1차 의원 의료사고 현황분석(2010-2012): 대한의사협회 의료공제회 사건기록지 분석을 통해 = The state of medical malpractice caused by private practice physicians (2010-2012): analysis through incident reports at Korean Medical Association Medical Indemnities Mutuals

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study was conducted to understand the current state of medical malpractice through analyzing recorded incidents by characteristics of medical intervention, and treatment results classified by treatment type and so on. The data for this study were extracted from the recorded incidents of medical malpractices committed by private practice physicians, which were provided by the Korean Medical Association Medical Indemnity Mutuals (KMAMA). The analysis was based on the treatment codes registered as primary medical practice of the respective private practice physicians at the time of joining KMAMA Medical malpractice occurrence rate by region was highest in Daegu with 7.1%. Analysis of causes of malpractice by codes showed dermatology/urology/plastic surgery department’s C5 (standard medical care [outpatient] including standard injection, drug administration, simple topical anesthesia, simple treatment+regional anesthesia [spinal/epidural anesthesia]+general anesthesia [intravenous/inhaled anesthesia]) had the highest number of incidents with 223 cases. For the cases of death as prognosis, code B2, consisting of “basic treatment+regional anesthesia, intraarticular injection, epidural nerve block,” had the highest incidents. This study concluded with the suggestion for the need to establish a system that will allow reporting and sharing incidents of private practice medical malpractice, and the necessity of acknowledging the importance of sharing such knowledge among medical practitioners.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 유화진, "의료인의 민사책임" 대한의사협회 56 (56): 648-654, 2013

2 이인호, "의료사고의 책임소재에 관한 실증적 연구" 한국의료법학회 13 (13): 63-70, 2005

3 이현실, "의료사고와 의료분쟁에 대한 의료이용자들의 의식 조사" 한국병원경영학회 11 (11): 1-30, 2006

4 최행식, "의료사고 피해구조에 관한 고찰" 법학연구소 26 (26): 539-562, 2010

5 손명세, "의료사고 분쟁에 소요되는 총비용 추계" 한국의료법학회 13 (13): 57-76, 2005

6 이정찬, "의료사고 발생시 의사와 환자간 합의액에 영향을 미치는 요인" 한국보건사회학회 (28) : 169-196, 2010

7 임복희, "의료분쟁 판례분석" 한국콘텐츠학회 10 (10): 294-303, 2010

8 김은진, "의료분쟁 위기관리 커뮤니케이션 단계모델 추출을 위한 탐색적 연구" 한국보건사회연구원 32 (32): 391-428, 2012

9 김상현, "국내 판례분석을 통한 의료사고 예방대책 연구 - 외국인 환자 의료사고 예방을 중심으로-" 한국의료법학회 20 (20): 95-120, 2012

10 Stewart RM, "Trauma surgery malpractice risk : perception versus reality" 241 : 969-975, 2005

11 Levinson W, "The relationship with mal-practice claims among primary care physicians and surgeons" 277 : 553-559, 1997

12 Hwang MS, "The legal scheme for resolving conflicts between patients and physicians" National Research Council for Economics, Humanities and Social Sciences Cooperative Research Studies 2005

13 Lee MK., "The effects of apology and general trust on anger and forgiveness in medical malpractice" Chung-Ang University 2011

14 Beckman HB, "The doctor-patient relationship and malpractice : lessons from plaintiff depositions" 154 : 1365-1370, 1994

15 Korean Institute of Medicine, "Strategy alternatives of mal-practice prevention using the systematic analysis of medical service’s type" Korean Institute of Medicine 2003

16 Kim KH, "Research on meditation strategy and reputation recovery particulars regarding medical accidents" Korean Medical Associ-ation 2013

17 Asian Institute for Bioethics and Health Law, "Research on medical malpractice prevention programs for foreign patients" Korea Health Industry Development Institute 2009

18 Cho HS, "Reasons why patients and families choose medical dispute" 19 : 274-291, 1998

19 Beck RS, "Physician-patient com-munication in the primary care office : a systematic review" 15 : 25-38, 2002

20 Korea Health Industry Development Institute, "Medical re-source statistics handbook"

21 Nakajima K, "Medical malpractice and legal resolution systems in Japan" 285 : 1632-1640, 2001

22 Yasunaga H, "Legal intervention against medical accidents in Japan" 1 : 39-42, 2008

23 Lee SI, "Improvement of medical treatment quality through pa-tient safety control" Policy for Healthcare Facilities and Medicine 2012

24 Lee DY., "Identifying causes of pediatric malpractice and devel-oping measures to prevent recurrence through an analysis of court decisions on medical disputes in pediatrics" Yonsei University 2014

25 Korean Statistical Information Service, "Health Insurance Re-view & Assessment Service medical resources statistics system"

26 Baicker K, "Defensive medicine and disappearing doctors" 28 : 24-31, 2005

27 Kim JH, "Current situation and related issues on medical mal-practice : an approach form medical sociological perspective" 32 : 395-426, 1998

28 Cho BH, "Attitudes of Taegu citizens on medical malpractice and conflicts" 2 : 85-105, 1997

29 Korea Consumer Agency, "Annual report and casebook on con-sumer remedy damage" Korea Consumer Agency 2011

30 Shim JH, "Analysis of precedents related to the medical accidents of neu-rosurgery" 8 : 32-36, 2012

31 Lee SY, "Activating the medical acci-dent damage relief and medical dispute mediation law"

32 Shin EH, "A study for analysis of the current status of medical disputes and the characteristics by medical department : cen-tered on the data of 2006 Korea Consumer Agency" Yon-sei University 2007

33 Min HY, "A rational scheme for medical malpractice compensation in OBGYN : focusing on a structu-ral analysis by types" 12 : 63-100, 2004