원전 체제의 형성, 1940~1970: 미·영·프·독의 경우를 중심으로 = The Making of Nuclear Power Production Regimes during 1940~1970 in the US, UK, France and Germany

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The history of nuclear power production in the United States, the United Kingdoms, France and West Germany contradicts technological determinism. The reactor technology converged on the light water reactor, while their nuclear power regimes diverged quite differently. This historical development evades socio-economical factor analysis, since the historical contingencies and contexts of each nation played critical roles. Even nuclear engineers and scientists` legitimate domain of expertise were dissimilar. Though the nuclear policy of United States conditioned the nuclear development of the UK, France, West Germany, the influences never were unidirectional. Especially, UK`s nuclear development propelled US to created then non-existent nuclear power plant program. At the end of 1960s, nuclear power production regimes in each nations were established. However, they were confronted with different problems. In the United States, the traditional arguments on “government vs private sector” took a new turn. Safety concern iginited quite a acerbic controversy. Both of the United Kingdoms and West Germany shared the expectations that nuclear power plant industry would be a healthy export industry, but that prospects were not bright, regardless of who controls the nuclear industry, the government(UK) or private sector(West Germany). France had finally caught-up the Anglo-American nuclear capacities, if not quantity. However how to realize France`s strong nationalistic vision remained an open question. (Dongguk University-Seoul/[e-mail], Korea Military Academy, Sookmyung Women`s University, Dongguk University-Seoul)

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 문지영, "드골의 대미외교정책, 1958-1969" 한국프랑스사학회 16 (16): 165-192, 2007

2 U. Hasenöhrl, "Zivillgesellschaft und Protest. Zur Geschichte der Umweltbewegung in der BRD zwischen 1945 und 1980 am Beispiel Bayerns" WZB 16-, 2003

3 Walter E. Grunden, "Wartime Nuclear Weapons Research in Germany and Japan" 20 : 107-130, 2005

4 James H. Hill, "Uranium Enrichment In The United States" Oak Ridge Operations. Energy Research & Development Administration 1975

5 Spencer R. Weart, "The Rise of Nuclear Fear" Harvard University Press 32-44, 2012

6 Gabrielle Hecht, "The Radiance of France: Nuclear Power and National Identity after World War II" MIT Press 2009

7 John Krige, "The Peaceful Atom as Political Weapon: Euratom and American Foreign Policy in the Late 1950s" 38 (38): 5-44, 2008

8 Roger Williams, "The Nuclear Power Decisions" Croom Helm 22-42, 1980

9 A. Weinberg, "The First Nuclear Era: The Life and Times of a Technological Fixer" American Institute of Physics 136-, 1994

10 Mervyn O'Driscoll, "The European Parliament and the Euratom Treaty:past, present and future" European Parliament 1-44,

11 J. R. Newman, "The Control of Atomic Energy" McGraw-Hill 3-, 1948

12 H, Bufe, "Staat und Atomindustrie. Kernenergiepolitik in der BRD" Pahl-Rugenstein 1979

13 Robert Lorenz, "Protest der Physiker. Die Göttinger Erklärung von 1957" Transcirpt Verlag 2011

14 Simon Taylor, "Privatization and Financial Collapse in the Nuclear Industry" Routledge 9-18, 2007

15 C. Rogers McCullough, "Preliminary Design Proposal: Daniels Expermental Power Pile" ORNL 1946

16 Alex Wellerstein, "Patenting the bomb:Nuclear weapons, intellectual property, and technological control" 99 (99): 57-87, 2008

17 Leland Johnson, "Oak Ridge National Laboratory: First Fifty Years" University of Tennessee Press 82-, 1994

18 Maurice Goldsmith, "Nuclear fission and war" 70 (70): 646-647, 1975

19 Simon Sneddon, "Nuclear Unclear: An Investigation of British Nuclear Power Policy 1945-2005" Lambert Academic Publishing 136-, 2014

20 W. Allen, "Nuclear Reactors for Generating Electricity: US Development 1946-1963" RAND 1977

21 David Lowry, "Nuclear Power: An Assessment of Nuclear Decision Making 1932-79, with Special Reference to the Anglo-American Atomic Relationship" Open University 1986

22 Philip Sporn, "Nuclear Power Economics: 1962 through 1967" 2-22, 1968

23 R. F. Pocock, "Nuclear Power : Its Development in the United Kingdom" Institution of Nuclear Engineers 1977

24 OECD Nuclear Energy Agency, "NEA 50th Anniversary"

25 B. B. Heuser, "NATO, Britain, France and the FRG: Nuclear Strategies and Forces for Europe, 1949–2000" Palgrave Macmillan 125-130, 1997

26 M. L Wald, "Milton Shaw, 80, Who Oversaw First Nuclear Submarine Project"

27 Paul Reuss, "L’époque de l’énergie nucléaire. Une histore scientifique et industrielle" EDP Sciences 48-, 2007

28 Alain Mallevre, "L’histoire de l’énergie nucléaire en France de 1895 à nos jours" 101 : 17-, 2007

29 Bertrand Goldschmidt, "Les origines du CEA [Commissariat a 1'energie atomique)" (103) : 61-65, 1995

30 Jean-François Picard, "Les français et l’énergie. Receuil d’enquêtes et de sondages d’opinion effectués sur des thèmes se rapportant l’énergie en France de 1945 à nos jours" CNRS, EDF 4-, 1980

31 Philippe Simonnot, "Les Nucléocrates" Presses Universitaires de Grenoble 14-193, 1978

32 Gabrielle Hecht, "Le rayonnement de la France: Énergie nucléaire et identiténationale après la Seconde Guerre mondiale" La Découverte 2004

33 Jean-François Picard, "La longue marche vers le CNRS(1901-1945)" CNRS 13-, 1988

34 Sezin Topçu, "La France nucléaire. L’art de gouverner une technologie contestée" Seuil 27-, 2013

35 M. Gowing, "Independence and Deterrence: Britain and Atomic Energy 1945-1952, vol.1" Macmillan 4-, 1974

36 W. C. Patterson, "Going Critical: An Unofficial History of British Nuclear Power" Palatin Grafton Books 7-8, 1985

37 Mark Walker, "German National Socialism and the Quest for Nuclear Power, 1939-49" Cambridge University Press 1993

38 Pierre Biquard, "Frédéric Joliot-Curie et l’énergie atomique" Harmattan 135-136, 2003

39 Pertti Ahonen, "Franz‐Josef Strauss and the German nuclear question, 1956–1962" 18 (18): 25-51, 1995

40 Rolf-Jürgen Gleitsmann, "Fortschrittsfeinde im Atomzeitalter? Protest und Innovationsmanagement am Beispiel der frühen Kernenergiepläne der Bundesrepublik Deutschland" GNT-Verlag 133-, 2012

41 Irvin C. Bupp, "Failed Promise of Nuclear Power: Story of Light Water" Basic Books 33-55, 1978

42 Thomas R. Wellock, "Engineering Uncertainty and Bureaucratic Crisis at the Atomic Energy Commission, 1964–1973" 53 : 853-, 2012

43 Christian Deubner, "Die Atompolitik der westdeutschen Industrie und die Grundung von Euratom" 55-57, 1977

44 IAEA, "Country Statistics"

45 Georges Laminal, "Chronique de trente années d’équipement nucléaire Electricitéde France, t.1" Association pour l’Histoire de l’Electricité en France 12-22, 1988

46 H. Parr, "British Way in Cold Warfare: Intelligence, Diplomacy and the Bomb 1945-1975" Continuum 87-104, 2009

47 Joachim Radkau, "Aufstieg und Fall der deutschen Atom Wirtschaft" Oekom 77-181, 2013

48 Richard G. Hewlett, "Atoms for Peace and War, 1953-1961:Eisenhower and the Atomic Energy Commission, A History of the United States Atomic Energy Commission. Vol. III" University of California Press 27-407, 1989

49 Lawrence Scheinman, "Atomic Energy Policy in France under the Fourth Republic" Princeton University Press 199-200, 1965

50 David Owen, "Anglo-French Nuclear Cooperation" 41 (41): 158-161, 1985

51 Alice L. Buck, "A History of the Atomic Energy Commission" U.S. Department of Energy

52 Kent A.Williams, "A History of U.S. Uranium Enrichment in the 1950s" Oak Ridge National Laboratory

53 문지영, "20세기 초 프랑스 과학연구 조직화와 국립과학연구센터(CNRS)의 탄생" 한국프랑스사학회 (32) : 85-110, 2015