The 15-Year Evolution of the Thoracoscopic Anterior Release: Does It Still Have a Role?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Study Design: Retrospective.
Purpose: To determine how the indications for anterior thoracoscopic release and fusion have evolved over time.
Overview of Literature: Anterior release was commonly performed to correct severe spinal deformities before the advent of pedicle screw fixation. The thoracoscopic approach significantly reduced the morbidity, as compared to open thoracotomy procedures.
Methods: We reviewed charts and radiographs of pediatric spinal deformity patients who underwent thoracoscopic release/fusion for their deformity from 1994 to 2008. Indications for the thoracoscopic procedure were assigned to one of the following categories: hyperkyphosis, large/stiff scoliosis, crankshaft prevention, and ‘other’. We analysed indications grouped in 3-year intervals to determine how the indications for this procedure evolved over the past 15 years.
Results: One hundred and thirty-eight patients (mean age, 15 years; range, 2–28 years) underwent the procedure, with 160 identified indications. The frequency of thoracoscopic anterior release/fusion decreased after peaking in the years 2000–2002. Initially, hyperkyphosis was the most frequent indication (15/33, 45%; 1994–1996), but declined to an intermittent indication since 2006. The use of thoracoscopy to prevent crankshaft has also declined, but remains an indication for the most immature cases (2/17, 12%; 2006–2008). Severe or rigid scoliosis is currently the most common indication for thoracoscopic release/fusion at our center (11/17, 65%; 2006–2008).
Conclusions: The indications for a thoracoscopic anterior release/fusion has evolved with our increased understanding of this procedure and improved posterior fixation with pedicle screw instrumentation. Thoracoscopy in select spinal deformity patients still has an important role despite its less frequent use, as compared to the past decade.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Newton PO, "Thoracoscopic anterior instrumentation for idiopathic scoliosis" 9 : 595-598, 2009

2 Dickman CA, "Thoracic vertebrectomy and reconstruction using a microsurgical thoracoscopic approach" 38 : 279-293, 1996

3 Horowitz MB, "Thoracic discectomy using video assisted thoracoscopy" 19 : 1082-1086, 1994

4 Burton DC, "The treatment of large (>70 degrees) thoracic idiopathic scoliosis curves with posterior instrumentation and arthrodesis: when is anterior release indicated?" 30 : 1979-1984, 2005

5 Dubousset J, "The crankshaft phenomenon" 9 : 541-550, 1989

6 Geck MJ, "The Ponte procedure: posterior only treatment of Scheuermann’s kyphosis using segmental posterior shortening and pedicle screw instrumentation" 20 : 586-593, 2007

7 Newton PO, "Surgical treatment of main thoracic scoliosis with thoracoscopic anterior instrumentation: surgical technique" 91 (91): 233-248, 2009

8 Newton PO, "Surgical treatment of main thoracic scoliosis with thoracoscopic anterior instrumentation: a five-year follow-up study" 90 : 2077-2089, 2008

9 Bradford DS, "Surgical management of severe thoracic lordosis: a new technique to restore normal kyphosis" 8 : 420-428, 1983

10 Tsirikos AI, "Spinal deformity in neurofibromatosis type-1: diagnosis and treatment" 14 : 427-439, 2005

11 Savini R, "Spinal deformities in Marfan’s syndrome" 6 : 19-40, 1980

12 Rosenthal D, "Removal of a protruded thoracic disc using microsurgical endoscopy: a new technique" 19 : 1087-1091, 1994

13 Dohin B, "Prevention of the crankshaft phenomenon with anterior spinal epiphysiodesis in surgical treatment of severe scoliosis of the younger patient" 3 : 165-168, 1994

14 Shufflebarger HL, "Prevention of the crankshaft phenomenon" 16 (16): S409-S411, 1991

15 Lapinksy AS, "Preventing the crankshaft phenomenon by combining anterior fusion with posterior instrumentation. Does it work?" 20 : 1392-1398, 1995

16 Landreneau RJ, "Postoperative pain-related morbidity: video-assisted thoracic surgery versus thoracotomy" 56 : 1285-1289, 1993

17 Suk SI, "Is anterior release necessary in severe scoliosis treated by posterior segmental pedicle screw fixation?" 16 : 1359-1365, 2007

18 Bridwell KH, "Indications and techniques for anterior-only and combined anterior and posterior approaches for thoracic and lumbar spine deformities" 54 : 559-565, 2005

19 Dwyer AF, "Experience of anterior correction of scoliosis" (93) : 191-206, 1973

20 Betz RR, "Comparison of anterior and posterior instrumentation for correction of adolescent thoracic idiopathic scoliosis" 24 : 225-239, 1999

21 Johnson JR, "Combined use of anterior and posterior surgery for adult scoliosis" 19 : 361-370, 1988

22 Floman Y, "Combined anterior and posterior fusion in seventy-three spinally deformed patients: indications, results and complications" (164) : 110-122, 1982

23 Mack MJ, "Application of thoracoscopy for diseases of the spine" 56 : 736-738, 1993

24 Dobbs MB, "Anterior/posterior spinal instrumentation versus posterior instrumentation alone for the treatment of adolescent idiopathic scoliotic curves more than 90 degrees" 31 : 2386-2391, 2006

25 Arlet V, "Anterior thoracoscopic spine release in deformity surgery: a meta-analysis and review" 9 (9): S17-S23, 2000

26 Rosenthal D, "Anterior decompression and stabilization using a microsurgical endoscopic technique for metastatic tumors of the thoracic spine" 84 : 565-572, 1996

27 Upasani VV, "Anterior and thoracoscopic scoliosis surgery for idiopathic scoliosis" 38 : 531-540, 2007

28 Kostuik JP, "Anterior Zielke instrumentation for spinal deformity in adults" 71 : 898-912, 1989