Developing a Performance-Based Budgeting Maturity Model and Constructing a DEA-Based Composite Indicator to Measure It’s Score

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Performance-based budgeting has been a controversial topic over the past decades among budget professionals. Since the 1990s, a new wave of eagerness on performance-based budgeting has emerged among governments. In recent years, although utilization of performance-based budgeting has begun and various organizations have claimed the establishment of this system, its progress is not satisfactory. To evaluate the progress in establishing a performance based budgeting system, two budgeting maturity models have been presented. However, these two models cannot fully report the maturity of a performance-based budgeting system. By reviewing maturity reference models as well as two performance-based budgeting maturity models presented in budgeting literature, it has been attempted to highlight weaknesses of the recent models in order to present the developed performance-based budgeting maturity model. In addition to emphasizing the existence of necessary subsystems in a performance-based budgeting system, the model also emphasizes the results of this system. After developing a conceptual performance-based budgeting maturity model, it is now essential to develop an instrument for measuring this maturity. Obviously, this instrument should be able to aggregate criteria and sub-criteria of the conceptual maturity model in the form of a composite indicator and report the budgeting maturity indicator in the form of a score. Therefore, the second objective of this study is to develop a multi-layer data envelopment analysis model to measure PBB maturity index using optimization approach in constructing the composite indicator. By calculating the maturity score of each decision unit, the weight of sub-criteria in the macro indicator will be calculated.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• ABSTRACT
• 1. INTRODUCTION
• 2. LITERATURE REVIEW
• 3. A CRITICAL REVIEW ON CURRENTPBB MATURITY MODELS ANDPRESENTING A DEVELOPED PBBMATURITY MODEL
• 4. MULTILAYER DEA BASED-CIMODEL TO CALCULATE MATURITYSCORE
• 5. Numerical example
• 6. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
• REFERENCES

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Meng, W., "Twolevel DEA approaches in research evaluation" 36 (36): 950-957, 2008

2 Melyn, W., "Towards a Synthetic Indicator of Macroeconomic Performance: Unequal Weighting When Limited Information is Available" Katholieke Universiteit Leuven 1991

3 Melkers, J., "The state of the states : Performance-based budgeting requirements in 47 out of 50" 58 (58): 66-73, 1998

4 Popesko, B., "The maturity of a budgeting system and its influence on corporate performance" 14 (14): 91-104, 2017

5 Azar, A., "Provide a conceptual model of performance-based budgeting" 24 : 15-33, 2015

6 Kong, D., "Performance-based budgeting : The US experience" 5 (5): 91-107, 2005

7 NeuBrain, "Performance-Based Budgeting Methodology and Tools, White paper"

8 Curristine, T., "Performance information in the budget process" 5 (5): 87-131, 2006

9 Lu, H., "Performance budgeting resuscitated: Why is it still in viable?" 10 (10): 151-172, 1996

10 Lu, E. Y., "Performance budgeting in American states : A framework of integrating performance with budgeting" 38 (38): 562-572, 2015

11 Herzog, R. J., "Performance budgeting : Descriptive, allegorical, mythical, and idealistic" 9 (9): 72-91, 2006

12 Azar, A, Bayat, K., "PBB reward model, technical report" 2013

13 Azar, A., "PBB and performance auditing" Publication of the Center for Human Resources Development and Training 2009

14 Cherchye, L., "One market, one number? A composite indicator assessment of EU internal market dynamics" 51 (51): 749-779, 2007

15 Shen, Y., "Modeling qualitative data in data envelopment analysis for composite indicators" 2 (2): 21-30, 2011

16 Nazari-Shirkouhi, S., "Modeling customer satisfaction with new product design using a flexible fuzzy regression-data envelopment analysis algorithm" 50 : 755-771, 2017

17 Despotis, D. K., "Measuring human development via data envelopment analysis : The case of Asia and the Pacific" 33 (33): 385-390, 2005

18 Shen, Y., "Inter-national Benchmarking of Road Safety Performance and Development using Indicators and Indexes: Data Envelopment Analysis based Approaches" Hasselt University 2012

19 Yazdi, M. R. T., "Integrated fuzzy DEA-ANFIS to measure the success effect of human resource spirituality" 49 (49): 151-169, 2018

20 Shen, Y., "Fuzzy data envelopment analysis in composite indicator construction, Performance Measurement with Fuzzy Data Envelopment Analysis" Springer 89-100, 2014

21 Ramanathan, R., "Evaluating the comparative performance of countries of the Middle East and North Africa : A DEA application" 40 (40): 156-167, 2006

22 Diamond, M. J., "Establishing a performance management framework for government" International Monetary Fund 2005

23 Färe, R., "Environmental performance : An index number approach" 26 (26): 343-352, 2004

24 Andersson, E. A., "EMG activities of the quadratus lumborum and erector spinae muscles during flexion-relaxation and other motor tasks" 11 (11): 392-400, 1996

25 Cherchye, L., "Creating composite indicators with DEA and robustness analysis : The case of the technology achievement index" 59 (59): 239-251, 2008

26 Shah, A., "Budgeting and budgetary institutions" The World Bank 137-178, 2007

27 Libby, T., "Beyond budgeting or budgeting reconsidered? A survey of North-American budgeting practice" 21 (21): 56-57, 2010

28 Robinson, M., "Best practice in performance budgetting" School of Economics and Finance, Queensland University of Technology 2002

29 Russell, S. J., "Artificial intelligence: A modern approach" Pearson Education Limited 2016

30 Nili, M., "Addressing the growth failure of the oil economies: The role of financial development" 46 (46): 726-740, 2007

31 McGill, R., "Achieving results: Performance budgeting in the least developed countries, Chapters 7and 8"

32 Hatefi, S. M., "A slack analysis framework for improving composite indicators with applications to human development and sustainable energy indices" 37 (37): 247-259, 2018

33 Hermans, E., "A methodology for developing a composite road safety performance index for crosscoountry comparison" Hasselt University 2009

34 Zhou, P., "A mathematical programming approach to constructing composite indicators" 62 (62): 291-297, 2007

35 Kao, C., "A linear formulation of the two-level DEA model" 36 (36): 958-962, 2008

36 Shen, Y., "A generalized multiple layer data envelopment analysis model for hierarchical structure assessment : A case study in road safety performance evaluation" 38 (38): 15262-15272, 2011

37 Shwartz, M., "A DEA based composite measure of quality and its associated data uncertainty interval for health care provider profiling and pay-for-performance" 253 (253): 489-502, 2016