4차 산업혁명 시대의 공유경제 생태계 정책 제안: 우버(Uber) 사례를 중심으로 = A Study on the Sharing Economy Ecosystem in the 4th Industrial Revolution: Focused on Uber

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The aim of this conceptual article is to explore the sharing economy ecosystem concept in innovation policy context with cluster, innovation system, smart specialization and business ecosystem approaches. This study conducts comparative study to understand what has been changed by sharing economy through Uber case in four cities. By analyzing vital constructs in sharing economy ecosystem, we suggest how sharing economy ecosystem works, and presenting core factors in policy framework of sharing economy ecosystem. In addition, we attempt to explain that policy maker should consider the relationship between these factors. The result of this paper shows sharing economy ecosystem has developed with their characteristics and constructs that are different with traditional industry.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 한진주, "한발 물러선 우버…’우버 엑스 중단, 서울시 권고 수용" 아시아경제

2 백승렬, "한국판 에어비앤비·우버 키운다…공유경제 등 투자 50조원 유발" 연합뉴스

3 한영일, "출퇴근 시간 선택제’ 카풀 앱 고발한 정부·지자체…”규제 완화” 외치더니 혁신 어깃장만 놓나" 서울경제

4 민상식, "차량공유서비스 ‘우버(Uber) 코리아’ 경찰 수사" 헤럴드경제

5 정동일, "지식생태계의 조직화: 플랫폼 리더의 조직역량이 지식창출을 위한 기업간 협력의 확장에 미치는 영향" 한국지식경영학회 16 (16): 1-27, 2015

6 박치성, "정부정책에 대한 이해관계자 정책 프레임 비교연구: 금연정책을 중심으로" 한국행정연구원 26 (26): 1-36, 2017

7 김성수, "우버·에어비앤비 거품?...’공유경제’ 세 가지 위험" 뉴스핌

8 박희진, "우버, 카풀로 한국시장 다시 노크…차선책 ‘우버쉐어’ 통할까" 한국경제

9 김은정, "우버, 장애인과 노약자 안전하게 모시는 우버어시스트 출시" 함께걸음

10 함영훈, "우버, 관광공사 행사 등장, 융복합시대 한 수 귀띔" 헤럴드경제

11 백봉삼, "우버 신고 포상제 내달 2일부터…포상금은" ZDNet Korea

12 김영수, "우리나라 클러스터정책의 특징과 지역산업생태계론으로의 진화 필요성" 한국지역학회 28 (28): 23-43, 2012

13 이동인, "실리콘밸리서 인기끄는 앱 ‘우버’…한 국 에도 고급 리무 진 달 린다" 매일경제

14 정진화, "신기술 융합화에 따른 산업패러다임 변화와 우리의 대응" 산업연구원 28-61, 2004

15 김범금, "스타트업 육성한다더니… ‘그림자 규제’로 발목잡는 서울시" 이투데이

16 구철모, "스마트 관광 생태계의 이론화와 활용" 한국경영정보학회 16 (16): 69-87, 2014

17 백서인, "세계 주요국의 자율주행차 정책 및 기업전략에 관한 통합적 연구" 한국지식경영학회 18 (18): 1-36, 2017

18 전효재, "비즈니스 생태계 관점에서 관광산업 건강성에 관한 연구" 한국관광학회 41 (41): 129-140, 2017

19 국토교통부, "불법택시 ‘우버’ 당국 ‘금시초문’ 보도내용은 사실과 다름" 정책브리핑

20 장석권, "글로벌 미디어 생태계의 태동과 한국의 전략적 포지셔닝" 에스케이텔레콤 (주) 20 (20): 56-70, 2010

21 김동규, "국토부, “우버는 불법 영업” 단속 방침 재확인" 허프포스트

22 공유허브, "공유허브란"

23 구희언, "공유도시 서울’ 어디까지 왔나" 주간동아

24 이경민, "공유경제에서 프라이버시 정책을 통한 신뢰형성 및 신뢰 전이에 대한 연구: Airbnb 사용자의 문화적 배경의 조절 효과" 한국서비스경영학회 18 (18): 315-340, 2017

25 김해중, "공유경제 서비스의 성공요인에 관한 실증 연구" 한국콘텐츠학회 16 (16): 214-229, 2016

26 심수진, "공유경제 서비스 사용의 영향요인에 대한 실증 연구" 한국인터넷전자상거래학회 16 (16): 163-183, 2016

27 손상영, "공유경제 비즈니스 모델과 새로운 경제 규범" 정보통신연구원 2015

28 부형원, "공유경제 ‘우버’ 도입후 택시일자리 되레 늘었다" 동아일보

29 김점산, "공유경제 (Sharing Economy) 의 미래와 성공조건" 134 : 1-25, 2014

30 Batheja, A, "With New Rules, Will Uber, Lyft Stay in Austin" The Texas Tribune

31 Len, S, "Why can’t Uber make money" Forbes

32 Armstrong, E.G, "Using an outcomes-logic-model approach to evaluate a faculty development program for medical educators" 81 (81): 483-488, 2006

33 Solomon, D, "Uber’s Petition to the Texas Legislature Has Nearly 100,000 Signatures" TexasMonthly

34 Topham, G, "Uber’s London licence renewed for only four months" The Guardian

35 Buchanan, M, "Uber’s Free Ride" The New Yorker

36 Siegler, M. G, "UberCap Cease & Desist Means One Thing: They’re Onto Something" TechCrunch

37 Samuels, A, "Uber, Lyft returning to Austin on Monday" The Texas Tribune

38 Topham, G, "Uber wins high court case over taxi app" The Guardian

39 Samuels, A, "Uber wants to return to Austin, spokesman says" The Texas Tribune

40 Chen, B. X, "Uber to Roll Out Ride Sharing in California" The New York Times

41 Davies, R, "Uber takes TfL to high court over English written test" The Guardian

42 Butler, S, "Uber stripped of London licence due to lack of corporate responsibility" The Guardian

43 McCormick, R, "Uber settles lawsuits to keep drivers as independent contractors in California and Massachusetts" The Verge

44 Paul, M. V, "Uber returns to Spanish streets in search of regulatory U-turn" Reuters

45 Davies, R, "Uber loses court case to block English-language written test in London" The Guardian

46 Ayala-Talavera, M, "Uber launches in Austin despite official ban" Kxan

47 Topham, G, "Uber launches appeal against loss of London licence" The Guardian

48 Hellier, D, "Uber hails victory after Transport for London drops restrictions" The Guardian

49 O’Connor, S, "Uber drivers win UK legal battle for workers’ rights" Financial Times

50 Booth, R, "Uber drivers threaten rebellion against the $40bn company" The Guardian

51 Tepper, F, "Uber and Lyft shut down in Austin After voters defeat Proposition 1" TechCrunch

52 Sisson, P, "Uber and Lyft return to Austin : What’s changed, and why it’s important" Curbed

53 Artyom, D, "Uber Revenue and Usage Statistics 2017" Business of Apps

54 Franceschi-Bicchierai, L, "Uber Protests Spark Chaos and Traffic Jams From London to Madrid" Mashable

55 Ogurchak, A, "Uber IP: A primer on the patents, trademarks and copyrights owned by Uber" IPWatchdog

56 Gidda, M, "Uber Gets Green Light in London After Massive Protests" Time

57 Graham, D, "Uber And Lyft And The Debate Over Fingerprints In Austin" TechCrunch

58 Rif kin, J, "The zero marginal cost society : The internet of things, the collaborative commons, and the eclipse of capitalism" St. Martin’s Press 2014

59 Smits, R, "The rise of systemic instruments in innovation policy" 1 (1): 4-32, 2004

60 Botsman, R, "The rise of collaborative consumption" Harper Collins 2010

61 Moore, J.F, "The r ise of a new corporate form" 21 (21): 167-181, 1998

62 Gutiérrez, J, "The eruption of Airbnb in tourist cities: Comparing spatial patterns of hotels and peer-to-peer accommodation in Barcelona" 62 : 278-291, 2017

63 Rinkinen, S, "The business ecosystem concept in innovation policy context: building a conceptual framework" 1-17, 2017

64 Evans, D.S, "The antitrust economics of multi-sided platform markets" 20 : 325-, 2003

65 Nicholson, E, "The City Wants Uber, the On-Demand Private Driver App, to Get a Taxi Permit or Shut Down" Dallas Observer

66 Kawate, I, "Technologies like Uber, Grab creating new economic divide" Nikkei

67 Lyne, N, "Taxi drivers strike in Spanish cities over rise of Uber and Cabify" El Pais

68 Hedgecoe, G, "Spanish taxi drivers strike in effort to stem Uber tide" The Irish Times

69 Giles, C, "Spanish taxi drivers force ban on ‘unfair’ Uber,” Independent"

70 Miller, C.A, "Socio-energy systems design: a policy framework for energy transitions" 6 : 29-40, 2015

71 Knight, H, "S.F., L.A. threaten Uber, Lyft, Sidecar with legal action" SFGate

72 Geron, T, "Ride-Sharing Startups Get California Cease-And-Desist Letters" Forbes

73 Lessig, L, "Remix: Makingart and commerce thrive in the hybrid economy" Penguin 2008

74 Cooke, P, "Regional innovation systems: Institutional and organisational dimensions" 26 (26): 475-491, 1997

75 Fischer, F, "Reframing public policy: Discursive politics and deliberative practices" Oxford University Press 2003

76 Moore, J.F, "Predators and prey: a new ecology of competition" 71 (71): 75-83, 1993

77 Lavie, D, "Organizational differences, relational mechanisms, and alliance performance" 33 (33): 1453-1479, 2012

78 Lawler, R, "On-Demand Car Service Uber Launches In Dallas And Strikes A Partnership Deal With Virgin America" TechCrunch

79 Worstall, T, "Now Uber’s In Trouble, They’ve Got The London Black Cabs After Them" Forbes

80 Pocock, N.S, "Medical tourism and policy implications for health systems: a conceptual framework from a comparative study of Thailand, Singapore and Malaysia" 7 (7): 12-, 2011

81 Tallantyre, S, "Madrid taxi drivers strike to protest Uber app" The Local

82 Solomon, D, "Lyft And Uber Continue to Battle With The City of Aust in" TexasMonthly

83 Woods, B, "Lower-cost UberX taxi service comes to London with professional drivers, not ride-sharing" The Next Web

84 Trenholm, R, "London streets blockaded as taxi drivers protest against Uber" Cnet

85 Porter, M.E, "Location, competition, and economic development: Local clusters in a global economy" 14 (14): 15-34, 2000

86 Fisher, D, "Judge Rejects Uber Settlement, Saying It Lowballs California Labor Claims" Forbes

87 McDonald, F, "Is there evidence to support Porter-type cluster policies" 41 (41): 39-49, 2007

88 Kosoff, M, "In An Effort To Boot Uber From Spain, Madrid Will Fine Drivers Up To $22,000" Business Insider

89 권애라, "IT 비즈니스 발전에 따른 공유경제 성장전망 및 시사점" KDB 산업은행 2013

90 Foray, D, "Guide to research and innovation strategies for smart specialisation (RIS 3)" EU 2012

91 Cooke, P, "From technopoles to regional innovation systems: the evolution of loca lised tech nolog y development policy" 24 (24): 21-40, 2001

92 Irving, W, "From Mass Production to Mass Individualism" 2014

93 Lejano, R. P, "Frameworks for policy analysis: Merging text and context" Routledge 2006

94 Schon, D. A, "Frame reflection: Toward the resolution of intractrable policy controversies" Basic Books 1995

95 Chiquillo, J, "For t Wor th mayor calls deregulation of Uber and Lyft ‘the right way.’ Is it" Dallas News

96 Uotila, T, "Finnish mosaic of regional innovation system—assessment of thematic regional innovation platforms based on related variety" 20 (20): 1583-1602, 2012

97 Wessner, C.W, "Entrepreneurship and the innovation ecosystem policy lessons from the United States" 2004

98 Mason, C, "Entrepreneurial ecosystems and growth oriented entrepreneurship" 30 (30): 77-102, 2014

99 인현우, "EU 최고법원 ‘우버는 운송기업… 택시회사처럼 규제해야" 한국일보

100 Lach, S, "Do R&D subsidies stimulate or displace private R&D? Evidence from Israel" 50 (50): 369-390, 2002

101 Martin, R, "Deconstructing clusters: chaotic concept or policy panacea" 3 (3): 5-35, 2003

102 Benning, T, "Dallas adopts rules governing Uber and other car-for-hire apps" Dallas News

103 Nicholson, E, "Dallas Wants to Rewrite its Taxi Rules to Outlaw Uber, the App-Based Private Driver Service" Dallas Observer

104 Asheim, B.T, "Constructing regional advantage: Platform policies based on related variety and differentiated knowledge bases" 45 (45): 893-904, 2011

105 Lien, T, "California taxis sue Uber, allege false advertising, unfair competition" Los Angeles Times

106 Gillespie, P, "California prosecutors sue Uber for misleading customers" CNN Money

107 Isaac, M, "California Says Uber Driver Is Employee, Not a Contractor" The New York Times

108 Thomas, O, "California Regulators Are Fining Uber, Lyft, And SideCar" Business Insider

109 Ha, A, "California Regulator Passes First Ridesharing Rules, A Big Win For Lyft, SideCar, And Uber" TechCrunch

110 Dillon, L, "Bill would let Uber, Lyft drivers get a single California business license rather than multiple local ones"

111 Mekelburg, M, "Austin’s Proposition 1 Defeated" The Texas Tribune

112 Oskam, J, "Airbnb: the future of networked hospitality businesses" 2 (2): 22-42, 2016

113 Guttentag, D, "Airbnb: disruptive innovation and the rise of an informal tourism accommodation sector" 18 (18): 1192-1217, 2015

114 Lafferty, C.K, "A framework for evaluating comprehensive community initiatives" 4 (4): 31-44, 2003

115 Craig, S, "84 Amazing Uber Statistics, Demographics and Facts" DMR Business Statistics / Fun Gadgets

116 박현철, "4번의 ‘콜’과 1만8000원의 수입…우버가 가져간 것은" 한겨례