Can Threatened Moral Self Make People Prefer Ecological Product? - An Eye Tracking Research based on Chinese Face Consciousness

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: Social influence has a decisive role in shaping a person's cognition and behavior. Chinese face consciousness, including moral component, is an important part of Chinese traditional culture, which influences people to implement moral behavior. With both eye-tracking technology and traditional questionnaire, this research aims to explore people's moral psychology and the psychological processing mechanisms of Chinese face consciousness, as well as the impact of Chinese face consciousness on the preference for the ecological product.
Method and Data: 75 college and MBA students' eye movement data were collected when they read different kinds of moral materials, as well as data from the subsequent questionnaires. To test the hypothesis, ANOVA analysis and Heat Map analysis were performed. Besides, the PROCESS of bootstrap was used to test mediation effect.
Findings: The results reveal that: 1. Compared to the moral-situation reading, when subjects read immoral situations, they need more processing time due to the moral dissonance and cognitive load. 2. Compared to the control condition, when threatened moral self is primed, subjects prefer to choose ecological product. 3. Protective face orientation is the mediator between threatened moral self and preference to ecological product.
Key Contributions: First, this study broadens the use of eye-tracking technology in marketing and demonstrates a better understanding of the relationship between morality and consumer behavior in a more scientific way. Second, this study not only distinguishes the meanings between “protective face orientation" and “acquisitive face orientation", but also innovatively validates that when moral self is threatened, consumers tend to choose ecological product as moral compensation in order to protect their face. It can shed light on the promotion of ecological product in practical applications.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Carrington, Michal J., "Why Ethical Consumers Don't Walk Their Talk : Towards a Framework for Understanding the Gap between the Ethical Purchase Intentions and Actual Buying Behaviour of Ethically Minded Consumers" 97 (97): 139-158, 2010

2 Conway, Paul, "When Does Feeling Moral Actually Make You a Better Person? Conceptual Abstraction Moderates whether Past Moral Deeds Motivate Consistency or Compensatory Behavior" 38 (38): 907-919, 2012

3 Liu, Han-Chin, "Using Eye-Tracking Technology to Investigate the Redundant Effect of Multimedia Web Pages on Viewers’Cognitive Processes" 27 (27): 2410-2417, 2011

4 Brown, P., "Universals in Language Usage : Politeness Phenomena" Cambridge University Press 1978

5 Heiskanen, Eva, "Toward Sustainable Consumption : Two New Perspectives" 20 (20): 409-442, 1997

6 Luchs, Michael G., "The Sustainability Liability : Potential Negative Effects of Ethicality on Product Preference" 74 (74): 18-31, 2010

7 Triandis, Harry C, "The Self and Social Behavior in Differing Cultural Contexts" 96 (96): 506-520, 1989

8 Bradley, Margaret M., "The Pupil as a Measure of Emotional Arousal and Autonomic Activation" 45 (45): 602-607, 2008

9 Peng, Kaiping, "The Psychophysics of Morality: Phenomena, Mechanism and Meaning" (12) : 28-45, 2012

10 Sherman, David K., "The Psychology of Self-Defense: Self-Affirmation Theory(Vol. 118)" Media Source 1-103, 2006

11 Barkan Rachel, "The Pot Calling the Kettle Black : Distancing Response to Ethical Dissonance" 141 (141): 757-773, 2012

12 Ratner, Rebecca K., "The Impact of Private versus Public Consumption on Variety-Seeking Behavior" 29 (29): 246-257, 2002

13 Henderson, John M., "The Effects of Semantic Consistency on Eye Movements during Complex Scene Viewing" 25 (25): 210-228, 1999

14 Eldar, Eran, "The Effects of Neural Gain on Attention and Learning" 16 (16): 1146-1153, 2013

15 Hu, Hsien Chin, "The Chinese Concept of Face" 46 (46): 45-64, 1944

16 Smith, Arthur H., "The Chinese Characteristics" FH Revell Co 1984

17 Yan, Guoli, "The Application of Eye Movement Analysis Method in Psychological Research" Tianjin Education Press 2004

18 Jordan, Jennifer, "Striving for the Moral Self : The Effects of Recalling Past Moral Actions on Future Moral Behavior" 37 (37): 701-713, 2011

19 Myers, David, "Social Psychology" Posts and Telecom Press 2006

20 Sachdeva, Sonya, "Sinning Saints and Saintly Sinners : the Paradox of Moral Self-Regulation" 20 (20): 523-528, 2009

21 King, A. Yeo-ehi, "Shame as an Incomplete Conception of Chinese Culture: A Study of Face" Chinese University of Hong Kong, Social Research Center 1977

22 Baumeister, Roy, "Self-Regulation Failure : An Overview" 7 (7): 1-15, 1996

23 Dunning, David, "Self-Image Motives and Consumer Behavior : How Sacrosanct Self-Beliefs Sway Preferences in the Marketplace" 17 (17): 237-249, 2007

24 Lu, Xun, "Said the ‘Face’" China Renmin University Press 2005

25 Preacher, Kristopher J., "SPSS and SAS Procedures for Estimating Indirect Effects in Simple Mediation Models" 36 (36): 717-731, 2004

26 Tun, Patricia A., "Response latencies in Auditory Sentence Comprehension : Effects of Linguistic versus Perceptual Challenge" 25 (25): 730-735, 2010

27 Wang, Jianming, "Resource Conservation and Environmental Protection Behavior and Its Effect Mechanism" China Social Sciences Press 2010

28 Nassar, Matthew R., "Rational Regulation of Learning Dynamics by Pupil-Linked Arousal Systems" 15 (15): 1040-1046, 2012

29 Laeng, Bruno, "Pupillometry: A Window to the Preconscious?" 7 (7): 18-27, 2012

30 Preuschoff, Kerstin, "Pupil Dilation Signals Surprise : Evidence for Noradrenaline's Role in Decision Making" 5 : 115-, 2011

31 Chou, Meiling, "Protective and Acquisitive Face Orientation : A Person by Situation Approach to Face Dynamics in Social Interaction" 43 : 1135-1160, 1999

32 Ho, David Yau-fai, "On the Concept of Face" 81 (81): 867-884, 1976

33 Li, Honghan, "Moral Self Threats and Corresponding Coping Mechanisms" 49 (49): 147-153, 2013

34 Hardy, Walker, "Moral Identity as Moral Ideal Self : Links to Adolescent Outcomes" 50 (50): 45-57, 2014

35 Bandura, Albert, "Mechanisms of Moral Disengagement in the Exercise of Moral Agency" 71 (71): 364-374, 1996

36 Wänke, Michaela, "Measuring Implicit Consumer Attitudes and Predicting Brand Choice" 29 (29): 222-, 2002

37 Lowell, Jonathan, "Managers and Moral Dissonance : Self Justification as a Big Threat to Ethical Management" 105 (105): 17-25, 2012

38 Hertwich, Edgar G., "Life Cycle Approaches to Sustainable Consumption : A Critical Review" 39 (39): 4673-4684, 2005

39 Mehta, Ravi, "Is Noise Always Bad? Exploring the Effects of Ambient Noise on Creative Cognition" 39 (39): 784-799, 2012

40 Effron Daniel, "Inventing Racist Roads Not Taken : The Licensing Effect of Immoral Counterfactual Behaviors" 103 (103): 916-922, 2012

41 Shi, Zhuomin, "How Face Consciousness Reverse Pro-Self Behavior? A Study on Sustainable Consumption from the Perspective of Social Value Orientation" 10 (10): 59-81, 2014

42 Zaltman, Gerald, "How Customers Think:Essential Insights into the Mind of the Market" Harvard Business School Press 2003

43 Kant, Immanuel, "Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals/ Immanuel Kant" Oxford University Press 2002

44 Peloza, John, "Good and Guilt-Free : The Role of Self-Accountability in Influencing Preferences for Products with Ethical Attributes" 77 (77): 104-119, 2013

45 Joosten, Anne, "Feel Good, Do-Good? On Consistency and Compensation in Moral Self-Regulation" 123 (123): 71-84, 2014

46 Ting-toomey, Stella, "Facework Competence in Intercultural Conflict: An Updated Face-Negotiation Theory" 22 (22): 187-225, 1998

47 Hwang, Kwang-kuo, "Face and Favor : The Chinese Power Game" 92 (92): 944-974, 1987

48 Cavanagh, James F., "Eye Tracking and Pupillometry Are Indicators of Dissociable Latent Decision Processes" 143 (143): 1476-1488, 2014

49 Rayner, Keith, "Eye Movements in Reading and Information Processing : 20 Years of Research" 124 (124): 372-422, 1998

50 Yan, Guoli, "Eye Movement Analyses in Advertisement Psychology and Its Research Trend" 27 (27): 459-461, 2004

51 Underwood, Geoffrey, "Eye Guidance and Visual Information Processing:Reading, Visual Search, Picture Perception and Driving" 1-28, 1998

52 Just, Marcel Adam, "Eye Fixations and Cognitive Processes" 8 (8): 441-480, 1976

53 Haidt, Jonathan, "Differentiating Diversities : Moral Diversity Is Not like Other Kinds" 33 (33): 1-36, 2003

54 Zhu, Zhixian, "Dictionary of Psychology" Beijing Normal University Press 1989

55 Hofstede, Geert, "Cultures and Organizations : Software of the Mind" McGraw-Hill 1991

56 Zhang, Xin'an, "Consciousness of Social Face and Conspicuous Consumption of Luxury Products in the Chinese Society" 8 (8): 76-94, 2012

57 Jap, Warveni, "Confucius Face Culture on Chinese Consumer Consumption Values toward Global Brands" 5 (5): 183-, 2010

58 Wan, Echo Wen, "Confidence and Construal Framing : When Confidence Increases versus Decreases Information Processing" 39 (39): 977-992, 2013

59 Festinger, Leone, "Cognitive Dissonance Theory" Zhejiang People's Publishing House 1999

60 Shi, Zhuomin, "Cognitive Discrepancy in Chinese “Face”: Mian and Lian, and Their Impact on Cognition of Country-of-Origin Image" 5 (5): 163-178, 2011

61 Kohlberg, Lawrence, "Cognitive Development and Epistemology" Academic Press 1971

62 Chen, Zhizhao, "Chinese Social Psychological Review (Vol. 2)" Social Sciences Academic Press 107-160, 2006

63 Jin, Yaoji, "Chinese Social Psychological Review (Vol. 2)" Social Sciences Academic Press 107-160, 2006

64 Lin, Yutang, "Chinese People" Xuelin Press 1994

65 Zhou, Nan, "Chinese Consumer Readings of Global and Local Advertising Appeals" 33 (33): 63-76, 2004

66 Lu, Taihong, "Chinese Consumer Behavior Report" China Social Sciences Press 2005

67 Cupach, William R., "Characteristics and Consequences of Interpersonal Complaints Associated with Perceived Face Threat" 19 (19): 443-462, 2002

68 Zahn, Theodore P., "Autonomic Activity in Relation to Cerebrospinal Fluid Neurochemistry in Obsessive and Disruptive Children and Adolescents" 33 (33): 731-739, 1996

69 Critchley, Hugo D., "Anterior Cingulate Activity during Error and Autonomic Response" 27 (27): 885-895, 2005

70 Shi, Zhuomin, "An Empirical Study on Chinese Face and Its Effect on Consumer’s Attitude toward Advertising of Luxury" 15 (15): 151-160, 2012

71 Zhang, Zhenglin, "A Study of Consumer Impulsive Buying Based on the View of Social Influence and Mianzi" 21 (21): 66-72, 2008

72 Wedel, Michel, "A Review of Eye-Tracking Research in Marketing" 4 : 123-147, 2002

73 Duchowski, Andrew T., "A Breadth-First Survey of Eye-Tracking Applications. Behavior Research Methods" 34 (34): 455-470, 2002

74 Jiang, Bo, "A Bibliometric Analysis on Eye Movement Research in China from 1980 to 2009" 34 (34): 235-239, 2011