남북한 구강보건의료 통합과제와 접근방안에 관한 전문가 견해조사 = An expert opinion study on policy tasks and approaches for the oral health care systems ntegrations in South-North Korea

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Objectives: The aim of this study was to develop policy tasks and approaches for the integration of oral health care systems in South and North Korea on the basis of a literature research, and to verify their validity through a Delphi survey of an expert panel.
Methods: Twelve policy tasks and 11 approaches for South-North Korea integration were developed by a comparative model of oral health care systems. Two rounds of Delphi surveys were conducted via e-mail on May 20 and June 16, 2020, targeting 10 experts with experience in inter-Korean oral health care exchange and cooperation or related research. The mean, coefficient of variation (CV), and content validity ration (CVR) were calculated for each item. The validity of each item was judged based on the CVR.
Results: The five policy tasks that meet the consensus of experts are: the integration of dental college education, the integration of activity qualifications and supply/demand for general dentists, the integration of education and training for auxiliary dental personnel, the integration of activity qualifications and supply/demand for auxiliary dental personnel, and the integration of oral health care financing. The nine approaches of the consensus of experts are: sharing the philosophy, values, and strategies, guaranteeing geographic access for residents, standardized oral health care delivery, an integrated performance management system, an integrated computerized information system, an integrated governance structure, the installation and operation of an integrated organization, the re-education and re-qualification of active oral health care personnel, and integrated goals for oral health outcomes.
Conclusions: The expert panel showed a relatively high degree of agreement with policy tasks and approaches for the integration of the South-North Korea oral health care systems. It is necessary to develop more realistic contents based on more reliable North Korean data in the future.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 윤석준, "체제통합국 사례에 비추어 본 한반도 통일 후 보건의료 체계 구축의 시사점" 대한의사협회 56 (56): 389-393, 2013

2 신터전 ; 한동헌 ; 진보형 ; 김태일 ; 이재일 ; 김종철, "북한의 치의학 교육 시스템을 통해 고찰해 본 남북한 치의학교육 통합방향에 대한 시사점" 대한치과의사협회 53 (53): 726-731, 2015

3 최만호, "남북한 보건의료체계의 통합모형 개발" 한국보건복지학회 7 : 83-102, 2004

4 이새롬 ; 정세환, "김정은 시대의 북한 구강보건의료 발전방침과 실태에 대한 탐색적 연구" 대한예방치과·구강보건학회 44 (44): 26-33, 2020

5 Kim BS, "Unification perception survey 2019. Seoul: Institute for peace and unification studies" Seoul National University 30-82, 2020

6 Moon OR, "The unification of health care for the united Korea" 35 (35): 48-71, 1998

7 Lee MC, "The necessity of the inter-Korean confederation discussion for true national liberation" Korea Institute for National 1-7, 2020

8 Ministry of Unification, "The national community unification formula"

9 Lee GY, "The healthcare system approach between South and North Korea in preparation for unification" 4 (4): 98-105, 1994

10 Jeon WT, "Preparation of health community in the Korean peninsula" Parkyoungsa 3-26, 2018

11 Lee JH, "Preparation of health community in the Korean peninsula" Parkyoungsa 165-180, 2018

12 Park IH, "Policy issues and directions for the integration of North and South Korean health care system" 14 (14): 163-189, 1994

13 Jung SH, "People centered oral health policy and management" DaehanNarae Publishing Inc 5-18, 2021

14 Widstrom E, "Oral healthcare systems in the extended European Union" 2 : 155-194, 2004

15 Ministry of Unification, "Moon Jae-in’s policy on the Korean peninsula-peace and prosperity on the Korean peninsula"

16 Kravitz AS, "Manual of dental practice 2015. 5.1. ed"

17 Oral Health Policy Research Group, "Initiative of a oral health care system unification in South and North Korea" Gunchi 2001

18 North Korea Information Portal, Ministry of Unification, "Health care, Education and training of health care personnel"

19 World Health Organization, "Everybody business: strengthening health systems to improve health outcomes: WHO’s framework for action"

20 "Database on a Unified Korea’s Legal System"

21 Lee HK, "A study on the training policy for ‘health care workers’ in North Korea: with the focus on workers training to lead the regime" University of North Korea Studies 2013

22 Lawshe CH, "A quantitative approach to content validity" 28 : 563-575, 1975

23 Moon OR, "A comparative study on the health care system of South and North Korea" 30 (30): 45-72, 1993

24 Neumann DG, "A comparative analysis of oral health care systems in the United States, United Kingdom, France, Canada, and Brazil" Network for Canadian Oral Health Research 1-18, 2014