Comet tail artifact on ultrasonography: is it a reliable finding of benign gallbladder diseases?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: The aim of this study was to evaluate whether the comet tail artifact on ultrasonography can be used to reliably diagnose benign gallbladder diseases.
Methods: This retrospective study reviewed the clinical findings, imaging findings, preoperative ultrasonographic diagnoses, and pathological diagnoses of 150 patients with comet tail artifacts who underwent laparoscopic cholecystectomy with pathologic confirmation. The extent of the involved lesion was classified as localized or diffuse, depending on the degree of involvement and the anatomical section of the gallbladder that was involved. This study evaluated the differences in clinical and imaging findings among pathologic diagnoses.
Results: All gallbladder lesions exhibiting the comet tail artifact on ultrasound examination were confirmed as benign gallbladder diseases after cholecystectomy, including 71 cases of adenomyomatosis (47.3%), 74 cases of chronic cholecystitis (49.3%), two cases of xanthogranulomatous cholecystitis (1.3%), and three cases of cholesterolosis (2.0%); there were two cases of coexistent chronic cholecystitis and low-grade dysplasia. There were no statistically significant differences in any of the clinical and ultrasonographic findings, with the exception of gallstones (P=0.007), among the four diseases. There were no significant differences in the average length, thickness, or number of comet tail artifacts among the four diagnoses. No malignancies were detected in any of the 150 thickened gallbladder lesions.
Conclusion: The ultrasonographic finding of the comet tail artifact in patients with thickened gallbladder lesions is associated with the presence of benign gallbladder diseases, and can be considered a reliable sign of benign gallbladder disease.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Singh VP, "Xanthogranulomatous cholecystitis: what every radiologist should know" 8 : 183-191, 2016

2 Feldman MK, "US artifacts" 29 : 1179-1189, 2009

3 Lafortune M, "The V-shaped artifact of the gallbladder wall" 147 : 505-508, 1986

4 Pattison P, "Sonography of intraabdominal gas collections" 169 : 1559-1564, 1997

5 Raghavendra BN, "Sonography of adenomyomatosis of the gallbladder: radiologic-pathologic correlation" 146 : 747-752, 1983

6 Goldblum JR, "Rosai and Ackerman's surgical pathology" Elsevier 2018

7 Kumar V, "Robbins basic pathology" Elsevier 2018

8 Hwang JI, "Radiologic and pathologic correlation of adenomyomatosis of the gallbladder" 23 : 73-77, 1998

9 Mellnick VM, "Polypoid lesions of the gallbladder: disease spectrum with pathologic correlation" 35 : 387-399, 2015

10 Lee KF, "Polypoid lesions of the gallbladder" 188 : 186-190, 2004

11 Carey MC, "Pathogenesis of gallstones" 165 : 410-419, 1993

12 Van Erpecum KJ, "Pathogenesis of cholesterol and pigment gallstones: an update" 35 : 281-287, 2011

13 Katabi N, "Neoplasia of gallbladder and biliary epithelium" 134 : 1621-1627, 2010

14 Dattal DS, "Morphological spectrum of gall bladder lesions and their correlation with cholelithiasis" 5 : 840-846, 2017

15 Yoshimitsu K, "MR diagnosis of adenomyomatosis of the gallbladder and differentiation from gallbladder carcinoma: importance of showing Rokitansky-Aschoff sinuses" 172 : 1535-1540, 1999

16 Runner GJ, "Gallbladder wall thickening" 202 : W1-W12, 2014

17 Sandri L, "Gallbladder cholesterol polyps and cholesterolosis" 49 : 217-224, 2003

18 Bonatti M, "Gallbladder adenomyomatosis: imaging findings, tricks and pitfalls" 8 : 243-253, 2017

19 Bertrand PB, "Fact or artifact in two-dimensional echocardiography: avoiding misdiagnosis and missed diagnosis" 29 : 381-391, 2016

20 van Breda Vriesman AC, "Diffuse gallbladder wall thickening: differential diagnosis" 188 : 495-501, 2007

21 방상흠, "Differentiating between Adenomyomatosis and Gallbladder Cancer: Revisiting a Comparative Study of High-Resolution Ultrasound, Multidetector CT, and MR Imaging" 대한영상의학회 15 (15): 226-234, 2014

22 Andren-Sandberg A, "Diagnosis and management of gallbladder polyps" 4 : 203-211, 2012

23 Smith EA, "Crosssectional imaging of acute and chronic gallbladder inflammatory disease" 192 : 188-196, 2009

24 Shapiro RS, "Comet-tail artifact from cholesterol crystals:observations in the postlithotripsy gallbladder and an in vitro model" 177 : 153-156, 1990

25 Ching BH, "CT differentiation of adenomyomatosis and gallbladder cancer" 189 : 62-66, 2007

26 Song ER, "CT differentiation of 1-2-cm gallbladder polyps: benign vs malignant" 39 : 334-341, 2014

27 Kim SJ, "Analysis of enhancement pattern of flat gallbladder wall thickening on MDCT to differentiate gallbladder cancer from cholecystitis" 191 : 765-771, 2008