Applying BIM to support dispute avoidance in managing multi-owned buildings

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

With the growth of high-density living, disputes experienced by residents in multi-owned buildings (MOBs) have become an ongoing challenge in urban areas. A significant number of the disputations have found their root cause in the issues concerning improper use and management of MOBs by residents. It stems from their inaccurate understanding of ownership rights that are inherently 3D but using 2D cadastral survey plans, authoritative documents of ownership. This research explores the ability of building information modeling (BIM) to address required information for improving the perception of ownership rights that affect resident behaviors in managing MOBs. An open data model of BIM is extended to accommodate the necessary information for preventing resident misbehaviors that led to dispute cases in Victoria state, Australia. In this study, we implement BIM data of an MOB where a real dispute happened to demonstrate the validity of the enriched data model on the information delivery and an enhanced understanding of ownership rights. It is confirmed that the use of BIM facilitates the alleviation of the misbehaviors by informing residents with accurate communication of ownership rights and could support the avoidance of disputes in MOBs.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Oldfield, J., "Working with open BIM standards to source legal spaces for a 3D cadastre" 6 (6): 351-, 2017

2 Leshinsky, R., "What are they fighting about? Research into disputes in Victorian owners corporations" 23 (23): 112-119, 2012

3 Shojaei, D., "Visualization requirements for 3D cadastral systems" 41 : 39-54, 2013

4 Easthope, H., "Urban Regeneration in Australia" Routledge 112-126, 2018

5 Ho, S., "Towards 3D-enabled urban land administration : Invisible constraints and strategic choices" The University of Melbourne 2014

6 Zhu, Y., "Toward community engagement: Can the built environment help? Grassroots participation and communal space in Chinese urban communities" 46 : 44-53, 2015

7 Stoter, J. E., "The phased 3D cadastre implementation in the Netherlands" 2012

8 NBIMS, "The national BIM standard – United States version 3"

9 Lemmen, C. H. J., "The modelling of spatial units (parcels) in the Land Administration Domain Model (LADM)" 2010

10 Sherry, C., "The New South Wales strata and community titles acts: A case study of legislatively created high rise and master planned communities" 1 (1): 130-142, 2009

11 Clemen, C., "The Industry Foundation ¨Classes (IFC) – Ready for indoor cadastre?" 1-9, 2006

12 Government of Victoria, "Subdivision Act 1988"

13 Dredge, D., "Strata title : Towards a research agenda for informed planning practice" 26 (26): 417-433, 2011

14 Isikdag, U., "Semantically rich 3D building and cadastral models for valuation" 2014

15 Amole, D., "Residential satisfaction in students’ housing" 29 (29): 76-85, 2009

16 Marcin, K., "Registration of untypical 3D objects in Polish cadastre – Do we need 3D cadastre?" 61 (61): 75-89, 2012

17 Goodman, R., "Privatised communities : The use of owners corporations in master planned estates in Melbourne" 39 (39): 521-536, 2008

18 Leshinsky, R., "Owners corporations in Victoria: A manual for owners, occupiers and managers" Hybrid Publishers 2008

19 Johnston, N., "Multi-owned properties in Australia : A governance typology of issues and outcomes" 8 (8): 451-470, 2015

20 Blandy, S., "Multi-owned housing:Law, power and practice" Ashgate Publishing, Ltd 2010

21 Dupuis, A., "Multi-owned housing: Law, power and practice" Ashgate 197-206, 2010

22 Yip, N. M., "Multi-owned housing" Routledge 131-146, 2016

23 Johnston, N., "Multi-owned developments : A life cycle review of a developing research area" 31 (31): 366-388, 2013

24 Atazadeh, B., "Modelling building ownership boundaries within BIM environment: A case study in Victoria, Australia" 61 : 24-38, 2017

25 Easthope, H., "Living well in greater density" Shelter NSW 2010

26 Cradduck, L., "Living a managed community lifestyle : Managed community lifestyle from Queensland" 31 (31): 326-334, 2013

27 Christensen, S., "Links between physical and legal structures of community title schemes and disputes" 14 : 90-111, 2006

28 El-Mekawy, M., "Integration of 3D cadastre, 3D property formation and BIM in Sweden" 17-34, 2014

29 Dimopoulou, E., "Initial registration of 3D parcels. In Best Practices 3D Cadastres"

30 "ISO16739. Industry Foundation Classes (IFC) for data sharing in the construction and facility management industries"

31 Easthope, H., "How property title impacts urban consolidation : A life cycle examination of multi-title developments" 23 (23): 289-304, 2014

32 Easthope, H., "Governing the compact city: The challenges of apartment living in Sydney, Australia" 24 (24): 243-259, 2009

33 Easthope, H., "Governing the Compact City: The role and effectiveness of strata management" City Futures Research Centre 2012

34 Atazadeh, B., "Extending a BIM-based data model to support 3D digital management of complex ownership spaces" 31 (31): 499-522, 2017

35 Gao, W., "Explaining the outcomes of multi-owned housing management : A collective action perspective" 57 : 233-241, 2016

36 Douglas, K., "Ethical concerns for owners corporation managers who informally mediate in owners corporation disputes: The need for a community of practice" 35 (35): 118-138, 2017

37 Douglas, K., "Conflict in strata title developments: The need for differentiated dispute resolution rules" 37 (37): 163-189, 2016

38 Christudason, A., "Common property in strata titled developments in Singapore: Common misconceptions" 22 (22): 14-28, 2004

39 Gao, W., "Collective actions for the management of multiowned residential building: A case of Hong Kong" 49 : 316-324, 2015

40 Ho, D., "Collective action in apartment building management in Hong Kong" 38 : 10-17, 2013

41 C¸agdas, V., "Co-ownership shares in condominiums – A comparison across jurisdictions and standards: Long version" 2018

42 Paasch, J. M., "Building a modern cadastre : Legal issues in describing real property in 3D" 60 (60): 256-268, 2016

43 Land Use Victoria., "Building Subdivision Guidelines"

44 Eastman, C., "BIM handbook: A guide to building information modeling for owners, managers, designers, engineers and contractors" John Wiley & Sons 2011

45 Becerik-Gerber, B., "Application areas and data requirements for BIM-enabled facilities management" 138 (138): 431-442, 2011

46 Barton, J., "A note on Cadastre: UrbanIT Research Project"

47 Rajabifard, A., "3D-cadastre, a multifaceted challenge" 2014

48 Janecka, K., "3D data management—Overview report" 18-20, 2016