체계적 고찰 방법을 이용한 임상진료지침 정책효과 평가 = Evaluation of the Effect of Clinical Practice Guideline using Systematic Review

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

A systematic review of the literatures was conducted to evaluate the effect of clinical practice guideline. The 77 studies were identified from a computerized search of published research on MEDLINE, Science-Direct and Blackwell synergy from January, 1997 to October, 2007. The main search terms were “clinical practice guideline" and “effectiveness", “clinical practice guideline" and “impact", “clinical practice guideline" and “evaluation". These studies were assessed the quality twice by one qualified expert and converted into weighted scale. The 63 studies were eligible inclusion criteria and subdivided into type of effect. Final indicator using for policy effect of clinical practice guidelines were classified as 4 categories; "improvement of outcomes" in 81 studies, "betterment in practice patterns" in 68 studies, "rationalization in resource utilization" in 84 studies and "cost containment" in 31 studies. The vote-counting method, one of meta-analysis method, was applied to summarized the effect of clinical practice guidelines and test statistically. From results of meta analysis, all indices were statistically significant. In conclusion, this meta-analysis showed that introduction of clinical practice guidelines were resulted positive outcomes in health policy.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최병휘, "천식진료지침 개발 사례" 13 (13): 35-40, 2007

2 유승흠, "진료지침의 개발과 의료의 질" 3 (3): 154-176, 1996

3 이상일, "진료지침의 개념적 이해" 10 (10): 96-101, 2003

4 김수영, "임상진료지침의 번역 혹은 지역 지침 개정" 10 (10): 254-265, 2003

5 신승수, "임상진료지침의 개발" 10 (10): 266-277, 2003

6 박성희, "임상진료지침 개발과정의 장애요인: 심폐소생술을 중심으로" 심폐소생술을 중심으로,한국의료QA학회지,7(1); 46-58 7 (7): 46-58, 2000

7 보건복지부, "임상진료지침 개발 정책모형 수립 및 사례지침 개발연구"

8 김춘배, "우리나라에서의 임상진료지침 개발과 적용방안" 8 (8): 108-132, 2001

9 김남순, "외국의 현황과 국내사례 비교를 통한 임상진료지침 발전방안" 10 (10): 238-252, 2003

10 안경옥, "소아 천식 진료 가이드라인에 대한 인식도 및실제 적용에 대한 조사" 대한 소아알레르기 호흡기학회 12 (12): 201-211, 2002

11 신영수, "병원단위의 임상진료지침 개발과정" 4 (4): 82-108, 1997

12 이선희, "국내 임상진료지침의 개발 및 활용을 위한 정책방향" 13 (13): 9-17, 2007

13 Labarere J, "Validation of a clinical guideline on prevention of venous thromboembolism in medical inpatients: a before-and-after study with systematic ultrasound examination" (256) : 338-348, 2004

14 Guyatt G, "User's guides to the medical literature XXV. Evidence-based medicine: Principles for applying the users' guides to patient care" (284) : 1290-1296, 2000

15 Plaza V, "Usefulness of the guidelines of the Spanish Society of Pulmonology and Thoracic Surgery(SEPAR) in identifying the causes of chronic cough" 42 (42): 68-73, 2006

16 Burgers JS, "Towards evidence-based clinical practice: an international survey of 18 clinical guideline programs" 31-45 15 (15): 31-45, 2003

17 Shrier LA, "Three years of a clinical practice guideline for uncomplicated pelvic Inflammatory disease in adolescents" (27) : 57-62, 2000

18 Cook D, "The trials and tribulations of clinical practice guidelines" 281 (281): 1950-1951, 1999

19 Natsch S, "The role of clinical practice guidelines, policies and stewardship" (53) : 172-176, 2003

20 White V, "The management of early breast carcinoma before and after the introduction of clinical practice guidelines" 101 (101): 476-485, 2004

21 Heinemann AW, "The impact of stroke practice guidelines on knowledge and practice patterns of acute care health professionals" 9 (9): 203-212, 2003

22 Griffiths CEM, "The impact of psoriasis guidelines on appropriateness of referral from primary to secondary care in a randomized controlled trial" (155) : 393-400, 2006

23 Reynolds BC, "The impact of national guidelines on the assessment and management of acute paediatric asthma presenting at a tertiary children's emergency department" (14) : 142-146, 2007

24 Foy R, "The impact of guidelines on mild hypertension in pregnancy in time series analysis" (111) : 765-770, 2004

25 Phillips AW, "The impact of clinical guidelines on surgical management in patients with thyroid cancer" (15) : 485-489, 2003

26 Muntner P, "The impact of JNC-VI guidelines on treatment recommendations in the US population" (39) : 897-902, 2002

27 Silagy CA, "The effectiveness of local adaptation of nationally produced clinical practice guidelines" 19 (19): 223-230, 2002

28 Hepner KA, "The effect of adherence to practice guidelines on depression outcomes" 147 (147): 320-320, 2007

29 Mostafa G, "The economic benefit of practice guidelines for stress ulcer prophylaxis" 68 (68): 146-150, 2002

30 Ahmed KS, "Survey and evaluation of antibiotic prophylaxis usage in surgery wards of tertiar level institution before and after the implementation of clinical guidelines" 150-156 (68) : 150-156, 2006

31 Rizvi F, "Successful reduction of massive postpartum haemorrhage by use of guidelines and staff education" (111) : 495-498, 2004

32 Wennberg JE, "Small area variations in health care delivery" (182) : 1102-8, 1973

33 Patel MR, "Prevalence, predictors, and outcomes of patients with non-ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction and insignificant coronary artery disease: results from the Can Rapid risk stratification of Unstable angina patients Suppress ADverse outcomes with Early implementation of the ACC/AHA Guidelines (CRUSADE) initiative" (152) : 641-647, 2006

34 Coode CJ, "Outcomes from use of an evidence-based practice guideline" 18 (18): 202-207, 2000

35 Shravat BP, "NICE guideline for the management of head injury: an audit demonstrating its impact on a district general hospital, with a cost analysis for England and Wales" (23) : 109-113, 2006

36 Bland DR, "McGann PE" 51 (51): 979-984, 2003

37 Cho MK, "Instruments for assessing the quality of drug studies published in the medical literature" 101-104 272 (272): 101-104, 1994

38 Patel M, "Initial management of candidemia at an academic medical center in Evaluation of the IDSA guideline" (52) : 29-34, 2005

39 Pharm NT, "Improving ACE inhibitor use in patients hospitalized with systolic heart failure: a cluster randomized controlled trial of clinical practice guideline development and use" 9 (9): 373-382, 2003

40 Vikman S, "Improved adherence to practice guidelines yields better outcome in high-risk patients with acute coronary syndrome without ST elevation: findings from nationwide FINACS studies" (256) : 316-323, 2004

41 Bo S, "Implementing hospital guidelines improves warfarin use in non-valvular atrial fibrillation in a before-after study" (7) : 203-, 2007

42 Kalla K, "Implementation of guidelines improves the standard of care in The viennese registry on reperfusion strategies in ST-elevation myocardial infarction" (113) : 2398-2405, 2006

43 Lainscak M, "Implementation of guidelines for management of heart failure in heart failure clinic: effects beyond pharmacological treatment" (97) : 411-416, 2004

44 Jacobs EM, "Impact of the introduction of a guideline on the targeted detection of hereditary haemochromatosis" 63 (63): 205-214, 2005

45 Croudace T, "Impact of the ICD-10 Primary Health Care(PHC) diagnostic and management guidelines for mental disorders on detection and outcome in primary care" 20-30 (182) : 20-30, 2003

46 Mancuso CA, "Impact of new guidelines on physicians' ordering of preoperative tests" (14) : 166-172, 1999

47 Jackson JL, "Impact of national low back pain guidelines on clinical practice" 98 (98): 139-143, 2005

48 Cooney A, "Impact of national guidelines about the management of colorectal cancer on Australian surgeons' awareness of evidence in a pre/post survey" 418-427 (6) : 418-427, 2004

49 Wasserfallen JB, "Impact of medical practice guidelines on the assessment of patients with acute coronary syndrome without persistent ST segment elevation" 16 (16): 383-389, 2004

50 Alerany C, "Impact of local guidelines and an integrated dispensing system on antibiotic prophylaxis quality in a surgical centre" (60) : 111-117, 2005

51 Adam C, "Impact of introducing a sedation management guideline in intensive care" (61) : 260-263, 2006

52 Debrix I, "Impact of guidelines implemented in a Paris university hospital in application to the use of antiemetics by cancer patients" (48) : 616-622, 1999

53 Shrader AJ, "Impact of evidence-based interdisciplinary guidelines on testis cancer management" 106 (106): 313-319, 2006

54 Touzet S, "Impact of consensus development conference guidelines on primary care of bronchiolitis in are national guidelines being followed?" 13 (13): 651-656, 2007

55 Soo Hoo GW, "Impact of clinical guidelines in the management of severe hospital-acquired pneumonia" 128 (128): 2778-2787, 2005

56 Kotagal UR, "Impact of a bronchiolitis guideline in A multisite demonstration project" 121 (121): 1789-1789, 2002

57 Shiliang J, "Impact of Chinese guidelines for management of patients with acute myocardial infarction on outcomes of hospitalized patients" 19 (19): 26-31, 2006

58 Offerhaus P, "Guidelines on anaemia in effect on primary-care midwives in The Netherlands" 204-211 (21) : 204-211, 2005

59 Samain E, "Guidelines for perioperative cardiac evaluation from the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association task force are effective for stratifying cardiac risk before aortic surgery" (31) : 971-979, 2000

60 Micieli G, "Guideline compliance improves stroke outcome in A preliminary study in 4 districts in the Italian Region of Lombardia" (33) : 1341-1347, 2002

61 Dasgupta S, "Evaluation of management of Graves' disease in district general hospital in achievement of consensus guidelines" 1097-1100 59 (59): 1097-1100, 2005

62 Ramsay CR, "Evaluation of clinical guidelines for the management of end-stage renal disease in Europe in the EU BIOMED 1 Study" (15) : 1394-1398, 2000

63 Sinuff T, "Evaluation of a practice guideline for noninvasive positive-pressure ventilation for acute respiratory failure" 123 (123): 2062-2062, 2003

64 Goolsby MJ, "Evaluating and applying practice guidelines" 13 (13): 3-6, 2001

65 Daly C,Clements F,Lopez-Sedon JL,Tavazzi L,Boersma E,Danchin N, "European heart journal" 1298-1304 2006

66 Partridge CA, "Effects of a reduced-visit prenatal care clinical practice guideline" 18 (18): 555-560, 2005

67 Ward MM, "Effectiveness of a nationally implemented smoking cessation guideline on provider and patient practice" (36) : 265-271, 2003

68 Bekkering GE, "Effect on the process of care of an active strategy to implement clinical guidelines on physiotherapy for low back pain: a cluster randomized controlled trial" 14 (14): 107-112, 2005

69 Tomas LH, "Effect of clinical guidelines in nursing, midwifery, and the therapies: a systematic review of evaluation" (7) : 183-191, 1998

70 Williams A, "Effect of a new guideline on outcome following third-degree perineal tears: results of a 3-year audit" 385-389 (14) : 385-389, 2003

71 Suwanrath-Kengpol C, "Effect of a clinical practice guideline on physician compliance" 16 (16): 327-332, 2004

72 Gerson LB, "Effect and outcomes of the ASGE guidelines on the periendoscopic management of patients who take anticoagulants" (95) : 1717-1724, 2000

73 Quaglini S, "Economic benefit from clinical practice guideline compliance in stroke patient management" (69) : 305-315, 2004

74 Humphreys K, "Does following research-derived practice guidelines improve opiate-dependent patient's outcomes under everyday practice conditions? Results of the multisite opiate substitution treatment study" (11) : 1-7, 2007

75 Katz DA, "Does concordance with guideline triage recommendations affect clinical care of patients with possible acute coronary syndrome" (27) : 423-437, 2007

76 Lesho EP, "Do clinical practice guidelines improve processes or outcomes in primary care" 170 (170): 243-246, 2005

77 Smink DS, "Diagnosis of acute appendicitis in Children using a clinical practice guideline" (39) : 458-463, 2004

78 MacCarty CA, "Diabetic retinopathy: effects of national guidelines on the referral, examination and treatment practices of ophthalmologist and optometrists" 52-58 (29) : 52-58, 2001

79 Guterman SJ, "Cost-effective medicine in The financial impact that practice guidelines have on outpatient hospital charges in the emergency department" 16 (16): 215-219, 1998

80 Lankveld MAV, "Compliance to surgical and radiation treatment guidelines in relation to patient outcome in early stage endometrial cancer" 12 (12): 196-201, 2006

81 Agthoven MV, "Compliance and efficiency before and after implementation of a clinical practice guideline for laryngeal carcinomas" 729-737 (263) : 729-737, 2006

82 Iliadis EA, "Clinical practice guidelines in unstable angina improve clinical outcomes by assuring early intensive medical treatment" 34 (34): 1689-1895, 1999

83 Deutsch S, "Clinical practice guidelines in A tool to help provide quality care" 53 (53): 57-75, 1998

84 Field MJ, "Clinical Practice Guideline in Directions for an New Program" National Academy Press 1990

85 Martelli A, "Brambilla. Guidelines for clinical use of albumin: comparison of use in two Italian hospitals and a third hospital without guidelines" 64 (64): 676-684, 2003

86 McWhirter E, "Baseline radiological staging in primary breast cancer in impact of educational interventions on adherence to published guidelines. Journal of evaluation in clinical practice" 13 (13): 647-650, 2007

87 Keris valdis, "Association between implementation of clinical practice guidelines and outcome for traumatic brain injury" (31) : 1352-1355, 2007

88 Jadad JA, "Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary" (17) : 1-12, 1996

89 Leinwand MJ, "Application of the APSA evidence-based for isolated liver or spleen injuries in A single institution experience" 39 (39): 487-490, 2004

90 Kievit W, "Annals of Oncology" (16) : 1874-1881, 2005

91 Watts DD, "An evaluation of the use of guidelines in prehospital management of brain injury" 8 (8): 254-261, 2004

92 Froelich JB, "American college of cardiology/American heart association preoperative assessment guidelines reduce resource utilization before aortic surgery" 36 (36): 758-763, 2002

93 Grimshaw J, "Achieving health gain through clinical guidelines Ⅰin Developing scientifically valid guidelines" (2) : 243-248, 1993

94 Kocher MS, "A clinical practice guideline for treatment of septic arthritis in children" 85 (85): 994-999, 2003