s index of morbidity and mortality" 7 : 787-794, 1988