Occupational Prestige in South Korea: Stability and Variations

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study examined stability and variations in occupational prestige in South Korea. We investigated both the differentiation and incorporation processes of occupational prestige evaluation using the Korean Social Stratification Survey 2022 and obtained several findings. First, prestige rank correlations for the 15 common occupations obtained from five surveys conducted between 1990 and 2021 were extremely high, showing strong stability in occupational prestige ranks. Second, prestige score rating differed by individuals’ socioeconomic status (SES) and social network. High-SES people tend to rate occupational prestige higher than low-SES individuals but this differential disappeared after controlling for other factors, and people evaluated an occupation more highly if they knew a person in that occupation personally. Third, the effects of SES and social network on prestige score evaluation depended on occupational prestige ranks. While the difference in prestige ratings between college graduates and non-college graduates was greater for high-ranked occupations than low-ranked ones, the positive effect of having a friend in an occupation on prestige rating was greater for low-ranked occupations than high-ranked ones, suggesting that social network had a buffering effect on occupational prestige evaluation.
This study showed that occupational prestige in South Korea was characterized by both between-group variations and temporal stability.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 한신갑, "혼합식 조사와 웹패널의 (옅은) 빛과 (짙은) 그늘" 한국조사연구학회 13 (13): 1-31, 2012

2 계봉오 ; 황선재, "한국의 직업위세 평가의 변화: 1990-2016" 통계청 22 (22): 121-140, 2017

3 유홍준 ; 김월화, "한국 직업지위 지수: 과거와 현재" 한국사회학회 40 (40): 153-186, 2006

4 심경섭 ; 설동훈, "대학생의 사회적 자본과 문화적 자본이 직업 포부에 미치는 효과 분석" 한국인구학회 33 (33): 33-59, 2010

5 Hout, Michael, "What We Have Learned : RC28’s Contributions to Knowledge about Social Stratification" 24 (24): 1-20, 2006

6 Nakao, Keiko, "Updating Occupational Prestige and Socioeconomic Scores : How the New Measures Measure up" 24 : 1-72, 1994

7 Hong, Doo-Seung, "Traditions and Changes in Korean Society" Panmunsa 141-170, 1983

8 Zhou, Xueguang, "The Institutional Logic of Occupational Prestige Ranking : Reconceptualization and Reanalyses" 111 (111): 90-140, 2005

9 Valentino, Lauren., "The Heterarchy of Occupational Status : Evidence for Diverse Logics of Prestige in the United States" 36 (36): 1395-1418, 2021

10 Goyder, John, "The Dynamics of Occupational Prestige : 1975-2000" 42 (42): 1-23, 2005

11 Blau, Peter M., "The American Occupational Structure" John Wiley & Sons 1967

12 Groves, Robert M., "Survey Methodology" John Wiley & Sons 2009

13 Hauser, Robert M., "Socioeconomic Indexes for Occupations : A Review, Update, and Critique" 27 (27): 177-298, 1997

14 Kim, Harris Hyun-Soo, "Social Capital and Job Search Assistance : A Multilevel Analysis of East Asian Countries" 35 (35): 45-69, 2020

15 Seol, Dong-Hoon, "Setting Up a Probability-Based Online Panel of the General Population in South Korea: The Social Research Panel" 2022 : 2022

16 Balkwell, James W., "On the Intersubjectivity of Occupational Status Evaluations: A Test of a Key Assumption Underlying the “Wisconsin Model” of Status Attainment" 58 (58): 865-881, 1980

17 Kraus, Vered, "Occupational Prestige in the Collective Conscience" 56 (56): 900-918, 1978

18 Lin, Nan, "Occupational Prestige in Urban China" 93 (93): 793-832, 1988

19 Treiman, Donald J, "Occupational Prestige in Comparative Perspective" Academic Press 1977

20 Duncan, Otis D, "Occupation and Social Status" The Free Press 139-161, 1961

21 Duncan, Otis D, "Occupation and Social Status" The Free Press 109-138, 1961

22 Biemer, Paul P, "Introduction to Survey Quality" John Wiley & Sons 2003

23 Ganzeboom, Harry B. G., "Internationally Comparable Measures of Occupational Status for the 1988 International Standard Classification of Occupations" 25 (25): 201-239, 1996

24 Weber, Max, "From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology" Oxford University Press 180-195, 1946

25 Kim, Harris Hyun-Soo, "Exploring the Downside of Social Embeddedness : Evidence from a Cross-National Study" 97 (97): 232-251, 2016

26 Guppy, Neil, "Consensus on Occupational Prestige : A Reassessment of the Evidence" 62 (62): 709-725, 1984

27 Lin, Nan, "Access to Occupations through Social Ties" 8 (8): 365-385, 1986

28 Lynn, Freda B., "A Position with a View : Educational Status and the Construction of the Occupational Hierarchy" 82 (82): 32-58, 2017