Assessment of collapse safety margin for DDBD and FBD-designed RC frame buildings

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper investigates the seismic performance of buildings designed using DDBD (Direct Displacement based Design) and FBD (Force based Design) approaches from the probabilistic viewpoint. It aims to estimate the collapse capacity of structures and assess the adequacy of seismic design codes. In this regard, (i) IDA (Incremental Dynamic Analysis) curves, (ii) interstory drift demand distribution curves, (iii) fragility curves, and (iv) the methodology provided by FEMA P-695 are applied to examine two groups of RC moment resistant frame buildings: 8-story structures with different plans, to study the effect of different span arrangements; and 3-, 7- and 12-story structures with a fixed plan, to study the dynamic behavior of the buildings.
Structural modeling is performed in OpenSees software and validated using the results of an experimental model. It is concluded that increasing the building height would not significantly affect the response estimation of IDA and fragility curves of DDBDdesigned structures, while the change in span arrangements is effective in estimating responses. In the investigation of the code adequacy, unlike the FBD approach, the DDBD can satisfy the performance criteria presented in FEMA P-695 and hence provide excellent performance.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Mander, J. B., "Theoretical stress-strain model for confined concrete" 114 (114): 1804-1826, 1988

2 Shibata, A., "Substitute-structure method for seismic design in R/C" 102 (102): 1-18, 1976

3 Bracci, J. M., "Seismic resistance of reinforced concrete structures designed only for gravity loads: part I-design and properties of a one-third scale model structure" University at Buffalo, the State University of New York 1992

4 Bracci, J. M., "Seismic resistance of reinforced concrete frame structures designed for gravity loads : performance of structural system" 92 (92): 597-609, 1995

5 Khorami, M., "Seismic performance evaluation of buckling restrained braced frames(BRBF)using incremental nonlinear dynamic analysis method(IDA)" 13 (13): 531-538, 2017

6 Wu, Y. T., "Seismic collapse safety of high-rise RC moment frames supported on two ground levels" 14 (14): 349-360, 2018

7 Alimohammadi, D., "Reliability-based probabilistic safety evaluation of seismic design approaches for RC-MR buildings" 7 (7): 04021017-, 2021

8 Mashhadiali, N., "Quantification of the seismic performance factors of steel hexagrid structures" 157 : 82-92, 2019

9 Arzeytoon, A., "Probabilistic seismic performance assessment of ribbed bracing systems" 148 : 326-335, 2018

10 Jalali, S. A., "Probabilistic seismic demand assessment of steel moment frames with side-plate connections" 19 (19): 27-40, 2011

11 Alimohammadi, D., "Probabilistic performance appraisal of seismic structural design methodologies : A case study for RC/MRF systems" 22 (22): 89-100, 2020

12 Onkar G. Kumbhar ; Ratnesh Kumar, "Performance assessment of RC frame designed using force, displacement & energy based approach" 국제구조공학회 73 (73): 699-714, 2020

13 McKenna, F., "OpenSees: Open System for Earthquake Engineering Simulation" Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center, University of California 2016

14 Choi, K. S., "Numerical investigation on design requirements for steel ordinary braced frames" 137 : 296-309, 2017

15 "Iranian Standard 2800, Iranian Code of Practice for Seismic Resistant Design of Buildings"

16 Dariush Alimohammadi ; Esmaeel Izadi Zaman Abadi, "Investigating the effects of span arrangements on DDBD-designed RC buildings under the skew seismic attack" 국제구조공학회 77 (77): 115-135, 2021

17 Basone, F., "Incremental dynamic based fragility assessment of reinforced concrete structures : Stationary vs. non-stationary artificial ground motions" 103 : 105-117, 2017

18 Vamvatsikos, D., "Incremental dynamic analysis" 31 (31): 491-514, 2002

19 Masoud Mirtaheri ; Mehrshad Amini ; Hossein Khorshidi, "Incremental dynamic analyses of concrete buildings reinforced with shape memory alloy" 국제구조공학회 23 (23): 95-105, 2017

20 Priestley, M. J. N., "Fundamentals of direct displacement-based seismic design and assessment" 494 : 133-154, 2007

21 Mokhtar Ansari ; Amir Safiey ; Mehdi Abbasi, "Fragility based performance evaluation of mid rise reinforced concrete frames in near field and far field earthquakes" 국제구조공학회 76 (76): 751-763, 2020

22 "FEMA P-695 (2009), Quantification of Building Seismic Performance Factors"

23 "FEMA 450 (2003), NEHRP Recommended Provisions for Seismic Regulations for New Buildings and other structures"

24 "FEMA 350 (2000), Recommended Seismic Design Criteria for New Steel Moment-Frame Buildings"

25 Majid Khorami ; Masoud Khorami ; Hedayatollah Motahar ; Mohammadfarid Alvansazyazdi ; Mahdi Shariati ; Abdolrahim Jalali ; M.M. Tahir, "Evaluation of the seismic performance of special moment frames using incremental nonlinear dynamic analysis" 국제구조공학회 63 (63): 259-268, 2017

26 Mahdi Shariati ; Majid Lagzian ; Shervin Maleki ; Ali Shariati ; Nguyen Thoi Trung, "Evaluation of seismic performance factors for tension-only braced frames" 국제구조공학회 35 (35): 599-609, 2020

27 Alimohammadi, D., "Evaluation of seismic design approach on RC/MR building using different probabilistic methods" 2019

28 Fox, M. J., "Evaluation of seismic assessment procedures for determining deformation demands in RC wall buildings" 9 (9): 911-936, 2015

29 Pettinga, J. D., "Dynamic behaviour of reinforced concrete frames designed with direct displacement-based design" 9 : 309-330, 2005

30 Powell, G. H., "Displacement-based seismic design of structures" 24 (24): 555-557, 2008

31 Chu Peng ; Serhan Guner, "Direct displacement-based seismic assessment of concrete frames" 사단법인 한국계산역학회 21 (21): 355-365, 2018

32 Salawdeh, S., "Direct displacement based seismic design for single storey steel concentrically braced frames" 10 (10): 1125-1141, 2016

33 Khatami, A., "Collapse assessment and seismic performance factors in tall tube-in-tube diagrid buildings" 19 (19): 197-214, 2020

34 Fiorino, L., "Behaviour factor(q)evaluation the CFS braced structures according to FEMA P695" 138 : 324-339, 2017

35 Vamvatsikos, D., "Application of incremental dynamic analysis to an RC-structure" 2003

36 Kheyroddin, A., "An experimental study on the influence of incorporating lap or forging(GPW)splices on the cyclic performance of RC columns" 241 : 1-12, 2021

37 Pettinga, J. D., "Accounting for P-Delta effects in structures when using direct displacement-based design" 2008

38 "ACI 318, Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete(ACI 318-05)and Commentary(ACI 318R-05)"

39 Sullivan, T. J., "A Model Code for the Displacement-Based Seismic Design of Structures: DBD12" Iuss Press 2012

40 Calvi, G. M., "A Model Code for the Displacement-Based Seismic Design of Structures: DBD09 Draft subject to Public Enquiry" Iuss Press 2009