대학생 토론 담화의 반박 전략 분석 = Analysis on Refutation Strategies Embedded in College Students` Debate Discourse

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study analyzed various uses of refutation strategies that college students presented in their debate discourse. This study first found out a firm relations between the background knowledge on the topic for debate and the uses of refutation strategies. Second, students frequently evaded and strayed from the point of debate due to the burden of refutation. Third, students had a tendency to proceed their refutation based on the prepared materials, instead of attacking the opposite team`s weak points directly. College students had various difficulties in handling two heavy loading works together, such as analyzing the opposite team`s weak points and developing their refutation strategies instantly. Preparation of data and materials is important; however, it is more critical for students to use their materials effectively, not to heavily relying on, for deepening examination of the topic and for making a productive debate. The aim of debate is to deepen the understanding of the topic of debate and to explore the ways to solving problems that the community members confront by the affirmative and opposite teams` argument and refutation. The findings of the study confirmed the importance of the deep understandings and examinations of debate topic in contents of debate education.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이두원, "한국 대학생의 디베이트 스타일에 대한 내용 분석 : CEDA 포맷을 중심으로" 한국커뮤니케이션학회 16 (16): 79-100, 2008

2 육영주, "토론에서 상대의 주장에 대한 반박 전략" 한국언어문화학회 (40) : 207-232, 2009

3 박용한, "토론대화 전략 연구" 역락 2003

4 박승억, "토론과 논증" 형성출판사 2005

5 한상철, "토론; 비판적 사고를 활용한 토론 분석과 응용" 커뮤니케이션북스 2006

6 박재현, "정책 토론의 입론 구성 교육 내용 연구" 우리말글학회 60 : 93-121, 2014

7 Meany, J, "모든 학문과 정치의 시작 토론: 의회식 토론법으로 배우는 토론의 이해와 실제" 커뮤니케이션 북스 2008

8 Toulmin, S. E., "논변의 사용" 고려대학교출판부 2006