Kazakhstan's economic soft balancing policy vis-à-vis Russia: From the Eurasian Union to the economic cooperation with Turkey

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

What has been the reaction of Kazakhstan toward the rising power and influence of Russia since 1994? This paper uses the concept of soft-balancing, specifically analyzing economic issues using Stephen Walt's balance of threats approach, in an analysis of Kazakhstan's relationship with Russia. It examines instances of Kazakhstan's internal and external economic soft balancing efforts vis-à-vis Russia to explain how it used economic tools to protect its energy security from Russia.
















After 1991, which marked the collapse of the Soviet Union, the newly independent countries of the former Soviet Union – the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), including Kazakhstan, needed to create an institution that could tackle economic and energy problems in the region. I argue that the Eurasian Union idea promoted by the president of Kazakhstan, Nursultan Nazarbayev, was a skillful attempt to simultaneously maintain a close cooperation with Russia and to soft balance against Russia's influence through collaboration with other CIS countries. However, that initiative failed and did not have the intended economic soft balancing effect.
















When Russia started asserting its economic and political power over the Central Asian and Caspian regions, Nazarbayev once again resorted to the economic soft balancing policy, but this time by relying on outside players. Part 2 of this article discusses two cases of such external economic soft balancing efforts: participation in the Baku–Tbilisi–Ceyhan (BTC) pipeline project, and the economic cooperation with Turkey as part of a free trade zone. The BTC pipeline project and the close economic cooperation with Turkey ended up being a more productive soft balancing effort than the earlier Eurasian Union initiative.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

What has been the reaction of Kazakhstan toward the rising power and influence of Russia since 1994? This paper uses the concept of soft-balancing, specifically analyzing economic issues using Stephen Walt's balance of threats approach, in an analysis of Kazakhstan's relationship with Russia. It examines instances of Kazakhstan's internal and external economic soft balancing efforts vis-à-vis Russia to explain how it used economic tools to protect its energy security from Russia.


After 1991, which marked the collapse of the Soviet Union, the newly independent countries of the former Soviet Union – the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), including Kazakhstan, needed to create an institution that could tackle economic and energy problems in the region. I argue that the Eurasian Union idea promoted by the president of Kazakhstan, Nursultan Nazarbayev, was a skillful attempt to simultaneously maintain a close cooperation with Russia and to soft balance against Russia's influence through collaboration with other CIS countries. However, that initiative failed and did not have the intended economic soft balancing effect.


When Russia started asserting its economic and political power over the Central Asian and Caspian regions, Nazarbayev once again resorted to the economic soft balancing policy, but this time by relying on outside players. Part 2 of this article discusses two cases of such external economic soft balancing efforts: participation in the Baku–Tbilisi–Ceyhan (BTC) pipeline project, and the economic cooperation with Turkey as part of a free trade zone. The BTC pipeline project and the close economic cooperation with Turkey ended up being a more productive soft balancing effort than the earlier Eurasian Union initiative.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Lieber, K., "Waiting for balancing: Why the world is not pushing back" 30 (30): 109-139, 2005

2 Tokaev, K. K., "Vektory vneshney politiki. Kniga 1: Vostochnoe napravlenie" 2008

3 "V Baku sostoyalas’ torzhestvennaya tseremoniya, posvyashyonnaya 20-letiyu ‘Kontrakta veka’ i zakladke fundamenta Yuzhnogo gazovogo koridora"

4 "V Antalii podpisan Protokol o sozdanii Parlamentskoi Assamblei tyurkoyazychnykh gosudarstv"

5 "Turtsiya predlozhila otkryt’ zonu svobodnoi torgovli s Tamozhennym soyuzom"

6 Markedonov, S., "Turkey and Russia: An evolving relationship" Carnegie Endowment for International Peace

7 Tanrisever, O. F., "Turkey and Russia in the Black Sea Region: Dynamics of cooperation and conflict" Centre for Economics and Foreign Policy Studies 2012

8 Satpaev, D., "Traditsionnaya mnogovektornost’ i nichego lishnego. Rossiisko-kazakhstanskaya evolyutsiya: ot partnerstva k konkurentsii"

9 Walt, S. M., "The origins of alliances" Cornell University Press 1987

10 Laumulin, M., "The foreign policy and security of the Republic of Kazakhstan" EURASIA Foundation 1997

11 "The Embassy of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the Russian Federation"

12 Vasiliev, A., "The Black Sea region in Turkish foreign policy strategy: Russia and Turkey on the Black Sea" Black Sea Peacebuilding Network Russian Expert Group 2010

13 Website of International Finance Corporation, World Bank Group, "The BTC Pipeline Project: “Lessons of Experience”"

14 Walt, S. M., "Taming American power: The global response to U.S. primacy" Norton 2005

15 Paul, T., "Soft balancing in the age of U.S. primacy" 30 (30): 46-71, 2005

16 Pape, R., "Soft balancing against the United States" 30 (30): 7-45, 2005

17 Kononovich, E., "Shagi real’noi integratsii"

18 Shkvarya, L. V., "Rossiya v integratsionnykh protsessakh na postsovetskom prostranstve: sovremennye osobennosti Problemy sovremennoi ekonomiki, No.4"

19 "Rossiya proigrala nefteproekt iz-za voiny v Chechne"

20 "Relations between Turkey and Kazakhstan" Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Republic of Turkey

21 Saari, S., "Putin’s Eurasian Union Initiative: Are the premises of Russia’s post-Soviet policy changing? November 1. Ul Brief, No. 9"

22 Sultanov, B., "Prezident Nazarbayev i sovremennyi Kazakhstan, Tom III" KISI 2010

23 Oganesyan, A., "Paper presented at the Mezhdunarodnaya konferentsiya: Evraziyskii vektor razvitiya: problemy i perspektivy"

24 "Ofitsial’nyi sayt Prezidenta Respubliki Kazakhstan – Vystuplenie Prezidenta Respubliki Kazakhstan Nazarbayeva v Moskovskom Gosudarstvennom universitete imeni Lomonosova"

25 "Novyi integratsionnyi proekt dlya Evrazii–budushchee, kotoroe rozhdaetsya segodnya"

26 Portnikov, V., "Nezavisimaya gazeta"

27 Povazhnaya, G., "Myagkaya sila: o podkhodakh i praktike v Rossii i na Evraziyskom prostranstve" 2012

28 Trubetzkoy, N. S., "My i drugie v knige Russkii uzel evraziystva, sbornik trudov evraziitsev (Belovod’e, 1997); Evraziistvo (opyt sistematicheskogo izlozheniya) kollektivnaya monografiya pervikh evraziisev (1926g.) v knige Osnovy Evraziistva (Arktogeya-tsentr, 2002)"

29 Tomberg, I., "Moskve pridyotsya privykat’ k “mnogovektornoı˘” diplomatii Nazarbayeva"

30 Kudaibergenov, O., "Komu v TS zhit’ horosho?"

31 Pomfret, R., "Kazakhstan’s economy since independence: Does the oil boom offer a second chance for sustainable development?" 57 (57): 859-976, 2005

32 Ukaz Prezidenta RK o kontseptsii vneshnei politiki RK na 2014–2020 gody, "Kazakhstanskaya Pravda"

33 "Kazakhstan: ekonomika i zhizn’, № 5"

34 "Kazakhstan vyigraet ot sozdaniya zony svobodnoi torgovli Turtsii s Tamozhennym soyuzom: eksperty"

35 Panfilova, V., "Kazakhstan obhodit Rossiyu"

36 Malashenko, A., "Interesy i shansy Rossii v Tsentral’noi Azii"

37 Laruelle, M., "Globalizing Central Asia: Geopolitics and the challenges of economic development" M.E. Sharpe, Inc 14-, 2013

38 Kazhegel’din, A., "Evraziyskii Soyuz: novye rubezhi, problemy, perspektivy" Izdatel’skii tsentr “SAMPO” 1996

39 Putin, V., "Evraziyskii Soyuz rozhdalsya so skandalami"

40 Nysanbaev, A., "Evraziyskaya doktrina Nursultana Nazarbayeva" 2010

41 Verkhoturov, D., "Evraziiskaya doktrina Nursultana Nazarbayeva" Institut filosofii i politologii KN MON RK 272-275, 2010

42 Overland, I., "Caspian energy politics: Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan" Taylor & Francis 2011

43 Roy, O., "A new geo-strategic context in the new central Asia: The creation of nations" I.B.Tauris 2000