보수체계의 유형이 조직의 업무성과에 미치는 영향 = The Influence of the Type of Compensation Scheme on Work Performance of Organizations

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 논문은 팀 조직의 구성원들에게 보상을 제공하는 세 가지 방식,즉 개인별,팀별,그리고 혼합 보상체계의 상대적 성과를 현장실험을 이용해 실증적으로 분석한다.현장실험의 결과에 따르면,세 가지 보상체계 간에 존재하는 평균성과의 차이는 통계적으로 유의하지 않다.그러나 개인별 보상체계와 비교할 때,팀별 체계와 혼합 체계는 참여자가 극단적으로 낮은 성과를 낼 가능성을 유의하게 낮춘다.그러나 탁월하게 높은 성과를 유도할 가능성의 측면에서 세 보상체계는 큰 차이를 보이지 않는다.이로부터 우리는 팀별 보상체계의 중요한 역할은 최상의 성과를 유도하는 것이라기보다는 최악의 실패를 막는 것이라는 점을 유추할 수 있다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper considers three types of compensation schemes for team members’ work performance: individual-based, team-based, and mixed compensation. To empirically analyze teams’ relative performance under each compensation scheme, we conduct a field experiment. The result shows that there is no statistically significant difference in the average performance under each scheme. However, compared with individual-based compensation, the team-based and the mixed compensation scheme significantly lower the possibility of extremely poor performance. On the other hand, the three compensation schemes do not lead to any significant difference in the possibility of excellent performance. Based on these results, we conclude that the crucial role played by the team-based compensation scheme is to prevent the worst failure, rather than induce the best outcome.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김세움, "공공부문 경쟁 인센티브의 유형과 조직성과" 한국노동연구원 2013

2 Hansen, Daniel, "Worker Performance and Group Incentives : A Case Study" 51 : 37-49, 1997

3 Sinclair, A.L., "The effects of justice and cooperation on team effectiveness" 43 : 74-100, 2003

4 Newhouse, Joseph, "The Economics of Group Practice" 8 : 37-56, 1973

5 Rack, Oliver, "Team-based Rewards in Computer-mediated Groups" 26 (26): 419-438, 2011

6 Dematteo, Jacquelyn S., "Team-Based Rewards : Current Empirical Evidence and Directions for the Future Research" 20 : 141-183, 1998

7 Hamilton, Barton H., "Team Incentives and Worker Heterogeneity : An Empirical Analysis of the Impact of Teams on Productivity and Participation" 111 : 465-497, 2003

8 Dawes, R.M., "Socialdilemmas" 31 : 169-193, 1980

9 Sniezek, J.A., "Social uncertainty and interdependence—A study of resource allocation decisions in groups" 46 : 155-180, 1990

10 Irlenbusch, Bernd, "Relative Rewards with in Team-based Compensation" 15 : 141-167, 2008

11 Nalbantian, Haig R., "Productivity under Group Incentives : An Experimental Study" 87 : 314-341, 1997

12 Alchian, A., "Production, Information Costs, and Economic Organization" 62 : 777-795, 1972

13 Shaw, J.D., "Pay dispersion and work force performance : Moderating effects of incentives and inter dependence" 23 : 491-512, 2002

14 Boning, Brent, "Opportunity Counts : Teams and the Effectiveness of Production Incentives" NBER 2001

15 Angrist, Joshua D., "Mostly Harmless" Princeton University Press 2009

16 Holmström, Bengt, "MoralHazardsin Teams" 13 : 324-340, 1982

17 Gaynor, Martin, "Moral Hazard and Risk Spreading in Medical Partnerships" 26 : 591-613, 1995

18 Barnes, C. M., "Mixing Individual Incentives and Group Incentives : Best of Both Worldsor Social Dilemma?" 37 (37): 1611-1635, 2011

19 Wageman, R., "Interdependence and group effectiveness" 40 : 145-180, 1995

20 Mitchell, T.R., "Individual and group goals when workers are inter dependent—Effects on task strategies and performance" 75 : 185-193, 1990

21 Barnes C. M., "Harmfulhelp : The costs of backing up behavior inteams" 93 : 529-539, 2008

22 List, John, "Hand book of Labor Economics, Vol.4A, Ch.2" Elsevier 103-228, 2011

23 Rosenbaum, Milton E., "Group Productivity and Process : Pure and Mixed Reward Structures and Task Interdependence" 39 : 626-642, 1980

24 Welbourne, T.M., "Gainsharing—A critical-review and afuture-research agenda" 21 : 559-609, 1995

25 Leibowitz, Arleen, "Free Riding, Shirking, and Team Production in Legal Partnerships" 18 : 380-394, 1990

26 Bandiera, Oriana, "Field Experiments with Firms" 25 (25): 63-82, 2011

27 Kozlowski, S.W.J., "Enhancing the effectiveness of work groupsand teams" 7 : 77-124, 2006

28 Beersma B., "Cooperation, competition, and team performance : Toward a contingency approach" 46 : 572-590, 2003

29 Heneman, R.L., "Balancing group and individual rewards : Rewarding individual contributions to the team" 274 : 63-68, 1995

30 Quigley, N.R., "A multilevel investigation of the motivational mechanisms underlying knowledge sharingand performance" 18 : 71-88, 2007

31 Pruitt, D.G., "20 years of experimental gaming—Critique, synthesis, and suggestions for future" 28 : 363-392, 1977